I agree with you on raising the efficiency of the otto cycle with out
some sort of energy recovery from the exhaust to 45%. If it was that
easy it would have been done years ago. Ceramic engines were tried
years ago.
Here is what I am talking about-It does not matter if you put a blowdown
turbine on this engine. this is for an ideal full expansion-all the
available energy to work engine-you cannot improve it. There is a certain
amount of unrecoverable waste energy. Physics period. Not open to debate,
this has been proven tested over and over. Please get a thermo text and read
the section on the second law and available energy.
Having said that the real hardware is not the same as the theoretical cycle.
It is very difficult to design a practical engine to match the theory and
even if you do it will not operate at that point most of the time. This is
the only reason that turbochargers and blow down turbines work. If you could
make the engine a variable volume device you could just maintain the ideal
cycle at all power levels. My point I am trying to get across is at part
throttle the engine is closer to the ideal cycle on EXPANSION. And this is
what is important. Energy content, kinetic, thermal, pressure, magnetic,
electrical, chemical are all the same, and can be converted (imperfectly)
through nozzles, diffusers, turbines, compressors, motors, generators, fuel
cells, combustion chambers. What combination and how these are hooked
together is really irrelevant to the maximum work you can get out of
something. You have so much energy to work with between two states-period.
If the exhaust gas is expanded to near atmospheric pressure it does not
matter what the temperature is. That temperature is unrecoverable energy
from the standpoint of doing useful work with an expansion device (turbine,
or Otto type cycle). There is NO pressure to convert to kinetic energy in
the NGV of the turbine. There is nothing more useless than low pressure hot
air. To recover the energy contained in the air as heat, you will have to
switch cycles, or working fluids, or both.
Think about this-The old VW's used an exhaust gas heat exchanger to heat the
cab-it was incapable of heating or defrosting the cabin effectively, ever
seen the water dripping out of a tail pipe? There is not even enough energy
in there to keep the water vaporized through the exhaust system-8 hp? I
don't think so.
That is why I said to measure the state of the exhaust gas. If you know how
much energy it contains and what state it is at you can calculate what the
best energy recovery possible is. Then figure out if it is worth it. The
graph of the energy content is not the information you need, you need to
know the STATE of the energy relative to your rejection state.
You could use a Stirling engine, or closed Brayton bottoming cycle scheme.
There are Stirling engines that will run on an ice cube, or a hot cup of
coffee but produce hardly any useable work. I assure you if it were
plausible, easy and economically viable for an automobile there would be
people all over it. If you think a radiator for a car is big now, try
putting a bottoming cycle on it. That is one of the reasons the Otto cycle
works so well in cars and aircraft, most of the waste heat is rejected in
the exhaust, try rejecting it just through a radiator and see how big,
heavy, expensive, and draggy it gets.
Personally I think that the current level of 30% efficient relative to 60%
theoretical is pretty damn good. It is going to be impossible to get that
last half economically. Trying to get another 10% will require a Herculean
effort, 15% in the next 7 years-I don't think so.
If you want this to work, try this-run the engine on LPG. Put the LPG
through a heat exchanger downstream of the recovery turbine. This will cool
the exhaust gas and drop the pressure, using the latent heat of vaporization
of the LPG, and increase the amount of kinetic energy you can produce for
the turbine. Keep in mind you are not dropping the pressure below
atmospheric pressure, you are just reducing the volume of the exhaust gas to
allow more expansion across the turbine by removing heat, your exhaust pipe
will now be ridiculously small.
Then inject the hot (not too hot or it will dissociate) propane gas directly
into the engine diesel style so you don't ruin the volumetric efficiency of
the engine. This is thermodynamically a sound way to do things-technically
difficult. You have changed the rejection state of the exhaust stream, and
put the energy back into the combustion stage of the otto cycle.
Even this may not be practical.
The point is there are limitations on what can be accomplished that are
based on the cycle and fuels used, and no matter what you do with the
hardware, you are stuck with these limitations. At some point PRACTICAL
increases in efficiency require new technology. You can't go to the moon on
a skate board, no matter what kind of wheels, bearings, or fairings you put
on it, what kind of steroids you take, how big a hill you go down, or what
type of ramp you use.
It is still a skate board.
Monty
Not to worry Doug. He is not talking about an aircraft turbo compound.
He is talking about a 240 HP rotary engine operating at 40 shaft HP and trying
to get an additional 8 HP out of the 50 HP worth of waste heat still in the exhaust.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.