A bullet moving through a vacuum has no pressure until it impacts
something. Yet it still has kinetic energy. M x V^2 An internal
combustion
engine
is similar to a gun. An exhaust port opening into an exhaust pipe,
which
initially is at atmospheric pressure, imparts kinetic energy to the
exhaust
gas molecules and all the molecules in the exhaust pipe. This results
in
a sensible increase in pressure in that that part of the exhaust pipe
due
to the static inertia of the molecules. At the other end of the
exhaust
pipe, which
is open to the atmosphere, the pressure is the same as the atmosphere.
Yet
the exhaust gas molecules now have kinetic energy minus the heat lost
through
conduction to the exhaust pipe itself. They are now capable of
imparting
that energy to a turbine by impacting the blades. The question remains
how big of a turbine?
Paul Lamar
pressure moves the gas through the pipe period. Is this not your
argument
for larger runners and less back pressure, and better breathing? from
whence
does this energy come? Why does an IC engine benefit from a decrease in
back
pressure? greater expansion. IF you insist on using the engine as a pump
to
drive the turbine it is simply the dog chasing its tail.
What causes the kinetic energy of this mythical bullet? combustion of a
propellant, and subsequent expansion (like a piston, or rotor)
EXPANSION!
Back pressure is a loss! not something to be desired. Negative work is
required to move the exhaust gas to the end of the tail pipe. Chop it
off
and you can expand to a lower state and make more power.
I am going to modify your bullet in a vacuum by placing it in the
atmosphere, because that is where we are operating, not in a vacuum.
Using
your analogy of the bullet and the gun what you are suggesting is to
take
and place a washer over the end of the barrel with a small hole in it.
connect a large piston to the bullet and duct air from in front of the
bullet to the back of said piston. The idea is you will take energy from
the
compressed air in front of the bullet an put into the bullet as it
accelerates down the barrel. The fallacy is the energy to compress the
air
in front of the bullet comes from the expansion of the combustion and
you
cannot do anything with the excess energy from the explosion. Now if you
could somehow connect the front of the piston to a vacuum source it
would
work. But we are stuck discharging to the atmosphere. In a vacuum there
is
no lower state to even make this work. The rejection state relative to
the
state of the exhaust gas in the manifold is key.
I have no argument against a turbocompound aircraft engine.
Monty
Residual pressure in the exhaust chamber accelerates the gas molecules
down the exhaust pipe when the port opens. The pressures is totally
converted
to kinetic energy at the end of the pipe. If the absolute pressure in the
exhaust pipe is higher there will be less acceleration.
I already mentioned the air molecules in the pipe reducing the
acceleration
of the exhaust gas molecules. We are in total agreement on this.
A radial inflow turbine results in higher back pressure I think. The
residual pressure in the exhaust chamber results in negative work on the
e-shaft.
If the back pressure is high this delays the mitigation of the residual
pressure increasing the negative work on the e-shaft. We are in total
agreement on this too.
I don't have a lot of data on the radial inflow turbine yet but when I
get a chance to go to UCLA I have a few good references to look up.
There are two kinds of axial flow turbines. Impulse
type and the pressure type. According to NACA Report 786 no significant
back
pressure was measured upstream of the axial flow turbine. I suspect NACA
was
using the impulse type.
I agree we need numbers. All of this is speculation without the numbers.
Here is what we know so far:
We know there is 50 HP worth of BTU's in the exhaust of a 240 HP rotary
engine
generating 40 HP at part throttle.
We know a turbo charger will generate some boost pressure at that HP
level.
We know it takes HP to generate boost pressure. Obviously there is some
kinetic or pressure energy in there or the turbo charger would not spin.
We also can hear the exhaust and noise takes HP to generate.
Here are some of the things we don't know yet:
We don't know how much is kinetic energy, pressure energy or is just plain
heated gas at atmospheric pressure.
Paul Lamar
The useful energy in the exhaust is no where near the 50HP worth of BTU's
The exhaust gas velocity
is a total pressure, and it got that by the exhaust stroke using work to
push the gases out. Even perfect
recovery expansion will not harness as much power as you are anticipating.
If you look at
PV diagram for the Otto cycle at part power, you will see that that big drop
at the bottom of
the expansion stroke has almost disapeared. The only amount of theoretical
work that is
available is the tiny triangle area that you would get extrapolating that
expansion to ambient
pressure. I fear that Monty has a much better grasp of the thermodynamics
and gas dynamics
of these cases than you - sorry Paul, de debbil made me do it. - Vance
I am sure he does but I am not willing to give up just yet.
So in your opinion it is impossible to recover 2/3rd of the heat in a
gallon of gas? Only one third can be recovered? What do you suggest?
Switching to 60% efficient combined cycle gas turbines in our cars.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.