....sniped
Mazda has the technology to make this work at low cost. It would be a
piece of cake
for Mazda and probably cost far less than a hybrid. Beside that there are
no expensive
nickel metal hydride batteries to replace every several years.
Electric turbo compounding is not worth it. By the time you convert
mechanical energy from the blow down turbine to electrical energy, charge
batteries
and than convert it back to mechanical energy you are down to 60 or 70% of
20% or
12 or 14%. Not worth the extra weight and expenses of all the electrical
stuff and the batteries required. Just like a current hybrid is not worth
it.
Paul Lamar
...sniped
Paul don't forget that nothing comes for free and/or overnight.
Hybrid or Electro technology may not be the real thing yet, but if the
companies don't try it will never be. They also need to get this emerging
technology to the consumer somehow to spark some interest at least.
Just take the Rotary as an example. Don't want to know how many people said
that the Wankel is no good for everyday driving if you have the engine
expire every 30 thousand km. That was at least one reason for NSU to expire.
But if wouldn't have been for the few "diehards" who kept buying NSU/Ro
cars, the ROtary wouldn't have made it to sofistication and the market.
I consider todays hybrid/electro buyers "diehards". As it was with the Ro80,
not even everybody could afford that car, less yet to maintain it....
If it wouldn't have been for the tenacidy of Mazda to keep going after NSU's
demise, there would be no Rotaries in todays live.
Sooner or later even the Rotary will be gone and everybody will be floating
around on a energyfield powered from some powercells!
Oooops, just got of Star Trek "Enterprise".........:)
Thomas J.
There is a difference between the Wankel and a hybrid. The hybrid depends
on several conversions of energy while the ICE is a lot more straight
forward.
Any time you convert energy from one form to another there are losses.
Hybrids are intrinsically complicated because they have at least two kinds
of prime movers. Furthermore they rely on battery technology.
Battery technology is not advancing very fast if at all yet it has been
around for well over 100 years. Electric cars were popular in the early days
of automobiles and they had about the same range as today's electric cars.
It will be very very difficult to replace the car as we know it in anybody's
lifetime reading this. The hybrid will eventually die when its drawbacks
are finally fully realized.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Actually they will finally die when fuel cells become cheaper. BTW a recent
breakthrough allows some F.C.s to run directly on ethanol now. That had been
a stumbling block for years. Sure the energy density in the fuel itself is
not as great as gasoline but the 'invested energy' (energy required to
produce, transport etc.) is almost half of gasoline and getting less all the
time as factory start using co-generation techniques and micro burst
technology on common things like cellulose.
Energy storage devices will get better as more nanotechnology is applied.
Cheers
Doug in Japan
When I was in college electronic engineers looked down on mechanical engineers :)
True electronics has made amazing strides in the last 25 years.
I am still betting on the ICE and crude oil as we know it :)
The real price of crude long term is still going down. Iraq is sitting
on the second largest known reserves of crude next to Saudi Arabia and
they have just scratched the surface of production.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.