| Subject: Refurbished 13B rotor housings |
| From: ACRE |
| Date: 3/18/2005, 12:47 PM |
| CC: Dave Lemon |
Brett & Tiana wrote: I've just checked out the website of a Winnipeg, Manitoba rotaryengine performance shop called JHB Performance. The link is http://www.jhbperformance.comThey specialize in refurbishing otherwise unuseable rotor housings(assuming they're not warped) by applying a "Cermet" coating, supposedly the same stuff used in the engine of the Lemans4-rotor. It first I thought they meant ceramic, but apparently this stuffcontains a carbide substance with a softer matrix material holding it together. They also re-do end and intermediate housings androtors. Their durability claims sound encouraging but maybe, shall wesay, "optimistic."My question is, has anybody on here actually used these housings andif so, how are they holding up? This would be valuable info because the latest word (at least according to the RX7 enthusiastrumor mill) is that Mazda intends to discontinue production of 12Aand 13B rotor housings to free up production space and tooling for more efficient Renesis engine production. May be just arumor but if not, the refurbishing option is looming large--- especiallysince their current prices appear to be half what Mazda is asking for a new housing.Ian wrote: the FD3S rx7 was produced till 02' in Japan, Mazda has at least 10 yearsworth of support for that car, I also just bought a new 13BT housing with no problems and my mazda rep said nothing aboutshutdowns in the BT line ( which would be the most likely candidate forretooling. ). (Killing off a 13B housing line over in Japan would be similar to retooling a SBC plant here.). Right now an rx7owner in Calgary I believe, has had the coating done to a pair of his BThousings. The general impressions were good however during JBH dressing it seems that some of the coating edges were chippedoff, JBH redid the housings at no charge, the dressing seems to also tobe cross hatched as well. The fellow said this process is still ' under development' for JBH, but he is going to be trying itout this year. ian BAS
-Brett & Tiana wrote:
I am aware of the guy in Calgary and his experience thus far. I'm also in Calgary but I don't know him personally. I may have to see if I can meet up with him to view these housings, if he hasn't already began re-assembling his engine. For the record, the info about Mazda allegedly discontinuing peripheral exhaust port housings came from a thread in the Canadian forum section of the main RX7 club forum titled "Mazda Canada parts availability" and is located on the last page or so of the thread. Apparently Mazda has just informed members of the SCCA (a Canadian racing entity) that production of these housings is to be discontinued effective immediately.
If that SCCA is the Sport Car Club of America we have them down here too. I find that hard to believe. They may discontinue making them available in North America as they can do that legally. I don't know the laws in Australia but 3rd gen. were imported up to 1998 and as he says sold up to 2002 in Japan. It does not make good sense to stop production. I'll check with Dave Lemon at Mazdatrix this afternoon. BTW rotor housing coatings other than detonation gun application has brought more than one company to it knees. Unless it is applied with a detonation gun I would stay away from them. Paul Lamar The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ Copyright 1998-2004 All world wide rights reserved.
|
A-Flame Corporation
8175 Kroger Farm Road, Cincinnati, OH 45243-1639 USA Tel 1-513-831-4284 Fax 1-513-831-5237
E-Mail: detonation@aflame.com
You Can Have It,
Too!
The gas detonation coating process is a spraying method aimed at creating a new technological generation of production coatings, or the production of bulk component parts, made from powders. The above images show the flow of detonation products from the Detonation Gun barrel. Four photographs are taken with a 50-microsecond interval between each. This illustrates the ultra-fast nature of the detonation process.
The
deposition of coatings is done, by using the energy of the detonation
(explosion) of gaseous mixtures to achieve powder acceleration. The
effect of gas detonation results in a premium coating quality, the lowest
substrate temperature, and a very economical, and safe manufacturing
operation. The patented design of the Detonation Gun, uses the gasses'
dynamic effects, to prevent a backflash during detonation, which eliminates
the need for mechanical valves, makes the apparatus extremely simple
and reliable, while substantially raising the operational frequency
and productivity. This process uses a wide variety of fuel gases, including
propane, methane, and natural gas.
Main Control Console Gas and Water
Control Unit
This process is capable of producing
coatings of the following metals: (Al, Zn, Cu, Fe, Ti, V, Co, Ni, etc.),
oxides (Al2O3, Cr2O3, MgAI2O4, TiO2, etc.), carbides (WC, Cr3C2, 91WC-9Co,
85Cr3C2 - 15[Ni-Cr], etc.), alloys (2OCr-8ONi, 30Al-O.2Fe-69, 8NI, 53Nb-47Ti,
etc.) and compounds (lOONi [B, A], etc.) on various metal, dielectric
and plastic substrates; including glass, ceramics, etc. The characteristic
value of adhesion is as high as a measured 36,250 psi, porosity <1%,
layer thickness is unlimited, deposition efficiency up to 80%, substrate
temperature during deposition 200-1500 C.
Advantages Of Gas Detonation Coating Technology
Gas detonation is capable of producing the highest pressure, velocity, and density in the gas flow, which is not achievable by all other spraying techniques. As a result, the detonation coatings are characterized by extremely high density, microhardness, and low porosity, and are suitable for applications requiring very high standards, such as aircraft engine components. An example would be production of WC-9Co coatings on the high strength alloy gears of turbines, for helicopter engines, with 0.3% porosity, 250 MPa adhesion and 1392 HV average microhardness. This allowed a 7-fold increase in the operational lifetime of this part.
A great variety of materials can be sprayed by using the detonation technology and a broad selection of base substrates can be coated. In addition to premium coating quality, the use of the gas detonation coating process, provides the following benefits:
- Low Substrate Temperature: Due to the intermittent nature of the process, the amount of heat transferred to the substrate stays very low. The substrate temperature, during spraying, does not exceed 150 C and can be maintained at room temperature, if necessary. This makes possible the spraying of precision components such as crankshafts, or turbine blades, without the danger of causing thermal deformations, or chemical changes. It is also possible to spray low melting point materials, such as plastics.
- No Use of Nitrogen: The use of Nitrogen changes the properties of the detonation wave, particularly its velocity, degrading the quality of the coating. This new gas supply system completely excludes the use of Nitrogen, as a protective gas. A significant feature is that the gases are fed continuously into the combustion chamber and backfiring is prevented by the special design of the gas supply unit. This eliminates the need for a buffer gas, as well as mechanically moving valves in the gas supply system, making the process much simpler and more reliable.
- Low Cost of Operation: The manufacturing experience of our customers, demonstrates that the use of the detonation coating process, in production, is very cost-effective; and, it results in substantial operational and maintenance cost reductions, as compared to the typical HVOF and plasma spray systems. This is due to the following five principle factors:
Less Gas Used: A high-pressure fuel and oxygen supply is not needed. The gases are fed into the combustion chamber at low pressure, slightly exceeding atmospheric pressure. The total amount of gases consumed, per unit mass of powder sprayed, is about 10 times less than the typical HVOF system.
Less Water Consumed: Due to the low amount of heat transferred to the gun barrel, a special cooling system is not needed. Water consumption is very low.
Less Electrical Energy Consumption: Very effective electric power consumption - the unit consumes a total of 200W of electrical power, which is comparable to a regular electric bulb. A water chiller is not needed, which requires a lot of electricity.
Less Downtime: The process is very simple to operate and very reliable. There are literally no components that can wear out, similar to Laval nozzle in the HVOF gun.
Less Scrap: There are no nozzles that can melt, or disintegrate, and spit copper on the expensive part being sprayed.
The gun barrel can be mounted at any angle, or can be fixed in the arm of a robot-manipulator. Multiple gun barrels can be installed to satisfy process requirements for high volume.
The gun design allows you to use the
same unit as a grit blaster, without modifications of the barrel, or
the gas supply system. This eliminates the need for a separate grit
blasting booth, and it allows for a combination of surface grit blasting
and further spraying, in one continuous operation.
COMPARISONS OF DIFFERENT METHODS OF THERMAL SPRAY
Type of System
|
Flame or Plasma Exit Temperature ( 0C) |
Heat Transfer to Substrate ( 0C ) |
Particle Impact Velocity (M/S) |
Oxide Content ( % ) |
Porosity
( % ) |
Adhesion (Bond Strength) |
Detonation Gun |
3000 |
20-150 MAX |
800-1000 |
0.1 |
0.1 - I |
Extremely high |
Plasma Jet (HVOF) |
2500-3100 |
500-700 |
500-800 |
0.2 |
1 - 10 |
Very High |
Plasma Spraying |
5500-8300 |
700-1000 |
200-600 |
0.1-1 |
1 - 10 |
Very High |
Wire Arc |
4000-6000 |
500-800 |
240 |
0.5-3 |
10-20 |
High |
Flame Spraying |
2500-3000 |
500-700 |
30-180 |
4-6 |
10-30 |
Low |
These are generic examples - your exact results will depend on spray duration, spray distance, process settings, and the substrate material
For More Information, please phone, fax, or e-mail
a note of inquiry to:
A-Flame Corporation
8175 Kroger Farm Road, Cincinnati, OH 45243-1639 USA Tel 1-513-831-4284 Fax 1-513-831-5237
E-Mail: detonation@aflame.com