If you don't have room in the back seat area put the
the sumps behind the firewall as in this 3D
The return fuel is precisely the problem and MUST be returned
to ONLY the tank you are drawing fuel from. Not the sump tank or
tanks under any circumstances. There is no other choice but to
use a double level left and right fuel tank selector. Is your life
worth
20 feet of 1/2 inch aluminum tube or not? Apparently John Denver did
not think so.
If you think there is a better way of doing it send me a sketch.
I am open to suggestions.
Paul Lamar
==============================================
First Paul what you are advocating will kill people;
-"The return fuel is precisely the problem and MUST be returned to
ONLY the tank you are drawing fuel from. Not the sump tank or tanks
under any circumstances"-
Even if you return the fuel to the tank that feeds the sump you are
drawing from, the fuel injection pump(s) will pump the fuel through
the fuel rail, the regulator will bypass the excess and what little
fuel you had in your sump will now be in your fuel tank, the sump
will be empty because the flow from the supply tank to the sump
cannot keep up with the pump recirculating it into the tanks. NOT a
good idea.
Second, references to John Denvers death had nothing to do with this
unless you are opportunistically using it to emotionally charge the
topic.
...Chrissi
www.CozyGirrrl.com <http://www.cozygirrrl.com/>
Cozy Mk-IV RG 13B-turbo
Plans #957 Chapter? big pieces done, details, details
Nonsense and I think you know it. It depends on the size of the line
gravity feeding the sump tank. To give you a ridicules example suppose the
line feeding the sump was two inches in ID? If the engine is burning 10
gallons an
hour and the size of the line feeding the sump tank can't flow twenty
gallons
an hour under gravity alone the line is a very small line indeed.
Furthermore you
are forgetting to evaluate the rate of flow through the small return line
from
the pressure regulator which is now under atmospheric pressure alone.
Or slightly above it at the pressure regulator end.
John Denvers crash has a lot to do with pusher fuel systems in general.
Have you read the NTSB report?
I am sorry I don't like your unique system and I hurt your ego. Please
take
up another hobby or use a different engine if you can't discuss this
in an objective and rational way.
Paul Lamar
I don't want to add fuel to the fire, but would like to post a simple
observation.
Our R-44 helicopters have the simplest fuel system ever:
Aux-Tank drains into the main tank - main tank gravity feeds through a
shut-off valve ( which normaly stays open at all times) and a gascolator to
the carb.
Our ( and customer helicopters) have colors ranging from white over silver
to dark blue and green - yellow. Basically the whole spectrum.
In my location daylight temps range from 24ºC to 40ºC as indicated by the
OAT gauge.
Now here it comes: Under these conditions, no matter the color, tha tanks
are sometimes so hot to the touch that you cannot maintain your hand on
them. (Not just after heatsoaking on the ramp but also after flights)
Draining fuel always shows fairly cool fuel until the fuelline fills with
fuel from the tank - it is hot!
So fuel temp shouldn't be the worst of concerns!
I would not put too much attention on wether to return to the tank in use or
the headertank, BUT to:
a) headertank (if used), sufficiently big and deep to stay at least 3/4 full
at the worst
b) good vent-line so vapor-bubbles can escape
c) good (high) flow in the HP system (headertank forward) to constantly
purge any possible vapor
d) design HP routing so that vapor can easily move up-wards.
Chrissi,
I see your point, but you assume you know when things will go wrong. You
probably wont until your sump is dry anyway.
What I mean is (if I read you right...), you say with return fuel in the
sump instead of the tank you will have more "emergency time" to play with,
right?
Well, when and how to you figure out that the tank doesn't feed the sump
anymore?
If I ever get to it (...building something flyable with a Rotary), my fuel
system will be able to fill the sump in no time (by gravity or pump...),
which probably means huge fuel lines - 1/2" or even 5/8". So if these lines
ever get plugged I will not know until the sump is dry - it only will be a
little later if I return to the sump instead of the tank. Time of incident
will be academic only...
I wouldn't say that Paul's system is advocating to kill people. Until
recently that was the way to go in cars.
Only cars don't have header tanks, ....as far as I know.
FWIW,
Thomas Jakits
PS: Until monday I will look up the fuel system of the new fuel injected
R-44, but as far as I understand this system only provides pressure to the
injector pump and if there is any return it only goes to the pump intakes (1
engine driven, 1 electric - always on)
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.