Dear Mr. Boyer
Haines's weight for the Mazda rotary is way off to the point
of slander. The firewall forward weight is 325 pounds. The same
as an aircraft IO-360 engine it replaces. The bare engine weight
is under 200 pounds despite many cast iron parts.
We have dozens of airplanes flying with Mazda rotaries
requiring no ballast in the tail.
For a list of those flying and building goto:
http://members.aol.com/rotaryroster/index.html?f=fs
Tracy Crook's RV4 went 217 MPH in the 2004 Sun 100 cross country race
with well over 500 hours on the engine. Look it up.
The total cost for a brand new Mazda RX8 engine and all the other
parts you need for an aircraft application is one third to one half what
an aircraft engine would cost. Overhaul cost is less than $3,000.
Also the Mazda rotary, unlike most car engines, will run almost forever
at full power. Nobody flying one has worn one out yet.
The turbo adds about 50 pounds and not 150 pounds.
Check out our web site below for a video of a turbo rotary
powered RV6. http://www.rotaryeng.net
BTW Mistral is copying the Mazda design for a certified rotary
aircraft engine. http://www.mistral-engines.com/testing.htm
I hope you will publish a retraction soon.
Paul Lamar
Mr. Lamar,
Thanks very much for your comments and for sharing your expertise. Phil
Boyer asked that I respond to your comments.
My intent in the two paragraphs where I mention Mazda rotary engines was
not to denigrate rotary engines. They certainly have a place in many
applications, including in some airplanes. The weight I quoted was from
an article we ran a number or years ago that compared the TSIO-360 to a
Mazda conversion. I assume your weight includes the gearbox and as you
note, the turbo adds additional weight. My note about 150 pounds was not
for just the turbo, but the gear box, accessories, plumbing, etc. We'll
look into it and if the total is incorrect, we'll run a correction.
I'm happy to hear of your successes in installing rotary engines in
kitbuilt airplanes, something that has been happening for the last 20
years or so. However, as a believer in a free market economy I have to
believe that if automobile engine conversions were a viable alternative
for airplanes, particularly production airplanes, which is the primary
target of our editorial, we would have seen a ground swell of support
for those installations over the last two decades.
I have heard from two AOPA members about an RV owner in Texas who has
1,400 hours on his rotary-powered airplane. He is held up as proof that
the concept works. But if that is the high-time airplane after all of
these years, then I still have to wonder about the value proposition for
such a conversion.
Phil and I were briefed about five years ago on the Mistral engine by
representatives of the company. At that time, they were expecting
certification in a few months. As you note, certification is not
complete yet. The current schedule is for 2007. We have reported on the
project numerous times.
I appreciate you updating us on the status of some of the rotary
conversions flying and will certainly keep your comments in mind as we
look at engine technology in future issues of "AOPA Pilot." And I thank
you again for taking the time to write. We may use a portion of your
letter in the magazine.
Sincerely,
--Tom Haines, AOPA Publications
Your weight for the rotary is still off by a couple of hundred pounds.
The total weight including everything needed firewall forward not counting
the turbo is 325 pounds. Bare engine block weight is less than 200 pounds.
This is fact and not opinion. If you added a turbo to a rotary the weight
increase is the same as if you added a turbo to an aircraft engine.
Don't lump the rotary in with car piston engines. The two are worlds
apart. That is one of the problems we have with a more widespread
acceptance of the rotary. The fact of the matter is the basic Mazda
rotary is far more durable and longer lasting than any piston aircraft
engines. The fact alone that they have no exhaust valves to burn or fail
makes them twice as good.
AOPA Pilot should publish a retraction as soon as possible
and not in the letters to the editor or some other obscure place in the
magazine. Don't publish my email to the letters to the editor
section of AOPA Pilot. That is unacceptable to me.
I suspect the real issue is the large amount of advertising revenue
AOPA Pilot derives from Continental and Lycoming. Your article and
others like it in AOPA Pilot are a sure sign the Wankel rotary is gaining
a following as a viable aircraft engine.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Although I hadn't read the original article, I must say Paul, your the right
man for the job- especially in this regard!
George ( down under)
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.