Subject: Letter to the editor.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/26/2005, 3:21 PM
To: AA-me



*From:* Haines, Thomas [mailto:Thomas.Haines@aopa.org]
*Sent:* Thursday, May 26, 2005 9:30 AM
*To:* Rick Irwin
*Cc:* Boyer, Phil
*Subject:* RE: Letter to the editor.



Thanks very much for your comments and for sharing your expertise. Phil
Boyer asked that I respond to your comments.

My intent in the two paragraphs where I mention Mazda rotary engines was
not to denigrate rotary engines. They certainly have a place in many
applications, including in some airplanes. The weight I quoted was from
an article we ran a number or years ago that compared the TSIO-360 in a
Mooney 252 to a Mazda conversion. We'll look into it and if the total is
incorrect for an installation for an airplane such as a Mooney as
opposed to a kit airplane, we'll run a correction.

You provide compelling information, much of it I am aware of, although
not at the detailed level I am sure you have. As an aircraft owner I am
hungry for better engines and engine technology, so you don't need to
sell me on that concept. If a rotary solution turns out to be it, that's
fine. I have no issue with rotary engines, although some in the rotary
community appear to have read that into my comments. I was simply making
the point that our existing dinosaur engines can carry us forward a
while longer if we can inject some technology into them. You'll recall
the rotary discussion was only two paragraphs out of about 20.

I'm happy to hear of the successes in installing rotary engines in
kitbuilt airplanes, something that has been happening for the last 20
years or so. However, as a believer in a free market economy I have to
believe that if automobile engine conversions were a viable alternative
for airplanes, particularly production airplanes, which is the primary
target of our editorial, we would have seen a ground swell of support
for those installations over the last two decades.

I have heard from two AOPA members about an RV owner in Florida who has
1,400 hours on his rotary-powered airplane. He is held up as proof that
the concept works. But if that is the high-time airplane after all of
these years, then I still have to wonder about the value proposition for
such a conversion.

I appreciate you sharing your information and will certainly keep your
comments in mind as we look at engine technology in future issues of
"AOPA Pilot." And I thank you again for taking the time to write. We may
use a portion of your letter in the magazine.

--Tom Haines, AOPA Publications


   Mr Boyer



   I have an application for signing up to AOPA tucked away in my Cozy
   MkIV aircraft plans.  I was thinking about signing up soon.  But
   this article you've written about Mazda rotary engines being heavy
   and not a good choice has me thinking I can delay a bit.  I say this
   mostly because I feel that it was irresponsible reporting due to the
   gross error in weight as well as the other comments about automotive
   engines in airplanes.



   First of all, the Rotary engine is typically within 30 to 50 pounds
   of the weight of a Lycoming installation.  Adding a turbo would be
   no different than adding a turbo to a reciprocating engine.



   A rotary engine is most like a turbine engine.   I There are only a
   few moving parts in a rotary engine.  There are so many parts that
   can fail in a reciprocating engine.  Have you counted those?  Or
   applied risk factors to those?  The greatest risk in putting a
   rotary engine in an aircraft is the quality of work and installing
   adequate cooling systems.



   The Renesis engine has won engine of the year for two years now.  A
   rotary recently won the Lemans race.  This engine can handle higher
   rpms and produce more horsepower per weight when compared to a
   reciprocating aircraft engine.



   A reciprocating engine by definition has parts that move "back and
   forth" .  Parts actually work against each other.   The rotary
   engine by contrast is already moving in the same direction as the
   prop.  It only makes sense that there is more mechanical efficiency
   there and certainly less vibration and wear.



   There are active interest groups putting these rotary engines in
   their aircraft and I don't feel that your article does this subject
   justice because many are flying, efficiently, fast, smooth, and quiest.



   I hope your magazine prints a retraction to cover these errors in
   reporting.



   Rick Irwin


Where have I heard this before?



Rick Irwin

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.