Subject: Systems For Rotor Seal Lubrication
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/3/2005, 4:22 AM
To: AA-me


         >
         > OK, aero-rotary engine newbie question!
         >
         > As I am reviewing numerous websites about the rotary engine
         > applicability to aircraft, it seems that more and more the
   issue of
         > proper lubrication for the rotor seals is one of, if not the,
        paramount
         > concern.  At www.wankel.org <http://www.wankel.org>
   <http://www.wankel.org> under the
        Aircraft Rotary Engine Best
         > Practises the 3 options of
         >
         > a. retaining the stock crankcase oil injection system,
         > b. mixing 2 stroke oil with the fuel, and
         > c. replacing the stock metering pump with one to inject 2
         > stroke oil
         >
         > are reviewed and the advantages/disadvantages of each are
   summarized.
         >
         > Clearly retaining the stock crankcase oil injection system is at
         > best problematic and should not be part of any responsible and
        effective
         > aero-installation.
         > While mixing the two stroke oil with the fuel during aircraft
         > refuelling would seem to be the most simple and straight forward
         > solution I have substantial concerns about keeping the oil
        properly and
         > even
         > distributed throughout the fuel so that the fuel/oil ratio being
        sent to
         > the engine remains constant independent of how much fuel is in
        the tank.
         >  (If the oil has a tendency to separate and settle onto the
   bottom of
         > the fuel tanks then the mixture would start out oil rich and
   then
        become
         > increasingly oil-lean as oil/fuel is used.)   Problems could
   also
        occur
         > when only partially filling fuel tanks or "topping up" partially
        empty
         > tanks - since the proper amount of oil is a function of fuel
   added it
         > seems the potential to have too much or too little oil is
   quite high
         > with resultant oil-rich or oil-lean mixtures adversely affecting
        engine
         > operation/reliability.
         > Metering pump injection of 2-stroke oil would seem to be the
   best
         > solution but the best practises site cautions that this
   retains the
         > "single point of injection" problem of the stock system.  When
        reviewing
         > a general engine layout drawing of a 13B I notice two oil
        injectors per
         > rotor, one in the intake port runner and one directly into
   the rotor
         > chamber.  I would have expected that the intake air flow
        turbulence and
         > fine oil misting provided by the oil injector would have
   resulted in
         > sufficiently thorough mixing that the fuel/air/2-stroke oil
   mixture
         > would effectively accomplish adequate seal lubrication and
   that the
         > chamber injected oil would serve to provide an excess of oil
   thus
        erring
         > on the side of safety.
         >
         > So, are my concerns about keeping the oil properly mixed and
   evenly
         > distributed in the fuel valid and if so what is being done to
        maintain
         > proper mixing?  Secondly how are people ensuring that the proper
         > 2-stroke oil/fuel mix ratio is maintained as fuel tanks are
   partially
         > filled, partially emptied and refilled in the course of normal
        aircraft
         > operation? (I would think that you would want to put the oil
   into the
         > fuel tanks before fuelling so that fuel "in-rush turbulence"
   would
         > assist in mixing and distributing the oil throughout the
   fuel volume,
         > but at that point you don't "know" how much fuel you will be
        adding and
         > hence there is no "factual" basis to determine how much oil to
        put into
         > the tanks first.)
         > Secondly, is there really a problem in distributing the oil
   evenly
         > over the rotor seal faces when using a metering pump that draws
        2-stroke
         > oil.  At first review a replacement metering pump really
   seems to
        be the
         > ideal solution with the advantages of properly proportioned
   oil/fuel
         > mixture, constant mixture control independent of fuel
   reserves on
        board,
         > use of a 2-stroke oil tank for oil cleanliness, ease of adding
        oil when
         > required and the ability to carry sufficient oil in case of
   supply
         > problems where airports might not have 2-stroke oil readily or
         > inexpensively available when/where re-fuelling.  (No doubt
   there are
         > other advantages of which I am not yet aware.)
         >
         > Comments, advise, suggestions please.
         >
         > Thanks and Cheers
         > Good Building and Flying
         >
         > Carl
         >
         > Carl P. Lindon  B.Eng., CD.
         > Lieutenant (Navy)
         > DGIIP/DIRAP
         >
         >
         >
         > I prefer mixing the two stroke oil with the fuel.
         > There is enough sloshing around in flight so keeping
         > it mixed is no problem. It lubes the seals better than injecting
         > oil.
         >
         > Paul Lamar
         >



        I have heard that fuel mix (two stroke plus gasoline) has a
   very short
        shelf life.  Care to comment on that?  Is that only when actually
        run in a
        2 stroke engine?


        Regards,

        Matt-
        VE N34RD, C150 N714BK


        That is a new one on me. Tracy has years of experience
        with pre mix but he has not mentioned that problem yet.

        Paul Lamar


   In the Land of Oz I understand it is common practice to use 2 stroke oil
   in the sump, in fact a few years ago when rotaries were still eligible
   to run at Bathurst Allan Moffat and Garry Waldon were winners using BP
   Energol 2 stroke oil that way. ( a win at Bathurst is the pinnacle of a
   racing career )
   Tracy has warned me not to do this, but I really would like to know why
   this is considered unsuitable, it certainly makes seal lubrication
   simple, and Mazda would seem to have put a lot of research into getting
   the injection system right.
   It seems that some 2 stroke oils remain well mixed, while others don't,
   also some of the mixtures go 'off' on standing.


I confess to not signing off that last post, apologies!

John Evans


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.