Matt wrote:
Paul will be the first to say that water cool aero engines make as
much sense as air cool submarines, but the fact is, all the potential
well engineered automotive core engines we have to choose from are
water cooled.
If Paul ever says that ("air cooled submarines"), I'll be the first in
line to thump him. If automotive conversions are "water-cooled", then
Lycoming/Continental/Volkswagens are "aluminum-cooled". The "coolant"
is just a thermal transfer mechanism. All non-marine engines are
"air-cooled" and all marine engines (including submarines) are
"water-cooled", regardless of the thermal transfer mechanism employed.
To mock automotive conversions because of their choice of thermal
transfer mechanism is to reveal one's own stupidity.
And by the way, Ford/GM/Chrysler/Mazda/Toyota/Subaru/Honda/... have
spent billions on engine research & design.
Lycoming/Continental/Superior/... have spent millions. So the
automotive engine people have spent several orders of magnitude more
money studying the problem. Who do you think is more likely to have
determined the right answer? :-)
Russell Kent
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.