Subject: Cooling method was (air cooled submarines)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/8/2005, 1:11 AM
To: AA-me



   That is not so in cars. They are often stationary, there is little,
   or no
   wind. Even a fan provides too little air flow and would be
   inadequate for
   cooling above a certain power. Water cooling will be much more efficient
   and provides a stable, even temperature. Nevertheless, there were
   some low
   power air cooled cars in the past (~40 hp). Once you go higher than
   that,
   air cooling just won’t do.

Rolf,
I am not mentioning this as an arguement just as information. The
"certain power" you are talking about must be pretty high. As an example
I offer the Porche 917-30 Can-Am variant that was dominating the
unlimited Can-Am's at the end producing over 1000 HP from 5 liters with
multiple turbochargers. An engine that used a lot of "unobtainium" to be
sure, but it was air cooled.
The point? It is what the engine is designed for, not the cooling
method that is important. Water cooled engines have proven to be more
efficient, quieter, generally more durable, and lastly more consistant
across a range of temperatures than air cooled engines. The reasons
proceeding are why water cooled engines now dominate.

Bill Jepson

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.