>
> Now that the subject of oil has arisen I'll try again.
> A month or so ago I asked on this site if anyone knew what
was wrong
> with using top quality water cooled 2 stroke oil in
rotaries, as is
> common practice here in racing.
> When I raised this with Tracy I was emphatically warned
against
it, but
> as yet I have seen no evidence, or reason for this opinion.
> Obviously the stuff is meant to burn cleanly without
gumming
up seal
> grooves, and must be an excellent lubricant to work in
the small
> quantities available both when injected and pre-mixed.
To me
it seems
> that its use in a rotary sump would be "light duty"
compared
with its
> usual role.
>
>>
> John Evans
> BTW there is nothing in the CD about using 2 cycle oil in a
rotary
> sump. You are on your own. Good luck. Frankly I would
stick to
Idemitsu
> rotary engine oil as it has been specifically
formulated and
developed
> at considerable cost to be used in the rotary engine.
This oil
was used
> in the Mazda Lemans winning four rotor.
>
> Paul Lamar
Don't forget most of us need a very high film strength oil
because
we are
running the gearbox in the same oil. It has to be a synthetic
or high
phosphorus motor cycle oil.
Ian Beadle
Good point Ian. Tracy has been using Mobil One synth for a
long
time.
Idemitsu is also a synthetic but I don't know how much
phosphorus
if any.
Paul Lamar
I had tried to get film strength data from various oil
companies, BP
Energol were the only ones who were of much help, actually they
were the
major sponsors of the RX 7 that won at Bathurst some years ago,
I know
from personal communication with one of the drivers that it ran
on their
water cooled 2 stroke oil, so it seems unlikely that the engine
would be
a problem.
To me the Reduction Drive appears to be a separate issue,
obviously the
planetary gears are usually lubricated by ATF, which appears to
be less
viscous than most engine oils, so presumably its film strength
would be
lower, but this does not seem to be an issue in its usual role
of being
hammered by a big V8 in the C6 transmission from which it is
derived.
Whenever I have worked on 2 strokes running on premix I have
always been
most impressed with how well the small amount of lubricant
present has
done its job, one would think that being pumped around an engine or
gearbox in copious quantities would be relatively light duty!
Furthermore it is specifically designed to burn cleanly without
gumming
up ring grooves, or leaving troublesome combustion chamber
deposits as
do ordinary engine oils!
What I really want to learn is whether or not there is any real
data
available to support the opinions put forward, or is it just that,
opinions without any rational basis.
John Evans.
We did some 500 F oven heat test on different oils a few years ago.
Put a teaspoon of oil in a can and baked it for 1/2 hour at 500 F.
Other than $10 a quart turbine oil Mobile One came out on top.
I have
not tried Idemitsu but I read a SAE paper they gave on the
development of
it for the Mazda Lemans four rotor engine. Others have mixed
two stroke oil with gasoline and burned it to check for residue.
there was none.
Paul Lamar
I looked into this some time ago, and concluded that two stroke oils are
not suitable for the sump. From memory, the reasons were:
1. The viscosity is not sufficient to maintain proper film thickness in
journal bearings.
2. The oil is formulated with a carrier that is designed to promote
mixing with gasoline. The carrier itself detracts from the properties of
the fluid as a lubricant if it is used neat.
3. The flash point of bulk two stroke oil is dangerously low.
I would think that a suitable lubricant could be formulated to address
these issues based on two stroke oil technology, but there would have to
be significant financial incentive for an oil company to do so. Perhaps
the Idemitsu oil is essentially what we are talking about, although as I
recall the Idemitsu oil carries API SF or higher ratings which would
suggest that the formulation is more similar to a typical automotive
oil.
Jon
Thanks for the good info, however I still have some concerns with
synthetics as they are known to mobilise lead deposits in engines that
have been run on leaded fuels leading to obstruction of small oilways. I
actually saw this happen to an O200 engined aircraft fairly recently, I
think the synthetic involved was Mobil 1, to which the owner had
recently changed, the engine lost compression due to the hydraulic
tappets becoming blocked with the deposits.
It would be nice to have specific information to allow direct comparison
of film strength, but I guess oil companies revealing that would not be
seen as in the corporate interest!
I have to confess to being something of a sceptic, who could tell if the
Idemitsu Rotary Engine Oil was 2 stroke oil repackaged? Most of us will
believe just about anything if it's released with enough hype!
When I was talking to the various oil company technical people they just
kept referring to viscosity when I asked about film strength, presumably
they regard them as the same thing.
When you look at ATF it is obviously less viscous than engine oil, now I
know that a few years ago one of the tricks used by
motorcycle Production Racers was to use ATF in the sump, apparently its
lower viscosity gave them a few more rpm than more viscous oils. There
is no evidence that it was in any way harmful.
John Evans
Synthetic oils do not appear to be a problem in rotaries.
I have been using Mobil One for five years in my RX7 and RX8.
Lately Idemitsu rotary engine oil in the RX8.
Tracy Crook has been using Mobile One in his rotary powered RV4 aircraft
for several years. Tracy uses high lead 100 LL aviation fuel from
time to time as auto fuel is not always available at airports.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.