Subject: Two cycle oil in the sump.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/27/2005, 6:34 PM
To: AA-me



   I have to confess to being something of a sceptic, who could tell if the
   Idemitsu Rotary Engine Oil was 2 stroke oil repackaged? Most of us will
   believe just about anything if it's released with enough hype!
   When I was talking to the various oil company technical people they just
   kept referring to viscosity when I asked about film strength, presumably
   they regard them as the same thing.
   When you look at ATF it is obviously less viscous than engine oil, now I
   know that a few years ago one of the tricks used by
   motorcycle Production Racers was to use ATF in the sump, apparently its
   lower viscosity gave them a few more rpm than more viscous oils. There
   is no evidence that it was in any way harmful.
   John Evans

I used to know a lot about lubricants but I have forgotten most of it by
now. I don't think that there is a standard measure for "film strength."
Lubricants behave very differently depending on the loads they are
subjected to. In a plain bearing, film thickness is highly dependent on
the basic viscosity of the fluid. In applications with very high contact
stresses, like rolling element bearings and gear meshes (and apex
seals), film thickness is more dependent on the pressure-viscosity index
(for which little data are published). In a highly loaded line contact
bearing, the pressure on the lubricant entrained in the contact zone
gets enormous. The viscosity increases dramatically along with the
pressure. The characteristic of viscosity vs. pressure is different for
different lubricants. The traditional viscosity and the
pressure-viscosity index are strongly influenced by the base stock, less
so by the additive packages. Another relevant measure is the shear
stability. This is a measure of how much the viscosity changes under
very high shear rates. I recall that the additives that increase the
viscosity index (to make multi viscosity oils like 10W-40) are not very
good under high shear rates. Finally, EP (extreme pressure) additives
serve to protect highly loaded contacts like differential gears by
providing a chemical film on the surface of the metals. These films
provide some "cushion" and shear away preferentially when the fluid film
is too thin to prevent metal to metal contact. The surface films prevent
scuffing and adhesive wear. The API classifications (SF, SH, CF, etc.)
require rigorous testing of many lubricant characteristics. I guess it
is possible for an oil company to "cheat" and label a product falsely,
but I doubt the reputable companies do this. Modern lubricants are very
high-tech components of an engine. The reason automotive engines
commonly run 200k miles and more these days has a lot to do with today's
improved lubricants.
Jon

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.