Subject: P-port maifold pressure tap
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/11/2005, 7:14 PM
To: AA-me


I had a long talk with Tracy on this subject.
The question is what is the true manifold pressure. We need to know
that number to set the pulse width of the fuel injectors. Since
Tracy samples it for only a millisecond or so it could be affected by
a lot of factors. We know there are pressure pulses in intake
and exhaust systems. The question is; what part of the pressure
curve is occurring when Tracy samples the pressure?

Tracy samples the pressure for firing the injectors on rotor two
right after (within a few microseconds) he fires rotor
one's ignition plugs (about 20 degrees BTDC). So far I have not been
able to talk him into taking many samples and averaging the data.

We discussed how to measure the pressure wave in the p-port intake manifold
as a function of e-shaft angle during one cycle per revolution of the
e-shaft. The max pressure will occur at different times depending
on the RPM and the length and diameter of the runners. So far suggestions
have been; feeding the output of the high speed pressure sensor into a PC
audio input card or the microphone jack of a note book computer. Tracy
pointed out the problem with that are those are AC inputs and we need
absolute numbers from  the pressure sensors. We also need to relate
them to the ignition pulse. That led to  using a storage oscilloscope
instead.

I picked up two open-source DIY fuel injection kits from the MegaSquirt
guys:
    http://www.bgsoflex.com/megasquirt.html  or
    http://www.megasquirt.info

... mostly to learn more about real-life fuel injection issues before
sticking it in my aircraft.  I plan to use it on an old 4x4 truck for
testing.  (I still plan to use Tracy's for the aircraft.)

TO THE POINT:  In the many helpful discussions on the MegaSquirt list,
one was how to "smooth out" the intake pressure pulses to avoid spurious
MAP readings at various RPMs.

Intuition leads you to implement a "surge tank" solution, where rapid
changes in pressure are "averaged out".  Turns out this is a bad idea,
due to opposing goals:
1) Larger surge tank = slower system response to throttle changes.
2) Smaller surge tank = inadequate "averaging" of pressure pulses.

#1 is the REAL problem, though.  A real long or fat vacuum line counts
as a surge tank, too.

It seems the best solution discussed is to put a restrictor in the
vacuum line to the MAP sensor.  A metal vacuum hose coupler drilled to a
specific size seems to be popular.  The only "surge tank" left is the
unavoidable minimal volume of the MAP vacuum line.  (The restrictor can
be at the manifold, the MAP sensor, or anywhere in between.)  The
restrictor effectively controls maximum rates of pressure change in the
MAP sensor side of the vacuum tube.  Drill to size to get your desired
response rate.

*******************************\__/*******************************
Manifold                        __                      MAP Sensor
*******************************/  \*******************************
                           Restrictor

This *is* RPM dependent.  The MAP tables are ultimately responsible for
factoring the fuel adjustments in.  We just want to eliminate
problematic MAP-sample-timing issues.

Simple.  Reliable.  Cheap.  Lightweight.  Reproducable.

What's not to like?

BTW - "taking many samples and averaging the data" is like adding a
surge tank.  Tracy probably wants to maintain system response.  (I'm
just guessing here...)

-Vince Orton

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.