Greg wrote:
Hello. I was advised to get involved here to possibly find out what
the fuel consumption will ultimately be with Innodyn's turbines. I
understand this is a newletter for rotary, but a saleman for a rotary
company said I'd find out some interesting things about turbines via
you newletter.
Thank you, Greg Nus
PS. I'm building an RV10 and am on the fence between a mistral
G-230TS
and innodyn 255.
Alias N510RV
The finest small turbo prop engines in the world can barely
achieve, under ideal circumstance, 0.65 pounds of fuel burned per hour
for each horsepower generated in each hour. This a fact and not
anyones opinion. These engines are extremely expensive with
many stages of axial flow compression and probably a few stages
of turbines. You can ask any legitimate turbine company
such as Rolls Royce (Allison), Pratt & Whitney, Garrett and/or GE.
They will give you the data on the turbo prop engines they build.
This is the result of very expensive world wide gas turbine
R&D for the last 70 or 80 years.
In other words a small 200 HP turbine will require a minimum of
200 times .65 pounds of fuel per hour or 130 pounds of fuel
per hour. Since there are 6 pounds of fuel in each gallon that
is 21.66 gallons an hour.
Go to a large library and obtain a technical book on gas turbines and
research this for your self. Don't take my word for it.
I can recommend "Aircraft Gas Turbine Engine Technology" by
Irwin E. Treager Glencoe Mcgraw Hill. Third edition 1995
ISBN 0-02-801828-1
If some small company comes along and claims they are burning
significantly less fuel than this while generating the same HP
it becomes quite obvious they are lying. The smaller the turbine the
worse this ratio. In other words at 100 HP the ratio could
be one pound of fuel burned for every HP or 100 pounds of fuel
per hour or 16.6 gallons per hour.
A 100 HP piston aircraft engine like the Continental O-200 will
achieve half that or better. Probably around .45 BSFC or 45 pounds an
hour or 7.5 gallons an hour. This ratio for piston aircraft engines is
a good number for piston engines up to 4,000 HP corn cob radial
engines. The number can go as low as .38 for a large turbo compound
radial engines used post world war II in airliners. See our web site
below.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/turbo.html
The best the Mazda Wankel rotary engine can do so far is 0.47 however
it is far more reliable than an aircraft piston engine mainly
because it has no problematic exhaust valves and it is less costly to
buy which will compensate over time for the slightly increased fuel
burn.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.
Hi Paul,
Do you know if anyone has done a study on how much equivalent horsepower
is lost to cooling and profile drag on a recip. as compared to a well
installed gas-turbine? I know that a really slick cowl design on a big
Continental will have very low cooling drag, but the gas-turbine still
has the advantage when it comes to frontal area.
Where I am going with this is that on a fast airplane, how much faster
will it go with the same shaft horsepower, but different installation
drag. This will offset some of specific fuel consumption disadvantage
of the turbine. How much it will offset it is what I am wondering.
Regards,
Matt-
The higher and faster you go the better. The intake temp goes
down and the dynamic pressure forcing air into the engine
increases with speed.
I can,t give you any specifics but small biz jets are state of the art.
It is getting to the point where they burn about the same fuel
per mile as turbo props.
Paul Lamar
Ah.. Mmm. It seems like you spoke of the difference between turboprops
and turbofans.. I get that. I was asking about the difference between
installed drag of a reciprocating engine and that of a turboprop. Is that
the subject you were replying to?
Regards,
Matt-
Ops.
Hard to say Matt there may be no difference. Done properly
with cowl flaps the recip cooling drag might be only 10% worse.
Wild ass guess on my part.
The bottom line is MPG verses speed.
Turbo props lose more power at altitude compared to a turbo recip.
If you want to go fast with better MPG go high and turbo charge
a Wankel.
Paul Lamar
Let me amend that. Up to 350 to 400 MPH for turbo ICE and turbo prop.
After that the turbofan wins hands down. This is because prop efficiency
drops off fast with speed over about 400 MPH.
Lancair did a study a few years back comparing a turbo prop with a turbo
recip in the 350 MPH range and 20,000 feet. The turbocharged recip won
hands down at altitude because the turbo recip was flat rated and the turbo prop
engine lost HP.
The big buck guys wanted the turbine anyway. Damn the MPG full speed ahead.
Mainly because you could get 600 to 1100 HP at sea level in the turbo prop
engine and it was long lasting, reliable and durable. Just like a Mazda Wankel :)
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.