Subject: Small turbo prop engines
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/11/2005, 8:10 AM
To: AA-me


    > Greg wrote:
    > > Hello. I was advised to get involved here to possibly find out
   what the
    > > fuel consumption will ultimately be with Innodyn's turbines. I
    > > understand this is a newletter for rotary, but a saleman for a
   rotary
    > > company said I'd find out some interesting things about
   turbines via you
    > > newletter.
    > > Thank you, Greg Nus
    > >
    > > PS. I'm building an RV10 and am on the fence between a mistral
   G-230TS
    > > and innodyn 255.
    > >
    > >
    > > Alias N510RV
    >
    > The finest small turbo prop engines in the world can barely
    > achieve, under ideal circumstance, 0.65 pounds of fuel burned per
    > hour for each horsepower generated in each hour. This a fact and
    > not anyones opinion. These engines are extremely expensive with
    > many stages of axial flow compression and probably a few stages
    > of turbines. You can ask any legitimate turbine company
    > such as Rolls Royce (Allison), Pratt & Whitney, Garrett and/or
   GE. They
    > will give you the data on the turbo prop engines they build.
    > This is the result of very expensive world wide gas turbine
    > R&D for the last 70 or 80 years.
    >
    > In other words a small 200 HP turbine will require a minimum of
    > 200 times .65 pounds of fuel per hour or 130 pounds of fuel
    > per hour. Since there are 6 pounds of fuel in each gallon that
    > is 21.66 gallons an hour.
    >
    > Go to a large library and obtain a technical book on gas turbines
    > and research this for your self. Don't take my word for it.
    > I can recommend "Aircraft Gas Turbine Engine Technology" by
    > Irwin E. Treager Glencoe Mcgraw Hill. Third edition 1995
    > ISBN 0-02-801828-1
    >
    > If some small company comes along and claims they are burning
    > significantly less fuel than this while generating the same HP
    > it becomes quite obvious they are lying. The smaller the turbine
    > the worse this ratio. In other words at 100 HP the ratio could
    > be one pound of fuel burned for every HP or 100 pounds of fuel
    > per hour or 16.6 gallons per hour.
    >
    > A 100 HP piston aircraft engine like the Continental O-200 will
   achieve
    > half that or better. Probably around .45 BSFC or 45 pounds an
   hour or 7.5
    > gallons an hour. This ratio for piston aircraft engines is a good
    > number for piston engines up to 4,000 HP corn cob radial engines.
    > The number can go as low as .38 for a large turbo compound radial
   engines
    > used post world war II in airliners. See our web site below.
    >
    > http://www.rotaryeng.net/turbo.html
    >
    > The best the Mazda Wankel rotary engine can do so far is 0.47 however
    > it is far more reliable than an aircraft piston engine mainly
    > because it has no problematic exhaust valves and it is less costly
    > to buy which will compensate over time for the slightly increased
   fuel burn.
    >
    > Paul Lamar



    > Hi Greg for all intents and purposes a turbine on a fixed gear
   airplane

   is absolutely impractical. A turbine is best served at altitude

   unless the aircraft is being used for special purpose like agricultural

   spraying or fire fighting. A turbines fuel consumption goes way down

   as altitude increases. My neighbor has a Lancair IVP with a Walther

   601 in it.700SHP He has added a 20 Gallon header tank to the already

   100 gallon wings. This is to give him 3 hours cruise with IFR reserves.

   His burn is 39 gal/hr at idle and 22 gal/ cruise. Of coarse he is

   cruising at 330 mph. What is fun is watching the VSI at 7000
   ft/min...LOL

   Respectfully,
   Doug Mueller
   RX-6 13BT
   N900DM
   Boulder City, NV

thx Doug, I was thinking along those lines. It is great getting the
advice. Greg

Alias N510RV


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.