Subject: Thank God for the Mazda rotary engine.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/18/2005, 10:27 PM
To: AA-me


This is from Flying magazine September 2005 page 46 about the Lancair
Columbia powered with a state of the art Continental TSIO 550-C 310 HP
dual turbo, dual inter cooler, air cooled aircraft engine. Aircraft
price $536,000.

"There is a 10-gallon fuel imbalance limitation in the 400, so the
tanks have to be  switched frequently in a full-power climb where the
fuel flow red line is at 40  gallons per hour. We climbed to 17,500
feet, using nasal oxygen cannulas to sustain  life, where at maximum
cruise power, as set by Doug, the true airspeed as calculated  by the
Avidyne system settled on 225 knots. The fuel flow was 22.5 gallons
per hour, which was somewhat below the book figure of 25 gph shown for
max cruise. Still, using  the .45 pounds per hour per horsepower
specific fuel consumption that usually works  for turbocharged
pistons, the fuel flow experienced suggests that we were developing
300 horsepower, which is a fairly high percentage of the 310 rating
for the engine.  It is quite obvious that the engine makes more power
than the rating.

Here we must become controversial. Doug leaned the mixture to 50°F on
the lean side  of peak. The airspeed dropped by seven or eight knots
and the fuel flow was reduced  by maybe four gallons per hour. Doesn't
that sound like magic? Trouble was, the  engine, which wasn't all that
smooth in this airplane to begin with, became decidedly
uncomfortable. Doug even said that when running lean of peak the
engine would  occasionally stumble or splutter.

Even without the stumble or splutter I was uncomfortable with the
engine's apparent  discomfort when running lean of peak. From a
technical standpoint it might be okay to  run like this, but there is
no way I am going to fly an airplane with the engine  running in a
ragged manner. I'd rather buy the gas to make it go as
  fast as possible and run as smoothly as possible and leave the
alleged
magic to
someone else.

Additionally, the POH specifies that the engine be run at best power
mixture when  operated between 65 and 85 percent power. That is all
the more reason. to burn the gas."

Sooner or later you will be flying a rotary.

Paul Lamar


Some of this is just silly, however.  Those engines don't run LOP very
well unless they have matched injectors - can't imagine why TCM doesn't
build them that way to start with.  Even if you don't run LOP, matched
injectors make the engine easier to fly.

Anyway, to run lean enough to keep the cylinders cool, 65% power is
about all you can make.  Any closer to peak EGT, and you get more than
65% power, and you run too hot.  No great mystery.

I bet John Deakin is fired up about this article - or maybe not since
this topic is still so misunderstood...

Even so, I agree, rotaries make much more sense.

Matt-


I went throught the Continental factory tour when I picked up my new
O-470 and they claimed they were matching the injectors.

Paul Lamar


I wonder if they meant they were all the same size, or actually fuel flow
matched to what each cylinder can effectively burn.  :)  Either way, it
doesn't sound like the engine
in the Columbia was running properly.  And the author sounded like he was
suffering from hypoxia...

Matt-

The artical was written by Richard Collins who happens to own
a Cessna P210 so he has years of expierence with turbo six cylinder
aircraft engines. Some of the claims made for matched fuel
injectors and running lean of peak on air cooled AC engines
are unrealistic. It does work somewhat but not to the extent
claimed. Some are claiming BSFC below .40 which is an out and out lie.

The big problem with it is pilot error. If you screw up
and open the throttle or descend without changing or reseting  the mixture
you could damage the engine exhaust valves and cylinder heads
as the EGT's go to or through peak. I think that is why Lycoming will
not honor the warrantee if you run lean of peak. Strictly prohibited.
The rotary engine on the other hand does not care what the mixture
is over a wide range. Needless to say, on here there, are no exhaust
valves to burn.

Paul Lamar


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.