>> > I would like to report a broken housing due to a
>> hard landing.
>> > Actually, in
>> > my case it was a wave on the water, same
>> consequences. Included are
>> > pictures to show the details. I use Tracy's
>> redrive and adapter
>> > plate. I
>> > have one engine mount under the adapter plate.
>> The force applied
>> > to the
>> > mount applies a force on the engine rear housing
>> right at the oil
>> > filterboss. My rear housing broke at the dowel
>> hole next to the
>> > oil filter boss.
>> > The new rear housing I bought is stronger in that
>> area, there is
>> > more metal
>> > around the dowel hole. One photo shows the broken
>> housing and where
>> > I tried
>> > to weld it. One photo shows where the forces are
>> applied. One
>> > photo shows
>> > the new and old housings.
>> >
>> > Rino Lacombe
>
>
>
>> > I am a bit skeptical that a hard landing caused
>> this. In order to
>> > do that
>> > all the other ten MM bolts holding the PSRU plate
>> to the engine
>> > throughthe spacer would have to deflect. This
>> dowel hole has been
>> > known to crack
>> > in car use. That is why Mazda beefed it up in the
>> third gen engine.
>> > Whattype of intake system are you using? It is a four
>> > port engine. Is it a turbo charged four port? NOS?
>> >
>> > Paul Lamar
>> >
>> > Did the engine ever back fire Rino?
>> >
>> > Paul Lamar
>
>
>> Rino,
>>
>> Did the bridge for your rear plyon mount sustain any
>> damage? (this is the single, center mount for
>> non-Glass Goose types). It would seem that this
>> relatively flexible mounting structure would have a
>> hard time imparting large enough loads to break the
>> rear engine housing.
>>
>> Could you tell if the housing break seemed to be
>> from a compression force (upward/forward) shoving
>> the redrive into the engine, or a
>> bending/distraction force (aft displacement of the
>> break) from the rear mount acting as a fulcrum
>> between the engine and redrive?
>>
>> BTW, how has your cooling system been working? Any
>> other flight or engine performance you'd like to share?
>>
>> Scott Gettings
>
>
>> Or torsion. Torsion is the usual failure mode as that dowel
>> pin is subject to all engine torque. Detonation can also
>> cause these kinds of failure.
>>
>> Paul Lamar
>
>
> Very interesting Paul. I did end up with one broken apex seal on the
> front
> rotor!
>
> I did not hear detonation and I have no gauge.
>
> I am using Tracy's engine controller and the timing was about 10 deg.
> BTDC.
>
> I also know that at wide open throttle the engine was surging which I
> interpret as too lean mixture.
>
> Two things must have happened at the same time, detonation and hit the
> wave
> because right after hitting the wave the engine stopped and the oil
> spilled
> out. The wave hit hard enough to damage the trailing edge of the two
> sponsons and some minor damage to the hull (bottom of the boat).
>
> Paul, I included a photo of the intake system and the turbo. It is a
> turbocharged four ports 1988.
>
> Scott, a bad landing that would hit that hard would probably end up with
> no
> landing gear left under the plane. The plane went flying for a minute
or
> two.
>
> When I removed the engine, that is the first place I looked for damage,
> rear
> pylon mount. I had painted the mounts when I made them so that stress
> points would show better. There is no sign of stress on any part of
the
> two mounts, I must say that I was surprised. The propeller did touch
the
> deck and made a small dent. It was not high enough, only 3/4", I raised
> to
> 1-1/4".
>
> Scott, I cannot comment on the cooling system, the plane did not fly
yet.
> I
> was away from it for about 14 months, building a house. I hope it will
> fly
> in a couple of weeks. The engine is back in the plane with apex seals
> from
> Tracy. I cannot tell what kind of force was applied to the rear
housing.
>
> Rino
>
> -------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Ah Ha broken apex seal and turbo! Strong indication of detonation.
> It is easy to make a detonation monitor with an amp and
> ear phone. I'll upload a schematic if anyone is interested.
> Also MSD sells one with a visible indication of detonation.
> Unfortunately once it happens it is usually two late.
>
> Were you using 3 piece 2 mm seals? Do you have an intercooler?
>
> Also it is possible a prop strike could break that end housing
> Prop strikes usually crack an aircraft piston engine's crank.
> Since the oil squirted out right after it hit the prop
> strike is a more likely scenario for breaking the end housing.
>
> Paul Lamar
The broken rear iron housing's dowel land comes from rotor
housing deflection against the dowels from high combustion chamber
pressures due to pre-ignition; not detonation. The mixture fired too
early for some reason (more than likely heat as 10*BTDC advance
is quite retarded if your manifold boost pressure was anything under
15psi (or 2bar ATM) on pump-octane fuel. I'll bet the engine was
running lean for a sustained amount of time, or had high intake charge
temps, and heated the internals up...
B
Brian D. Cain -/- Dallas/Ft. Worth, TX -/- bdc196@comcast.net -/-
bdc@bdcmotorsports.com
BDC Motorsports | Performance Rotary Engines, Haltech EFI Tuning &
Installation, Specialized port work
MSN bdc196@nospam.hotmail.com, Yahoo! bdc196, AOL Symajhi, ICQ# 1733105
http://www.bdcmotorsports.com -/- http://bdc.cyberosity.com
Brian, knowing that timing was a possible cause I checked it after the
incident. I thought I had set it at 20deg. BTDC but it was actually at
10deg. I have the stock intercooler and it works good, it normally keeps
the intake temp down but I cannot tell what it was during the incident. The
mixture was too lean at the time. I do not know what was the intake
manifold pressure either. So many things to watch for at the same time
when testing an engine.......
Quite a number of possible reasons for breaking the rear housing ... or a
combination of the above.
Paul, I was using 3 piece 2 mm seals and I use a stock intercooler.
Rino
Don't rule out the prop strike. That would put a torsional shock into
the engine.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.