Subject: Bell 47 planetery gear assemblie
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/28/2005, 12:57 AM
To: AA-me



>>
>> Paul,
>> Looking at the Bell 47 planet set up. We have a few trucks and the one
>> truck specifically is a Magirius Deutz with ZF diffs. this truck has a
>> planetary reduction drive which looks very similar to what i see in
>> your attachment in its wheel hubs. The exact ratio i'm not sure of but
>> to give you an indication of the torque and hp this planetary gear has
>> to endure is extremely high.The truck is a 6x6 with a 18 ton drill
>> mounted on it and still pulls a 8 ton compressor behind it. The engine
>> is a V12 Deutz Air cooled developing 400hp.
>>
>> My thinking is that possibly your Mack and  International series
>> trucks may have simaler planetery set ups in there diffs. Although i
>> feel the Mack and Deutz are old school tech, and we should possibly be
>> looking at new era truck's with lighter and stronger planetery set ups
>> in there diff's. But looking at your attachment, the size and OD of
>> the Bell 46 reduction looks very similer in design to what i
>> mentioned.
>> Craig.
>
>
> Has anyone on this group been keeping track of David Algae's airplane?
> He custom designed a gearbox to fit the LS-1 Chevy.   Indy car
> fabricator.
>   We just need to get him to see the light with Mazda instead of Bowtie.
>
> The gearbox is Carbon Fiber and beautiful (seen in person at OSH),
> though as yet unproven.  He's got good credentials, however.
>
> Pick a gearset, build some molds and lay it up.  Sounds simple...  :)
> Maybe his design would be easy to adapt to the 13B.  Custom bellhousing
> should be the largest change.  We might be able to talk him into it as a
> side project to help with cashflow until he can get some kits sold.
>
> General page:
>
> http://members.iquest.net/~aca/
>
> Custom gearbox shots:
>
> http://members.iquest.net/~aca/images/img07.jpg
>
> http://members.iquest.net/~aca/images/img04.jpg
>
>
>
> Matt-
>
> Heat will soften the resin. Too risky. Not worth
> the weight saving.
>
> You can also build a gear box housing out of six inch diameter
> thick wall aluminum tubing. You will need a lathe to make a PSRU anyway.
> The last pic will give you an idea just how small and light
> weight the Ford A4OD 2.85 planet set really is. Used in dozens, if not
> scores, of PSRUs.
>
> Paul Lamar


Heat will soften everything (including Al).  A CF gearbox uses high temp
resin.

http://www.sportcompactcarweb.com/motorsports/0507_scc_honda/

http://venus.13x.com/roadracingworld/issues/feb01/tularis.htm

And these are multispeed boxes..

There are tremendous benefits to using composites for things with complex
shapes.  Materials science is important, even when using metals.


Regards,

Matt-

300 f is marginal Matt.
What is complex about concentric cylinders?
Composite engines are nothing new. 20 or 30 years
ago people were building composite engines. Where are they now?
Composites are good for a lot of things but not everything.
It would take an NC lathe 5 minutes to make a gear box case
out of a chunk of aluminum. It would probably weigh 2 pounds
at the out side. Where is the savings?

Paul Lamar



Good morning Paul from South Africa,
Thinking of your Bell 47 reduction drive, i feel the internal components and
bearings are designed for a maximum input of possibly 3000 rpm and out put
of approx. 650 rpm. At 300-400hp. I feel putting a rotary engine on to it at
8000 rpm to develop 350 hp, the bearings and gears in the PSRU are designed
to take alot of torque and are not designed to accommodate such high input
speeds. If this was tried, I feel the Bell 47 gearbox would end up absorbing
at least 50hp at that speed in extra heat generated and end up with either
bearing failure or a melted aluminum casing.

I feel Tracy's PSRU's are along the right track with the Ford planetary
system. I realize he is catering for the needs of the home builder and costs
are a big issue with regards to the internal components, but i feel with a
better bell housing abaptor plate plate and possibly a re look at a
different bearing configuration within the PSRU the current planetary set up
is definitely worth continuing for the 300hp + aerobatic enthusiast.
Tracy needs to keep his present line of PSRU's going and possibly look to
design a more robust PSRU obviously at a different price for the aerobatic
market.
Craig.

The Dave Garber that built this thing checked with the Bell engineers
and they said no problem 6000 RPM and that is were the
1000 HP number came from. This airplane has flown several
times with push pull  350 HP turbo charged 12A motors. Zero problems
with the gear boxes. Nothing special in the way of box oil cooling.
The boxes were just partially filled with some light weight gear
oil. If it became a problem one could always use a pump and circulate
the gear box oil through a heat exchanger.

In fact the only bearings in the box are running at prop RPMs.
Thats me running it up for the onlookers at Sun & Fun in 2002.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.