Paul,
add me to your list. I'm with Vance. If you want to race at Reno, you
should
be too. Wink, Wink!
The rules for sportsman class racing state specifically that piston
engines
of less than some number (600 or so cubic inches, I don't remember
exactly.)
Claiming mythical status for the rotary as some ultra small displacement
non-piston engine just works in favor of all the conformists who want to
ban
it from racing. Let the tax regulators in Europe and Japan think it is 1.3
liter rotary super whats it.
Let the racing regulators at Reno think it is a six chamber rotary piston
engine of 3.9 liter displacement. Use Vance as your expert witness. Don't
give them bullets to shoot at us with.
It is what it is and does what it does.
Monty
Well it is indeed 1.3 liters if you consider it a two cycle.
It is also physically about the same size as a 1.3 L two cycle.
It is not a two cycle so the entire world including the tax
bureaucrats and all racing organizations now consider it a 2.6
liter engine. The only advantage it has over a 2.6 liter piston
engine is the 120% volumetric efficiency as opposed to
about 80% for the piston engine. It might have a slight RPM
advantage over a four cylinder 2.6 liter piston engine
as well. These two factors are at the core of the
rotary power advantage.
The Reno Sportsman class officials have already handicapped
the rotary by accepted only the 3 rotor turbo version
in lew of the 640 cubic inch limit. A scaled up turbo
charged 640 cubic inch rotary based on the 2.6 liter equivalent
would have of course something like 1066 HP with stock
Japan spec 3rd gen porting. No P-ports. Porting you would get if
you bought a Japan spec 650 cubic inch rotary if such an animal
were available.
The engine would be about physically twice the size and weight of a
current 4 rotor engine. Ironically it would weigh installed about twice
as much a 640 cubic inch aircraft piston engine unless it had aluminum
end housing and then it would be a couple of hundred pounds
lighter.
However at the same level of tune as the current racing 550 cubic
inch aircraft piston engines it would have roughly 2000 HP.
A four rotor 16B would be about 6.4 liters or 390 cubic inches.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
If you accept that the rotor is three sided and each face constitutes a
combustion chamber and each face completes a 4 cycle event per (rotor) rev,
and there are two rotors you get a 3.9L engine that has about a 10-20%
increase in volumetric efficiency and a great advantage in that it has no
valve train. If you look at the ROTOR rpm not the Eshaft, which is what
really matters, you get an engine rpm of 1/3 the Eshaft speed. 8500 becomes
2833 rpm which is similar to a piston engine. The big difference is a
piston/crank engine must complete two full revs per piston face to complete
a cycle where the rotary piston face can do so in one rev. The disadvantage
is to accomplish this the shaft spins 3 times the speed of the piston face.
No real magic. A very clever design and arrangement of parts with some
drawbacks related to heat rejection and combustion chamber shape. Still a
238 in^3 engine making 240 hp at 2833 rpm is phenomenal. A fairer
comparison is a piston engine at twice this speed or around 5700rpm. A
little over 1 hp/in^3 at 6000 rpm is attainable with a modern NA piston
engine. Durability is not good however.
Look at the numbers for volumetric efficiency. 120%!!!??? do you really
believe that removing the valves increases things from 80% to 120%?I still
prefer the rotary, but you only get a 20% increase in throughput over
displacement using supercharging. You are only going to get a few percent
increase in volumetric efficiency over 100% even under the best dynamic
tuning super duper magic runner engine of any configuration.
If you look at piston area and HP/area the rotary is still really good. Part
of that one rev/cycle thing.
We could argue this forever, but the bottom line is it is a good engine
on the other subject of racing:
So you are saying that they will let the turbocharged 3 rotor race? It does
not say so in the rules. A turbocharged 3 rotor in the right airframe would
be very competitive in the sportsman class.
My take from the people I have talked to is that they would not allow it to
race, or if you did and beat the pants off of everybody it would only race
once. Continental, Lycoming, Lancair and the like have a vested interest in
maintaining their big advertising festival. Would not do to have some dirty
neck hot rodders with some $20K converted auto engine making a mockery of
their temperamental $100,000 hand grenades.
Racing in the unlimited class is a no go. To make an airframe that will go
that fast with a small lightweight rotary, even a four rotor, will result in
your being tossed about like so much fluff in the wake of those heavy old
fighter planes. Even with a comparable wing loading, size matters.
Besides, I am not convinced you can cool a high output/high duty cycle 4
rotor with out going to a parallel cooling arrangement.
An NXT type airframe optimized for liquid cooling using a turbo three rotor
would be very, very fast.
The NXT kept up with the field with much lower HP than the others are
running. Wait until it has comparable power and the bugs are worked out.
A similar sized airframe taking advantage of the rotary's size, designed for
liquid cooling, turbocharged, ADI injected, 3 rotor of even a meager 500hp
would do quite well. This level of performance is easily acheivable without
multi-million dollar budgets.
Using Vance's and my argument for displacement calculations a four rotor 16B
based engine would be 9.6 L or 585 in^3 and would be slightly less weight
than the piston engines being run now. It would make an absolute farce of
the field......IF it could be cooled and would not turn into a banana or
slinky at such power output levels. This level of performance is not
acheivable without multi-million dollar budgets.
I would love to build a turbo three rotor aircraft designed specifically for
such a mission. Unfortunately it winds up being a lousy sport airplane-high
wing loading and ugly landing speeds. Plus the required outlay is pretty
high considering there are no guarantees that it will be allowed to race.
Monty
You are not serious. My GOD the rotation of the rotor or the number
of pistons an engine is equipped with has absolutely nothing to
do with the amount of air the engine pumps. Displacement has been
defined since the beginning of the internal combustion engine as
the amount of air the engine pumps at a VE of 100% in one revolution
of the output shaft. It is arbitrary. It is not good nor bad or here
nor there... it is the LAW! It could just as easily have been cubic
feet of air per second or the size of a hole that all air must
pass through.
The phasing gears are NOT transmitting any torque. Zero torque in
case you are using that argument. They are merely positioning
the rotors. It could be cams or four bar linkages that position
the rotors. They are not "speeding" up the "output shaft" which is
the silly argument you guys are making.
Cubic feet of the intake chamber per one revolution
(torque changing gearing on the output shaft not with standing) is
how displacement is DEFINED! PERIOD! End of story!
Of course displacement has nothing to do with the power
to weight and power to physical volume of the engine
which is all that counts in an aircraft engine.
Come on guys give it up. It is not a 3.9 liter six cylinder
by any stretch of wild imagination.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.