Subject: Turbine on e-bay - fuel cons
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/1/2006, 12:06 PM
To: AA-me




    >> Paul
    >> The BSFC on the 420hp JetRanger is .417 according to my
   calculations.
    >>
    >>
    >>> [snip]
    >>>
    >>>
    >>> There is a fellow here in Austin that has a 1 set helicopter with
    >>> one of
    >>> these engines. I think he said it idles at 12 gph and 14 gph WOT.
    >>>
    >>> Bobby Hughes
    >>>
    >>> He is dreaming :) That is a BSFC of .525 no way in hell will that
    >>> happen
    >>> with a small turbine.
    >>>
    >>> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >>
    >>
    >>
    >> Paul
    >> The BSFC on the 420hp JetRanger is .417 according to my
   calculations.
    >> Kevin Jarvis
    >>
    >> If that really is the case why are we screwing around with
   rotary and
    >> piston
    >> engines let alone diesel engines :)
    >>
    >> Up load your calculations and we will see where you went wrong :)
    >> What HP are you using. Do you know? How are you measuring it?
    >> Do you have rotor torque and RPM numbers?
    >>
    >> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    >
    >
    > Paul.. these numbers below came from:
    > http://www.heliswiss.ch/en/home/jetranger.htm
    > Turbine: Allison 250-c20b
    > Performance: 420 HP
    > Fuel consumption: 100 l/h
    > 100l = 26.41gal [my calc]
    >
    > and then earlier today I stopped at the local Sheriffs hanger
   (Collier
    > County Fl.)
    > and asked one of the pilots about their Jet Ranger.  He said 22
   gal per
    > hr and
    > the same 420 hp.  That works out to even lower than .417
    > This is not hard to believe..
    > Kevin Jarvis
    >
    > Yes it is!
    > Keven, he is not running the engine at 420 HP. If the engine
   could do
    > that
    > there would be absolutely no need for diesel engines in tractor
    > trailer trucks or boats or anything else. That BSFC (.417) is in the
    > range of diesel engines. The entire world wide  piston engine
    > manufacturing
    > would cease tomorrow. The M1 A1 Abrams tank would have twice or three
    > times
    > the range it has now.
    >
    >
    > Turbine: Allison 250-c20b
    > Performance: 420 HP
    > Fuel consumption: 100 l/h
    > Rotor span: 10.16 m
    > Overall length: 11.82 m
    > Width: 1.92 m
    > Overall height: 2.90 m
    > Unloaded weight (without fuel): 820 kg
    >
    >
    > I can believe .65 BSFC for a good small turbine which would
    > be 26 GPH at 240 HP or about 60% max power. I know nothing about
    > helicopters.
    > Will they stay in the air at 60% power? How much power does it
    > take fully loaded? Empty and low on fuel? As I understand it take
   more
    > power to hover out of ground effect than it does to fly forward.
    >
    > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Paul
   I just talked to a MedEvac pilot that I know.  Their helo has a 723hp
   turbine.  They plan for fuel consumption of 53gph avg.

   That is BSFC of .488  They run the engine near max continuous nearly
   always.  He was familiar with the model turbine on eBay, said it came
   from a Chinook and would probably burn 10-12gph.  Not bad for 160hp,
   about .5 I think.

   As for routine operations, turbines are not run at 60% or 50% etc.  The
   engines in the Citation II run at 104% at altitude.  Anything less and
   the cost per mile increase, strange but true.  And as he said they run
   the Med helos at max cont.

   There are many reasons that we are not seeing turbines replacing diesels
   in trucks, boats, farm tractors etc.  Two come to mind, initial cost and
   the cost of operation considering the turbine runs better at max
   continuous rather than up and down the power scale as would happen with
   the truck, boat, tractor scenario.

   Kevin Jarvis

   "He was familiar with the model turbine on eBay, said it came
   from a Chinook and would probably burn 10-12gph.  Not bad for 160hp,
   about .5 I think."

   As a Chinook pilot why would he know what
   power level the Chinook APU was generating? Ask him how many
   watts the Chinook APU was generating at what altitude when it
   was burning 10-12gph.

   Dan Grey here at SZP has a Check turbo prop PT6 copy in his
   Legend he tells me it burns 50 gallons an hour at high altitude
   cruise were the power level is way down. A Turbo charged piston
   engine can generate far more power than a turbo prop at
   high altitudes.

   The Citation II engine is not a turbo prop engine nor is it used
   to power helicopters. Turbo fan engines are not rated in BSFC.
   They are rated in pounds of thrust per pound of fuel burned.
   Further more you are talking 40,000 feet while a helicopter
   finds it hard to get over 18,000 feet. The pounds of fuel
   burned in a Willams WJ24 is 1.2 pounds of fuel burned per
   pound of thrust. Apples and Oranges.

   Large turbo prop engines like the Allison shown here can get down
   to .53 BSFC. A far cry from .417. Unfortunately large turbo prop
   engines do not scale down well. The BSFC gets much much worse as you
   make them
   smaller. .65 BSFC is typical for small expensive turbo prop engines.
   The problem is simple geometry. As you make the engine smaller tip
   clearance between the compressor and turbine blades and the housings
   becomes critical. Also only two or three stages are used for the
   compressor
   and one for the turbine in small expensive engines. By contrast this
   Allison
   Has a dozen compressor stages and two or three turbine stages.
   An APU turbine is usually a glorified turbo charger with fuel
   burner.

   I would like to discuss this further but unfortunately my time
   is limited. I would like to focus here on the rotary engine.
   Far far more practical for experimental aircraft use.


   Paul Lamar

   -----------------------------------------------------------
   http://www.hal-india.com/Enginebangalore/products.asp


   DO-228.

   It has a single shaft centrifugal compressor engine rated at 715 shaft
   horse power at 1591 RPM output speed. Being a reverse flow gas turbine
   with a small frontal area it has better dry specifics and easier
   airframe
   integration. Apart from its simplicity of design and superior
   performance,
   the engine features a propeller control system, anti-icing and
   foreign object
   damage resistance, reverse thrust and negative torque sensing
   facilities.
   The division is also an authorised service centre for Garrett TPE
   331-5 series
   engines up to - 12.


   Main Characteristics
   Maximum diameter (m)    0.7
   Length (m)      1.11
   Weight (kg)     164
   Power   715
   Specific fuel consumption
   (kg / shp-hr) = 0.268  =   .59  BSFC

   ---------------------------------------------

   Artouste III B


   Artouste III B Engine powers both Cheetah and Chetak helicopters.
   The Engine manufacture commenced in 1962 under licence from
   Turbomeca, France.

   The Engine has side air intake, one axial and one centrifugal
   compressor connected
   to a three stage turbine. The power output is 550 SHP at 33500 RPM.
   The reduction
   gear box in the front transfers the power to helicopter. More than
   665 engines have been
   manufactured and 2950 engines overhauled & repaired for various
   customers.


   Main Characteristics
   Maximum diameter (m)    0.50
   Length (m)      1.815
   Weight (kg)     182
   Power   550
   Specific fuel consumption
   (kg / shp-hr)= 0.346  = .76 BSFC

   -----------------------------------------------------
   DART 533 - 2 AND 536 - 2T

   The Dart series of engines were manufactured since 1966. Under
   licence from Rolls Royce, UK but at present are being repaired
   and overhauled. Two Dart engines power HS-748 aircraft.

   This engine has two stage centrifugal compressors, three stage
   turbine and utilises water methanol injection to increase the
   shaft horse power.


   Main Characteristics
   Maximum diameter (m)    0.960
   Length (m)      2.490
   Weight (kg)     628.6

   Power(shp)
   533-2


   536-2T

   1835 (dry)
   1990 (wet)

   1835
   2040 (wet)
   Specific fuel consumption
   (kg / shp-hr) = 0.348 = .77 BSFC

   -----------------------------------------------------

   Gnome 1400 - IT

   The Gnome 1400 - IT engines being repaired and overhauled under licence
   from Rolls Royce, UK and is the power plant for Seeking helicopter.

   It is a turbo shaft single spool with 10 stage axial compressor,
   two stage turbine and free power turbine.


   Main Characteristics
   Maximum diameter (m)    0.574
   Length (m)      1.376
   Weight (kg)     168
   Power (shp)     1535
   Specific fuel consumption
   (kg / shp-hr) = 0.276 = .61 BSFC

   --------------------------
   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


>From RR themselves...

http://www.rolls-royce.com/service/downloads/amc_m250.pdf

Shows that the lowest (best) BSFC numbers for the 250 series is 0.574
which is achieved by the C40B at takeoff power.  Rated at 715hp..
Interestingly (predictably), the BSFC numbers are worse at reduced power
settings - cruise power BSFC is 0.591.  Almost all of the light domestic
turbine choppers run some flavor of this engine.  The lower power
versions have significantly worse BSFC - as bad as 0.706, which is given
for the B15A rated at 317hp.

Gas turbine efficiency as always is about thermodynamics.  The number of
spools (stages), the overall size, and the pressure ratio are the
biggest factors (hugely dominant) in determining the thermodynamic
efficiency. The larger, less "leaky", and more spools it has, the better
the thermodynamics work out.  Single spool turbines like the T62 are
limited by the physics of the machine.

When turbines are applied to a particular airframe, they are often given
a rating which is less than the max torque/temp(ITT) available from that
engine.  When an operator claims to run the turbine at 100%, that is
likely 100% of the rating for that application.  The derated value means
that the engine will suffer the poorer BSFC numbers associated with that
power setting.


Regards,

Matt-


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.