Subject: P38 plumbing history
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/9/2006, 11:05 AM
To: AA-me




              From the book
            * Vee's For Victory! by Daniel D. Witney. An extensive and
       comprehensive
            book on the history and engineering of the Allison V-1700
liquid
            cooled aircraft engine. 8.5 by 11, hard bound, 470 pages.
$59.95.
            Schiffer Military History. Atglen PA ISBN:0-7643-0561-1

            Note: little has changed in the past  70 years.

            Since nose up climb is the worse case Allison got it right
            here with the pressure tank mounted at the nose.
            Here is what I suggest at this point in time for our use.

            Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

            Ops not quite the 3D I wanted. Here it is along with the
"Sniffle"
            valve :)

            "Those that fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat
it."
            Somebody other than me but I don't remember who.

            Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


       So am I to infer that the idea of having a P tank and an A tank
is
no
       longer necessary?  I ask because the expansion & overflow tanks
are
the
       last pieces I need to order before mounting and connecting all
of
the
       engine plumbing.  What capacity are we looking for in the P tank
then?
       I presume it is larger than the 2-tank scheme, in order to make
room for
       excess capacity / air gap.

       Mark Supinski

       I think you can get along with just a pressure tank and a 30 psi
       pressure
       cap. The RX8 does (15 psi pressure cap). BTW your firewall is so
high
       you don't have to worry about mounting on the front of the
engine.
Mount
       it as high as you can get it on the firewall.
       --
       Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Actually, I was liking the front of engine position.  My firewall is
completely jammed with various things already, so the front position
(which is absolutely clear) was sounding good.

Mark Supinski



Go for it. Ed Klepeis can weld you up something that looks
like the RX8 version.

BTW you can point the overflow vent straight up through the cowling
and then just like a Model T or Model A Ford if you start making
steam you will know it in an instant :)

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
The drawing shows the P can's return line going to what appears to be
the wp outlet.  Unless I'm mistaken, it should be connected to the inlet
(lower) hose?

Mark S.

No that is the inlet line to the top of the P-can and it is coming from
the output
of the block. The restricted out line off the bottom of the P-can is
going to
the half way point in the rad. That will work but to me more
faithful to the RX8 plumping scheme that should go to the water
pump inlet side. I just did it that way to shorten the line.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
OK, I didn't see the line going from the bottom of the P tank to the
forward tank (half-way point) of the dual pass radiator.  That brings up
another question though.  If coolant is flowing from the P tank into the
upper radiator tank, then how does trapped air escape from the forward
tank of the radiator?  My system uses a cross-flow radiator and has a
bleed circuit that flows out of the radiator tank (on return side) and
into the top of the P tank.  From there the coolant is drawn out from
the bottom of the P tank into the inlet side of the wp, leaving the
trapped air in the P tank. I just don't see how trapped air can get out
of the upper radiator tank on your system.

Another question... Wouldn't the air and coolant be churned up into a
froth as it passes through the water pump so that it would make it
difficult to separate the air from the coolant?  I guess it would
eventually make its way into the P tank, but is seems like it would
happen faster if drawn from a less turbulent area.

Mark S.

Good point run a 1/4 inch vent line from the front of the rad to
the P-can. Or just hope the bubbles go up the down pipe. They
probably will.

Well more than one person says the dissolved air will eventually
make its way out of pressurized coolant and make its way to the top of
the
P-can. I am not so sure. You could put temporary transparent lines
in your system and see after performing  some ground runs.

You could also drill and tap into the output of the water pump where it
goes
into the block and feed that to the P-can. Probably the best of
all scenarios.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
Yes, I can see that the while filling either system that air trapped in
the radiator tank would migrate up the line to the P-tank.  That should
also happen whenever the engine is stopped, unless there is a sag in the
line which traps water and prevents the air to pass (similar to a P-trap
in your sink).  Your drawing shows that line running pretty much
vertical, so this probably isn't a concern.  So, most, if not all of the
air should be out of the radiator by the time you start the engine the
first time.  Any bubbles left in the upper tank would likely be drawn
into the coolant flow and eventually find their way to the P tank.

I'm still debating whether the line from the rear housing to the P tank
is necessary.  I've been told that water flow through the block is very
fast, like a fire hose.  If that's true, then any air should be forced
out of the block early on.  I guess it won't hurt anything, unless it
springs a leak.  Wouldn't a petcock work just as well, open it while
filling cooling system then close it when the system is full?  That's
what I do, except my tap is at the highest point in the engine, the top
of the thermostat housing.  Any remaining bubbles should be flushed out
and trapped in the P tank during the first engine run.

Lots to consider here.

Mark

Flow in the system is fast. The Mazda spec is 30 gallons per minute.

-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
I suspected something like that.  So, it would appear the rear housing
vent line would be good at removing air from the block while initially
filling the system, or when the engine is not running, or at very low
rpm.  When at higher rpm, it will pass lots of coolant, and very little
air.  Hopefully, by that time most of the air will be out of the system
and it won't really matter.

Mark


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2005 All world wide rights reserved.