Subject: Aircraft Fuel System - Poor Design - Another Accident!
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/18/2006, 11:54 AM
To: AA-me


Report from Craig Catto:

Also, please tell everyone thank you so much for all your thoughts and
prayers for my 17 year old daughter Sara.  She was involved in an accident
with her flight instructor last August 3rd.  Sara has made a miracle
recovery from her major injury of a fractured L2 vertebra that was floating
in her spinal canal.  It was almost an identical injury to what Wayne Handly
experienced and is on the Discovery Medical channel.  A team of 7 specialist
doctors was put together and Sara underwent 8 hours of surgery, and was
successful and no damage to the spinal canal. Sara was finishing up her
private from a flying scholarship she won from the Woman in Aviation
Foundation.

Seven weeks later she started Cal Poly San Luis Obispo where she was
accepted in Aerospace Engineering after graduating Valedictorian at her high
school.  Over Christmas break she finally got out of the hard tortoise shell
brace and now has only a velcro type corset brace.

It is frustrating for me and for my daughter as this accident never should
have happened. As probably with most accidents.

On a night flight before the morning of the accident, Sara and her flight
instructor borrowed a Beech that Sara had never flown, and the instructor
had only 1 hour in, this as all the 172's were down.  On the two hour night
flight, the instructor briefing Sara did not use a checklist, and the
instructor decided to use the right fuel tank. Both tanks were full.  In
doing this on the 2 hour night  flight, the aircraft fuel injection system
recycles fuel back into the left tank, the tank that was suppose to be used.

What happened was for two hours, the excess of about 7 gallons an hour was
being pumped out of the left tank  fuel vent. 30 gallon tank, 2 hours fuel
burn, and 14 gallons overboard.

In the morning, they were to return the aircraft to its home base, only
about 5 minute flight away, and Sara was instructed to load up the plane and
fasten the instructors 5 year old daughter in the back seat while the
instructor did the preflight.  Assuming there was at least half tank
available on the right and full on the left, she did not check the tanks and
they proceeded back to the home base on the right tank.

In the pattern at the home base, the right tank went dry and the engine quit
downwind to base.  The instructor opted to try and make the airport vs. the
nearby field. Trying to stretch the glide the stall buzzer went off and they
pancaked into a river
levee and the aircraft broke in half.

It is really a miracle they all survived, the daughter was not hurt, the
flight instructor is currently in a wheel chair with major back injuries.


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.