Subject: NACA Report No. 822 on turbo compounding.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/21/2006, 10:36 PM
To: AA-me


    >
    > NACA REPORT No. 822
    >
    > CALCULATIONS OF ECONOMY OF 18-CYLINDER RADIAL AIRCRAFT ENGINE
    > WITH EXHAUST-GAS TURBINE GEARED TO THE CRANKSHAFT
    >
    > By RICHARD W. HANNUM and RICARD H. ZIMMERMAN
    >
    > SUMMARY
    >
    > Calculations based on dynamometer test-stand data obtained on an
   18-cylinder
    > radial
    > engine were made to determine the improvement in fuel consumption
   that can be
    > obtained at various altitudes by gearing an exhaust gas turbine
   to the engine
    > crankshaft in order to increase the engine-shaft work. The
   calculations
    > indicted
    > that, for turbine and auxiliary supercharger efficiencies of 85
   percent
    > minimum
    > net brake specific fuel consumption improvements of 0.357 pound
   per brake
    > horse
    > hour at an altitude of 10,000 feet and of 0.323 pound per brake
   horsepower
    > hour
    > at 30,000 feet can be obtained by gearing the exhaust-gas turbine
   to the
    > engine
    > crankshaft and operating that engine at a speed of 2,000 rpm, an
    > inlet-manifold
    > pressure of 40 inches [5 psi boost] of mercury absolute, and a
   fuel-air ratio
    > of 0.063 [12:1].
    >
    > The reduction in net brake specific fuel consumption that can be
   obtained if
    > the exhaust-gas turbine supplies all the auxiliary supercharger
   power and if
    > its residual power is transmitted through gears to the engine
   crankshaft as
    > compared with auxiliary turbo supercharging, is approximately 14
   percent at
    > an altitude of 10,000 feet and 21 percent at 30,000 feet.
    > The net brake specific fuel consumption is a minimum is for
   engine exhaust
    > gas pressure approximately 25 percent above inlet-manifold
   pressure and varies
    > only slightly from that minimum for a range of exhaust gas pressure
    > from 6 to 45 percent above inlet-manifold pressure.
    >
    > INTRODUCTION
    >
    > The use of an exhaust-gas turbine to drive a supercharger at high
   altitudes
    > is an effective method of maintaining sea level engine power at
   altitude.
    > Analysis has shown, however, that the waste energy of exhaust
   gases is
    > recovered more effectively by maintaining an engine exhaust
   pressure higher
    > than the minimum required for turbo supercharging and thus
   increasing the
    > work output of the exhaust-gas turbine. The extra turbine power
   beyond that
    > required for supercharging Can be supplied to the engine
   crankshaft through
    > suitable gearing (compound operation).
    >
    > The purpose of the analysis reported is to determine the
   improvement in net
    > brake specific fuel consumption that can be obtained if an engine
   is equipped
    > with a geared turbine and supercharger as compared with the
   engine using a
    > standard turbo supercharger. The calculated values specific fuel
   consumption
    > presented for an engine-turbine combination were based on NACA
   test data
    > obtained on an 18-cylinder radial engine. Operating conditions
   for which the
    > brake specific fuel consumption of the combination is a minimum
   are given.
    > The required turbine-nozzle area is also calculated to indicate
   the size of
    > turbine suitable for geared operation.
    >
    > Because the engine, the turbine, and the supercharger have different
    > characteristics, elements designed to give maximum efficiency at some
    > operating conditions are incorrectly matched at other conditions.
   Provision
    > must therefore be made to obtain satisfactory performance over
   the entire
    > operating range. The problem of obtaining a wide operating range
   is briefly
    > discussed.
    >
    > The investigation reported was conducted at the NACA Cleveland
   Laboratory
    > in the fall of 1944.
    >
    > -------------------------------------------------------
    > First the rotary is a very mechanically robust engine that
   tolerates high
    > boost
    > pressures. The Achilles heel of this technique proved over time
   to be the
    > failure of the piston engine exhaust valves when the exhaust gas
   pressure was
    > 25%
    > higher than the intake pressure.
    >
    > Guess what? The rotary has no exhaust valve.
    >
    > The full 9 page report is obtainable from:
    > http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/
    > In pdf form.
    >
    > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Paul

   I want to include a link to the turbo compounding report I am
   working on. I
   searched the data base under simple, advanced and even browsed all
   papers in
   1944 and 45. No luck. What is the link to this paper?


   Thanks

   Doug.

   I thought I sent the pdf to you. Do you have a size limit on your email?
   I'l send it to you again. The NASA search engine sucks. You almost need
   the full title and Report Number. http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/
   The scan rez was awful in the bargain.
   I sent email to NASA complaining about the scan rez.


   Dang I just tried putting in the complete title and it said "not found".
   Perhaps this is the problem.

   "These documents are in the process of being fully integrated into
   the NACA TRS collection. They are not searchable at this time."

   Annual Reports (AR)
   Research Memorandum (RM)
   Technical Memorandum (TM)
   Technical Notes (TN)
   Technical Reports (TR)
   Wartime Reports (WR)

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
   I had the same problem trying to find the paper.  Finallly I did a
   search using the title and found it.

   http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/reports/1945/naca-report-822/

   Joel
   Over the Hill Materials E


I tried it and it workded for me too. That is so strange.
As I said the NASA search engine sucks. They need to help of
google.

Just for the heck of it I put "NACA report 822" into google and I got it
as well. Looks like NASA should just give up and go with google :)

I'll try google on some of the other NASA papers I am looking for.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.