Gordan and Hans,
I want to thank you guys for bringing this subject up. I thought about
it a lot
in the last 12 hours. A fixed ratio has some other bad effects. It is
possible
to overload the traction drive HP wise by zinging the engine up with
little or
no load such as a fine pitch or fixed pitch prop or on a dyno with
no load what so ever. This is because of the rotational inertia of the
turbine is added to the rotational inertia of the compressor and both
are spinning
at 20 times engine RPM.
Another bad effect it has is it limits the range of ratios possible
between
box and engine. One must always think of not exceeding the turbine red
line of about 120,000 RPM at max engine RPM so that severly limits the
choice of ratios used.
So I have decided to put in a one way clutch. This now means you could
use
a ratio of as little as 1:10 and get power out of the turbine at
60,000 RPM
(if it were available) while the engine is running at 6000 RPM. In
fact the
coupling will not lock up until the traction box output RPM exceeds
the engine RPM.
I now understand and believe this feature is essential.
I will upload a drawing shortly.
I was concerned about the traction drive overload on acceleration too,
but then thought about the rotrex application, they drive a compressor
with their traction drive. Have you calculated the torque loads? Of
course you are right about adding the turbine inertia as well, but the
turbine should be putting in some torque in too. You will lose some
responsiveness with a sprag clutch preventing the engine from driving
the turbine/compressor assembly, but it is a reasonable choice. It
would be good to datalog the RPM differences across the one-way (sprag)
clutch at various loads, RPM's etc to see if it really is a problem.
One concern that pops into my non-engineer mind, is will the sudden
engagment of the clutch create to much of a load on the
turbine/compressor assembly? It may be gentler to not have a clutch.
Without the clutch, the engine will have some more inertial load and
will spool up slower until the exhaust energy takes over the inertial
load of the turbine/compressor and reduction drive.
I don't see how a one way clutch will expand your choice of ratios.
Care to elaborate? As I see it you probably want to pick your ratio so
that at cruise RPM you are in the sweet spot of the compressor chart,
for best efficiency, and not exceeding the compressor RPM limits at max
engine RPM. I think you want big pieces, larger turbines and
compressors for efficiency reasons. This is uncharted territory of
course, will require trial and error fitment.
One other point Paul, I like your compact manifold for its simplicity,
but I think there is VE to be gained by using tuned lengths, have you
considered a rolled 32 inch primary manifold?
Hans
Lets say we had a 20:1 fixed ratio. 10:1 in the box and 2:1 in the belt. No clutch.
That would limit max engine RPM to 6000 RPM. With clutch the engine will
over run the box at anything over 120,000 turbine RPM red line and 6000 engine RPM.
We can limit turbine RPM with a waste gate or largef compressor.
No matter the ratio with clutch the engine will never force the
turbocharger to exceed what ever RPM it wants to do.
Which manifold. The one in the last 3D is not complete. For max torque
and max BSFC at 6000 RPM the optimum runner lenght is around 25 inches.
Max HP is around 7000 RPM with this manifold length.
Optimum exhaust pipe lenght is 32 inches long because the speed of sound
is 1700 FPS in the hot exhaust gases rather than 1000 FPS in the cool intake
manifold air.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.