Subject: Aluminium end housings
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/30/2006, 3:06 PM
To: AAme





   Hi Paul & all,

   "Subject: More comments from Paul Lamar
   As back ground info on the rotary. The bare engine block weighs about
   190 pounds with cast iron end housings. About 140 pounds with aluminum
   end housings."

   Anyone flying with these aluminum end housings? Any links to more info?
   (Please excuse my ignorance if these are well known or previously
   discussed items)

   Thanks,
   Hennie

   ---------------------------------------------------------

   Never a problem on previously discussed items.
   That is why we are here.

   Not that I know of now. Allan Tolle probably flew an Everett Hatch
   all aluminum engine ten years ago or so.

   They are rather expensive. At about $1200 to $1500 USD
   from Racing Beat. The rear and two rotor intermediate housings
   in this 3 rotor engine  picture are aluminum.

   There is some question about the wear surface process and durability.
   Racing Beat would not tell me what the wear surface process was so I
   doubt it
   was detonation gun coated. If I were building all aluminum end housings
   I would brag about using proven, expensive detonation gun coatings.
   IMHO the ONLY reliable  way of doing an all aluminum end housing IMHO.

   If the wear surface does not hold up on these Racing Beat aluminum
   end housing you could always have them detonation gun re coated
   with silicon carbide and diamond reground.

   Richard Sohn is also developing a two piece end housing with
   cast iron wear surface.  <unicorn@gdsys.net <mailto:unicorn@gdsys.net>>

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


   Paul,
   Have you heard anything good about the process called Electrochemical
   Metallizing?  I got this off the Swain web site
   (http://www.swaintech.com/weld.html).

   <snip>
   Electrochemical Metallizing
   Metallizing is often used to describe wire flame spr-
   aying. The flame spraying process, however, should not be confused with
   electro chemical metallizing, an out-of-tank plating process for adding
   a metal coating to a metal substrate.
   Electrochemical metallizing is a technological br-
   eakthrough, an improvement over a process originally termed "brush
   plating". Thin (0.0001 in. to 0.01 in.) metallic coatings are
   applied at
   low temperature. A dc power pack has two flexible leads. One goes to the
   workpiece and the other connects to one of a number of working tools or
   styli. Anodes of different sizes and shapes are connected to the end of
   the stylus and wr-
   apped with an absorbent material. The covered anodes are dipped into the
   plating solutions, or the solutions are pumped to the anodes when the
   areas to be coated are large.
   The positive lead from the dc power pack is  connected to the work tool
   and the negative lead is connected to the workpiece. An electrical
   circuit is completed when the wrapped tool and workpiece are brought
   close to one another, resulting in metal being deposited from the liquid
   solution onto the metal base.
   More than 100 primary metals and alloys can be deposited by this method,
   including nickel, copper, tungsten, cobalt, gold, silver, tin, zinc,
   Babbit, cad-
   mium, lead, and nickel-tungsten.
   Electrochemical metallizing applications include repairing damaged
   printed circuit boards, dented molds, scored or pitted hydraulic rams,
   damaged pr-
   inting press rolls, and dented or cracked extrusion dies, and resizing
   pins or gates. Electrochemical met-
   allizing is also used for military repairs, as it meets many military
   specifications for wear, corrosion, and resizing
   <snip>

   Years ago we used to use an oxy-acetylene torch setup to spray powdered
   metal onto construction equipment wear surfaces such as backhoe buckets.
   It was subjected to extraordinary conditions and survived.  I haven't
   done anything along those lines since then.  According to Swain Tech,
   the process has advanced considerably.  I was wondering if this could be
   an economical solution to the aluminum end housings?
   Mark Steitle

   One thou (.001) is not very thick.
   It might be but the big problem is different materials on aluminum.
   There is a temperature expansion difference to contend with.
   Detonation gun coating actually embeds the wear surface particles
   into the
   aluminum as they impact the aluminum at super sonic velocities.
   The particle size can be varied to optimize the results. In a way it is
   similar, (on a microscopic level) to the SIP process Mazda uses for
   rotor housings. There is a mechanical lock between the steel liner
   and the aluminum. It has been proven to work on aluminum end housings by
   Mazda and others. Why risk anything else unless you are General Motors,
   Ford, Mazda, Toyoto etc. etc. ? I don't know of anybody with the
   $$$$$ resources to
   test 500 engines for 500 hours each to see if something new works.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


I've been buying airplane parts again recently..   $1200-$1500 doesn't
seem all that expensive to me when I am considering $6000 to TOH the
O470 with ECI cylinders (with a good discount).  Even if I had to pay
full price to Racing Beat, and then ship the parts off to someone else
for the det-gun coating, it wouldn't be too bad.  How much does the
det-gun finish cost?  $1000 per item?  I doubt it's that much.  That
would give our power/weight numbers a really nice boost.  I might
consider putting an all Aluminum P-port onto my Varieze.  It's fairly
common for a Varieze to have an O-320 on it, though it causes it to
glide like a manhole cover.


Matt-

The biggest problem Matt is you will wind up with a forward  CG problem :)

-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.