Subject: CARB VS FI
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/13/2006, 5:39 PM
To: AAme



   No matter what system you run (carb or FI) it does not matter where
        the butterfly resides when at WOT if the throttle is in the intake
        tube.  You could mount a side draft carb next to the block and use
        any length tubing needed to tune for max power.  As soon as you
        stick a butterfly or slide in the airflow you will no longer get
        organ pipe tuning.  If you want to tune for cruise you must
   have the
        throttle as part of the intake plenum rather than a part of the
        intake tube.

        Ken Powell
        Bryant, Arkansas
        501-847-4721
        C150 / RV-4 under construction

Ken,

Exactly the reason that motorcycles long ago went to slide throttle
carbs! Also why they are now going to EFI. The newest direct injection
from Siemens (used on the newest Audis) will soon be able to use
stratified charge and NO throttle valve like diesels to lessen pumping
losses. previous systems didn't have fast enough response in the
injectors to do this. They are using pezio actuated injectors to lessen
the response time.

Bill Jepson

BTW If the throttle is in the plenum and is not wide open you
still get the pumping losses. I think Tracy is attempting
to cruise is RV8 at aircraft drag minimum drag so that is probably down
around 140 MPH or so. In that case WOT might be too much power
at anything less than say 12,000 feet.

Also BTW when I say "carb" I mean aircraft carb which is a very simple
device. Also very reliable other than the occasional sunk float :)
(Happened to me once flying a rental 172)

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.