Subject: importance of proper turbo intercooling
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/28/2006, 11:54 AM
To: AAme



This is germane to all who want to turbo charge the rotary.

Marc Wiese

From: John Deakin <jdeakin@advancedpilot.com

Subject: importance of proper turbo intercooling There was a vigorous
"discussion" on the Beech List awhile back, and George Braly took the
time to write an outstanding message for the benefit of all. It's worth
passing on here to those of you not on that list.



George wrote: For a year, I spent a good portion of my time
re-engineering an intercooler installation and obtaining FAA approval
for the changes. Very careful instrumentation and measurement. I have
more recently done more of that with a different engine on the engine
test stand (see www.engineteststand.com
<http://www.engineteststand.com>). I learned a lot. I am a strong
supporter of intercoolers, so some of what I am going to say may sound
strange at first. So, here goes: Frankly most of the conventional wisdom
on this subject - - like a lot of the now famous LOP/ROP discussions - -
is simply not true. Almost everything anyone writes on this subject, in
theory is correct. But the practical application results in an outcome
that is rather different than everybody anticipates. It is largely a
myth that, at sea level, on the takeoff roll, that 30" of MP AFTER the
intercooler gets you more HP than 30" of MP BEFORE adding the
intercooler. Can it be done? Maybe, but not likely. Can it be done in
cruise at low altitude? More likely, but only. (Note: this is different
than comparing a normally aspirated sea level engine on the takeoff
roll, which will have, maybe 28.5" of MP --after the filter and after
the "suck down" from the engine induction pumping. In that case, the
extra 1.5 " of MP you get from the turbo system at 30" Hg makes up for
the back pressure of the exhaust and the nominal temp rise.) In fact, a
poorly executed intercooler installation can - - and often does - -
result in LESS horsepower at sea level than the same engine without the
intercooler. I know of one instance where one of the major OEM suppliers
of intercooler "engineered" an 'improved' intercooler for one turbo
system. They seriously improved the intercooler efficiency, according to
their calculations and according to flight test measurements. However,
the aircraft performance went down! Why? Because in order to improve the
intercooler efficiency, they ended up adding so much pressure drop
across the induction air path that the pressure drop across the
intercooler became excessive and the turbo back pressure required to
support the higher upper deck pressure ended up costing horsepower and
being counter-productive. I don't know who started the whole theory of
de-rating manifold pressure of an engine after an intercooler in typical
general aviation add-on intercooler installations, but I doubt it was
somebody who was actually measuring the engine torque - accurately - -
rather, they were just following the theory and making the calculations,
etc. (And, yes, I have heard a story about one after market intercooler
outfit that claims to have put a torque meter on before issuing the
reduced MP instructions based on that result... but until I see the
data, I will have a very hard time with that notion.) The big problem is
that in the euphoria over the large and very beneficial drop in
Induction Air Temperatures (IAT) that one gets with an intercooler, the
designers of that system forget all about something else: How much of
the "good stuff" (ie, good, cold, high density air) you can get into the
cylinder on each intake stroke - - also depends on how much of the BAD
STUFF (ie, exhaust products) you got out of the cylinder on the previous
exhaust stroke. Getting rid of the 'bad stuff' is strongly influenced by
the exhaust back pressure. The ratio of MP/ExBackPressure is one of the
terms in the equations that try to describe cylinder volumetric
efficiency. That ratio of the new "good stuff" to the total cylinder
volume, is called the cylinder volumetric efficiency Ve. When you add an
intercooler, you place a restriction in the intake plumbing. That means
that the compressor discharge pressure is now two or three (or 4 or 5 in
one case) inches of Hg higher than the wide open throttle MP!!! In order
to generate that extra pressure, the compressor has to work harder. And
that means that the turbo has to work harder. And that means that the
wastegate is closed a bit more. And THAT means the exhaust back pressure
(potato in tail pipe) increases and that reduces the cylinder volumetric
efficiency. Result? The improved number of molecules you get into the
cylinder due to the denser air (as described in the theory) is
frequently nicely offset by the effects of the exhaust back pressure on
Ve. Thus, often there is no net increase in useful mass airflow through
the cylinder. And the result of that is no net increase in horsepower at
the same MP. This is all more enhanced at lower altitudes and lower
airspeeds (ie, takeoff roll - when you want it most!) when the
intercooler has very low efficiency because of low flow of cooling air.
Now... having said THAT - - in my view, it is almost criminal for
anybody to operate a turbocharged engine without an intercooler. There
are excellent old SAE research papers that show a HUGE improvement in
the detonation tolerance of these engines by use of even a modestly
efficient intercooler. These improvements are not trivial. They are
substantial. Installing an intercooler means that you are very very much
less likely to inadvertently cause detonation during a moment of
inattention during a busy high power climb in an IFR environment - -
when you accidentally fail to have the mixture rich enough. Lots of
other benefits. For the same reasons, it lowers peak cylinder pressures
substantially and that seriously promotes reduced exhaust valve
temperatures and greater valve and cylinder longevity. Last, and this is
something almost nobody appreciates, adding an intercooler results in
much better fuel atomization by your fuel injectors during high power
operation. Like I said, the "conventional" wisdom on this subject is
seriously flawed. The benefits of intercoolers are sort of over promoted
for the wrong reasons and vastly under promoted for the right reasons
all at the same time. They are generally a good investment.


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.