Subject: Alternator Terminals -- I mean "Starter" terminals
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/1/2006, 11:57 AM
To: AAme

        I can't think of anything wrong with the idea as far
        as it working is concerned.

        Why do you want to keep power out of the high amp
        lead going to the starter from the positive stud on
        the battery? Seems to me you have more
        connections to possibly fail not to mention the extra
        weight of the additional contactor.

        It does indeed look like a 2nd gen RX7 starter.

        Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

        ---------------------------------------------------

        I had an automotive starter wired like that on my Lyc. RV4 and
   it worked
        fine, the trouble was the starter would not last, the main
   contacts kept
        wearing out, only lasted about 100 or 200 starts before having to
        replace it.

        Chuck D.

        --------------------------------------


        Hi Paul,

        The plane that I have is an Osprey 2.  With the engine on a
   pylon, I
        cannot
        have the battery inside the engine compartment due to the limited
        cowling
        space.  So by having the battery inside the cockpit, I wanted to
        limit the
        amount of juice going into the pylon -- to avoid any accidental
        shorts etc.
        But, I'm still bouncing the idea around of having a
   continuously hot
        lead
        going to the pylon -- because why would I be having any shorts if I
        designed
        it correctly.

        Cheers,

        Burck


   Mine is wired as you describe.  I have a starter contactor on the
   firewall which is connected to  the starter button.  When activated  it
   connects the battery to the starter.  I jumper the now-hot starter wire
   to the solenoid so it is activated whenever the main wire goes hot. If I
   were really anal retentive, I would wire the solenoid activator in
   parallel with the starter contactor activator -- that way both would
   have to fail for me to end up with a runaway starter.

   Mark Supinski

   Mark did you read what Chuck Dunlap said about the main contacts
   wearing out?

   What is your reason for wiring it like that? Just curious.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



I followed the logic from the AeroElectric connection.  There is endless
discussion on that list - but suffice to say I decided to go the starter
contactor route.  With respect to Chuck's report of the "main contacts
wearing out," I don't have any comment.  The only unique part of my
wiring is that the main supply line is de-energized when not in use.
It's not clear to me why that would affect the starter contacts in any
way.  In any case - there are many aircraft flying this configuration &
I have not seen a pattern of reports along the lines of what Chuck has
experienced.

Mark Supinski

What is the AeroElectric logic for this strange
practice?

The only thing I can thing of is a possible timing problem with
the contactors. The starter solenoid and contactor is designed to
be fed through a 14 gage wire. As the voltage is suddenly
applied to the starter solenoid with a start push button the
current builds up relatively slowly due to the inductance of
the solenoid. It takes a finite period of time for the solenoid
to engage the starter pinion gear to the ring gear and then
the starter contactor closes and energizes the starter motor.
The same thing happens in the starter motor. It take a finite
length of time until the current builds up in the starter
motor winding and torque is applied to the starter pinion gear.

This has been tested hundreds of millions of times over
a period of many years in zillions of cars.

I think it is a dumb idea to defeat this system. I don't
exactly know what is happening with the contactors without
hooking them up to a digital scope with event capture capability.

I could do that as I have a digital scope but why mess with
mother nature unless there is a very good reason to do so.

Frankly I would stick to the way Mitsubishi engineers designed it.
They know what they are doing and they are by no means stupid.

As far as air cooled aircraft engine starters are concerned
they could be designed differently and require a remote
contactor.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.