Comment from electronic engineer.
Bob Y
"Hey Bob it sounds like someone is thinking about the problem.
However, my memory, and this is from a long time back, is that
555s do not produce real pulse width stability in digital circuits.
I have avoided them and use a xtal oscillator in my Rotor Alarm
system in the helicopter.
Stuart & Kathryn Fields,"
------------------------------------------
It depends on what degree of stability one is talking
about. There is absolutely no doubt crystal oscillators
are several orders of magnitudes more stable than any
solid state RC oscillator including the 555.
However we are interested in pulse widths of several milliseconds
triggered by the e-shaft sensor while a low speed crystal oscillator
runs at 37,000 cycles per second. That is one part in 37,000
while a millisecond is one part in only 1000. Most crystal
oscillators are several million cycles per second. If you use
digital counters to count these crystal oscillators down there
is no doubt very stable pulse widths can be generated.
But so what? It is WAY overkill and WAY more expensive.
We are looking for averages. If the injector pulse width varies
by plus or minus 10% from pulse to pulse or e-shaft rotation
to e-shaft rotation it has absolutely no effect on the engine
as long as the average pulse width is the desired value. There
is no way the engine can vary its output in one one thousands
of a second or one millisecond. At 8000 RPM or 133 RPS it takes
.0075 seconds or 7.5 milliseconds to make one revolution.
BTW Klaus is telling me the Continental O-200 engine in his
Varieze is getting 100 mpg at 110 kts at altitude using a
555 based EFI system. No crystal oscillator or computer involved.
I am talking about a complete 555 based EFI system costing less
than 100 dollars while the cheapest crystal oscillator based
micro computer system, the Megasquirt, is over $300 (completely
assembled). Tracy Crook's dual system is over $750 and many like the
Haltech are over $1000. Plus the 555 EFI is a super simple system
and anybody that can tie their own shoe laces can fix it or build
it from scratch.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.