Subject: Battery post damage (was: Flywheel)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/3/2006, 9:00 AM
To: AAme



   This reminds me of the folks that remove battery terminals with a
big screwdriver instead of a terminal puller. The terminal indeed comes
off the post either way, but the seal at the base of the post is ruined
if you use a screwdriver. When the seal is ruined, the post will corrode
and fail in a few months. These same folks install the terminal with a
hammer. This also ruins the seal. When you mention this to someone
wielding the big screwdriver, they invariably say, "Been do'in it this
way fer years. Works jes fine."

Bill Dube'

That is hardly a good analogy as it is easy to see the damage
on a battery post seal. It is impossible to find the damage on
any rotary engine part after removing the flywheel with a good
wack :)

BTW In 60 years of fooling with cars I have never seen
anybody use a gear puller on the battery cable clamp :)
But then again I don't fool with electric cars (other than
the occasional road test for Pop Science or one of the
SF local newspapers.)


  Actually, it is NOT easy to see the damage on a battery post seal.
It is a surprisingly fragile seal. They bubble test them in the assembly
line for AGMs because you can't tell if they are damaged by visual
inspection. (This is exactly like the hidden damage to the hammered
flywheel.)

  If you damage the seal, you probably won't see it at the time, but
you see the result a few months later. If you ever see terminal
corrosion on an AGM (sealed battery) it is because someone installed the
terminals with the wrong tools and damaged the seal(s). They don't ever
corrode otherwise. Also, this same battery will have greatly reduced
life because it won't properly pressurize. It will lose water though the
broken seal quite quickly.

  A battery post puller is a just a few dollars.  The terminal comes
off faster and easier with the puller than it does with a big
screwdriver. Why do a job the hard way and the wrong way on purpose?

Bill Dube'

There is no hidden or any other kind of damage on the "hammered"
flywheel. Besides... none of us use them again if they were
damaged which they are not. I have never heard of a "hammered"
flywheell exploading after being reinstalled.
Who in their right mind is going to put a 35 pound flywheel
on an aircraft engine anyway? :)

I'll go down and examine closely my "hammered" flywheel
and see if I can even detect where I hit it :)
If it is dented I will have to throw it away and not
use it as I intended as a boat anchor :)

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.