> I have a question for Paul Lipps. The Xfoil program will graphically
> portray the pressure distribution forces across the airfoil. The
pressure
> distributions forces are used to predict lift and lift is used to predict
> thrust. However, if the summation vector of pressure forces is different
> than the lift force vector it would seem to be more accurate to
predict the
> thrust directly from the summation force vector (the vector resulting
from
> the summation of all of the discrete pressure forces). I don't
believe the
> conventional prop modeling programs do this. Is the coefficient of
moment
> (Cm) related to this? Can Cm be used to predict airfoils that would
be more
> favorable for converting engine power to thrust?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Del Johnson
Hi, Del!
I started off with the Basic program in Marty Hollman's book, then
added some elements such as Re, Mach, compressibility, and element
lengths of 1" rather than 0.1 span. I also used F=M*A to calculate lift
and induced drag rather than the complex formula in that program.
Aspect ratio of a propeller can not be taken as blade span^2/area, as Q
must be accounted for in the lift distribution, i.e., a rectangular
blade would appear as a wing with narrow root chord expanding almost
exponentially toward an extremely wide chord at the tip. Wing aspect
ratio considers constant velocity/Q over every part of the wing. A
rectangular blade would appear to have this exponential planform-derived
lift distribution, which, when modified by the Shrenck method, would
still apppear to have most of the lift in the outboard regions with the
root region contributing nothing. This gives much greater bending forces
in the root region, as well as causing much reduced efficiency since the
entire blade does not contribute equally to the lift. I calculate the
thrust/torque all along the blade. It is almost the same from the root
out toward the tip, then drops off toward the tip due to the high tip
losses. Keep in mind, 1lb drag at a 3' tip consumes 3 times as much
power as 1lb at 1' root and 6 times as much as at a 6" spinner! A wide
tip has no lift but only drag, and high Mach CD drag at that,
proportional to the chord! Paul
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.