I have been a member for many years and enjoy reading Sport Aviation.
This month was an exception. Ken Scott wrote an article comparing
PowerSport Rotary engines in VAN's RV aircraft with factory recommended
Lycoming. Last time I heard Van himself speak about putting anything BUT
Lycoming in his babies, he was very much against it.... today his web
site is chilly at best on the idea. Now here is where the editors of
Sport Aviation crossed the line. It seems that Ken Scott has financial
gain from Van's Aircraft.
http://www.vansaircraft.com/public/eaa-ye.htm
This certainly would taint his story to the corporate tune Van would
like to hear. especially since Van's Aircraft is a dealer for Lycoming
and not for PowerSport. This would explain the extraordinary fuel burn
the Rotary engines reported displayed and such descriptives as "outraged
vacuum cleaner".
This story should have been marked at "SPECIAL ADVERTISING" or at the
very least the editors should have explained at the top of the story
Ken's relationship to Van's Aircraft. Without this commonly accepted
professional journalistic practice, your magazine becomes like so many
other trade journals we get for free every day.
-David Arbogast
PS - Small world it seems that Ken and Van are both members of EAA 105
among many other connections:
http://www.eaa105.org/History/history.htm
In December is was the spokesman for Van's Aircraft
http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=15831491&BRD=2318&PAG=461&dept_id=484045&rfi=6
And at one time was "a company pilot" for Van's Aircraft.
http://dev.pilotweb.co.uk/content/articles/view_article.aspx?id=780
David,
Thanks for the heads-up on this. It is indeed very poor journalism to
have an author that is closely linked to one side of the story. What is
totally unacceptable is when that link is not disclosed in the article.
However, the reality is that most "enthusiast" magazines practice a very
low grade of journalism -- if it can even be called journalism. It's
more like advertising masquerading as articles. This is true for all the
popular car, motorcycle, aviation, boating, etc. magazines. The car
magazine editors practically live with the automakers' PR people gorging
themselves in a nonstop feeding frenzy of corporate freebies, junkets
and other goodies.
Also the level of writing -- if it can be called such -- is generally
atrocious. Stories are typically fluff designed to pander to major
advertisers.
Flying magazine is a good example of this. I remember a few years ago
when there was a spate of fatal Cirrus crashes, Dick Collins wrote a
piece questioning the fact that Cirrus did not have to spin-certify its
airplane because it had the parachute. Poor old crusty Collins. I guess
being an old-timer he remembered the days when that rag had some
integrity and you called things as you saw them, advertisers be damned.
Well, Cirrus pulled its advertising for about a year. All the while the
spineless Flying editor, J. Maclellan was backpedaling furiously, trying
to gladhand Cirrus at every opportunity. There must have been a Cirrus
on the cover every other month, and glowing write-ups in every issue.
Finally, after Cirrus figured it had bitch-slapped Flying enough to make
their point, they started advertising again and all was peachy. Even
poor old Collins started saying nice things and even went so far as to
"amend" his previous thinking on spin testing. I guess Mac must have
given him a pretty good lashing too.
I won't even mention the other rags like Kitplanes and such which are
really worse than a joke.
Within "real" journalism circles, the enthusiast magazine sector is
considered a joke. Few of the writers or editors are true professionals,
or have even been near a journalism school. It is unrealistic to expect
any kind of quality, or even fairness in their content. Really, the only
aviation magazine that can be said to be a real magazine is Smithsonian
Air & Space. But it doesn't really even fall within the enthusiast
sector, strictly speaking.
Still, Sport Aviation being a member-supported magazine should aim for
better. Unfortunately they are getting worse and worse and will soon be
as bad as the rest. There are still some informative articles here and
there, but a lot of it is advertising-driven fluff.
Regards,
Gordon.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.