Subject: May 2007 Sport Aviation Article.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/13/2006, 3:00 PM
To: AAme

      >
      > Great article on rotaries vs recip in the
May issue
      > of
      > Sport Aviation!!!
      >
      > Dr. Bill Doell

     I didn't think it was so great. The conclusion
was that the
     rotaries were
     maybe OK, but the fuel consumption was
prohibitive. One of
     the rotaries
     burned about 30% more fuel than the O-320 to
cover the
     same distance just a little bit faster.

     Other than that he says the rotary sounds like
a outraged
     vacuum cleaner.

     Al

     Sounds like the article in RV Aviator. Of
course 30% more fuel
     borders on slander :) Perhaps there was
something wrong with
     the Power Sport fuel injection system. Tracy
leans his to .47 BSFC
     which is about the same as most Lycoming at
.45. Tracy flys side
     by side with his buddies in similar RV's in
Florida burning
     about the same fuel.

     30% more fuel is about .58 BSFC. No doubt a
full rich rotary
     will burn .58 BSFC but then again so will a
full rich air
     cooled aircraft engine. A turbo charged air
cooled aircraft
     engine will burn as much as .65 BSFC on takeoff
and climb out.

     Lets go the other way. Say by some miracle the
Lycoming
     was leaned past peak to .40 BSFC. 30% more
would be .52 BSFC.
     Still not plausible. Lycoming does not allow
lean of
     peak and it voids the engine warranty last I
heard.

     The rotary will run smoothly as much as 200
degrees lean of
     peak with no damage to the non existent exhaust
valves if
     you screw up and allow it to go to peak EGT :)
Tracy Crook's
     theory on this is the rotating combustion
chamber rotary
     engine is naturally stratified charge due to a
centrifugal
     affect on the mixture forcing the rich portion
out towards
     the spark plugs.

     My RX8 gets 25 MPG at a steady 65 to 70 MPH
which is comparable
     to other 240 HP cars of the same size. Not 30%
more fuel.

     BTW Cars are not allowed to run lean of peak
for emissions reasons.
     The computer holds the mixture at
stoichiometric (14.7:1) with in
     plus minus .01. See the OBD II data captures.
From the
     air flow rate in pounds per minute you can
calculate
     the fuel flow rate in pounds per minute by
dividing
     by 14.7.

     There is also the cooling drag issue. The Power
Sport
     installation is not known for low cooling drag.
     In fact it is not known for effective cooling
either :)

     Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


     Hi Paul,

     How do peak-power mixtures compare between a
rotary and a Lycoming?
     They typically talk about air cooled aircraft
engines making best power
     at 80deg ROP. I don't have any idea what FA
ratio that would
     translate to.

     It would be key to know where these Powersport
engines are operating on
     the mixture curve, and whether at a leaner
mixture they could make
     enough power to keep up with the Lycs. I'm not
debating whether it's
     possible to design an RV8 system where the
rotary would keep up with the
     Lycoming for a given fuel flow, just whether
these aircraft are capable
     of doing so.

     Other random comments:

     Top speed is a poor predictor of peak/cruise
power requirement.
     Airframe drag (to include cooling drag) will
dominate fuel economy at a
     given cruise speed. Even on airplanes with the
same engine, airframe
     drag can vary markedly, though RV's are
probably some of the most
     consistent experimentals in that regard. One of
the RV's is a nose
     dragger. Everything else has a tail wheel. That
the rotarys were
     burning more fuel could be related to having to
make significantly more
     power to overcome cooling drag (or maybe even
prop inefficiency).

     The article noted that the rotary powered
airplanes had faster climb
     rates than the Lycoming. That would indicate
more thrust at the climb
     airspeed, which could be due to prop
optimization or because of more
     overall horsepower (or both). The article
stated that all airplanes
     were ballasted to the same weight for at least
the climb portion of the
     tests.


     Regards,

     Matt-

     Peak power mixtures are around 12:1 in both
cases.

     The fact of the matter is there is not a
significant
     difference in fuel burn given the problems of
building
     identical airplanes with identical over all
drag, one
     with a rotary and one with an air cooled
aircraft engine.

     I think the rotary is 5% worse. 5% worse is
what I maintain
     and believe. However due to the higher
percentage
     of kinetic energy in the rotary exhaust due to
the lack of
     exhaust valves I would not be a bit surprised
if a turbo
     compound rotary eventually achieved a better
BSFC than a
     piston engine turbo compound despite starting
from a 5% worse
     BSFC. Then of course you have the exhaust valve
failure mode
     where it takes out the turbine. This was the
Achilles heel of the
     R3350 TC.


     BTW somebody pointed out that the fuel cost is
not the largest
     cost of flying and airplane or driving a car.
There are other
     issues. lets say you spend $10,000 on your
rotary engine
     and $25,000 on your Lycoming. If you fly 50
hours a year
     (which is typical) and you spend $4 a gallon
for 100 LL
     and $3 a gallon for auto gas your cost for gas
is 25% less
     right off the bat. If both engines get a TBO of
2000 hours
     what is the cost per hour for the engine?

     I bought a factory reman O-470 for my C182 and
it cost $17,000


Paul,

Too bad that all of this dialogue could not be sent to
Sport Aviation!!!
Very interesting.

Dr. Bill Doell

Feel free. The email address is editorial@eaa.org

-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.