Subject: May 2007 Sport Aviation Article.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/13/2006, 12:50 PM
To: AAme

     >
     > Great article on rotaries vs recip in the May issue
     > of
     > Sport Aviation!!!
     >
     > Dr. Bill Doell

    I didn't think it was so great. The conclusion was that the
    rotaries were
    maybe OK, but the fuel consumption was prohibitive. One of
    the rotaries
    burned about 30% more fuel than the O-320 to cover the
    same distance just a little bit faster.

    Other than that he says the rotary sounds like a outraged
    vacuum cleaner.

    Al

    Sounds like the article in RV Aviator. Of course 30% more fuel
    borders on slander :) Perhaps there was something wrong with
    the Power Sport fuel injection system. Tracy leans his to .47 BSFC
    which is about the same as most Lycoming at .45. Tracy flys side
    by side with his buddies in similar RV's in Florida burning
    about the same fuel.

    30% more fuel is about .58 BSFC. No doubt a full rich rotary
    will burn .58 BSFC but then again so will a full rich air
    cooled aircraft engine. A turbo charged air cooled aircraft
    engine will burn as much as .65 BSFC on takeoff and climb out.

    Lets go the other way. Say by some miracle the Lycoming
    was leaned past peak to .40 BSFC. 30% more would be .52 BSFC.
    Still not plausible. Lycoming does not allow lean of
    peak and it voids the engine warranty last I heard.

    The rotary will run smoothly as much as 200 degrees lean of
    peak with no damage to the non existent exhaust valves if
    you screw up and allow it to go to peak EGT :) Tracy Crook's
    theory on this is the rotating combustion chamber rotary
    engine is naturally stratified charge due to a centrifugal
    affect on the mixture forcing the rich portion out towards
    the spark plugs.

    My RX8 gets 25 MPG at a steady 65 to 70 MPH which is comparable
    to other 240 HP cars of the same size. Not 30% more fuel.

    BTW Cars are not allowed to run lean of peak for emissions reasons.
    The computer holds the mixture at stoichiometric (14.7:1) with in
    plus minus .01. See the OBD II data captures. From the
    air flow rate in pounds per minute you can calculate
    the fuel flow rate in pounds per minute by dividing
    by 14.7.

    There is also the cooling drag issue. The Power Sport
    installation is not known for low cooling drag.
    In fact it is not known for effective cooling either :)

    Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


    Hi Paul,

    How do peak-power mixtures compare between a rotary and a Lycoming?
    They typically talk about air cooled aircraft engines making best power
    at 80deg ROP. I don't have any idea what FA ratio that would
    translate to.

    It would be key to know where these Powersport engines are operating on
    the mixture curve, and whether at a leaner mixture they could make
    enough power to keep up with the Lycs. I'm not debating whether it's
    possible to design an RV8 system where the rotary would keep up with the
    Lycoming for a given fuel flow, just whether these aircraft are capable
    of doing so.

    Other random comments:

    Top speed is a poor predictor of peak/cruise power requirement.
    Airframe drag (to include cooling drag) will dominate fuel economy at a
    given cruise speed. Even on airplanes with the same engine, airframe
    drag can vary markedly, though RV's are probably some of the most
    consistent experimentals in that regard. One of the RV's is a nose
    dragger. Everything else has a tail wheel. That the rotarys were
    burning more fuel could be related to having to make significantly more
    power to overcome cooling drag (or maybe even prop inefficiency).

    The article noted that the rotary powered airplanes had faster climb
    rates than the Lycoming. That would indicate more thrust at the climb
    airspeed, which could be due to prop optimization or because of more
    overall horsepower (or both). The article stated that all airplanes
    were ballasted to the same weight for at least the climb portion of the
    tests.


    Regards,

    Matt-

    Peak power mixtures are around 12:1 in both cases.

    The fact of the matter is there is not a significant
    difference in fuel burn given the problems of building
    identical airplanes with identical over all drag, one
    with a rotary and one with an air cooled aircraft engine.

    I think the rotary is 5% worse. 5% worse is what I maintain
    and believe. However due to the higher percentage
    of kinetic energy in the rotary exhaust due to the lack of
    exhaust valves I would not be a bit surprised if a turbo
    compound rotary eventually achieved a better BSFC than a
    piston engine turbo compound despite starting from a 5% worse
    BSFC. Then of course you have the exhaust valve failure mode
    where it takes out the turbine. This was the Achilles heel of the
    R3350 TC.


    BTW somebody pointed out that the fuel cost is not the largest
    cost of flying and airplane or driving a car. There are other
    issues. lets say you spend $10,000 on your rotary engine
    and $25,000 on your Lycoming. If you fly 50 hours a year
    (which is typical) and you spend $4 a gallon for 100 LL
    and $3 a gallon for auto gas your cost for gas is 25% less
    right off the bat. If both engines get a TBO of 2000 hours
    what is the cost per hour for the engine?

    I bought a factory reman O-470 for my C182 and it cost $17,000
    with my core trade in. That is $8.50 an hour for engine maintenance.
    If I threw the rotary away at the end of 2000 hour my cost per hour
    would be $5 an hour or less. Probably half that as the first cost
    includes a lot of things like PSRU and radiators.

    I think you get the idea. $40 an hour for fuel (10 gal an hour)
    and $8.50 an hour for the engine is $48.50 total for the
    AC engine. The rotary $31.50 for fuel (10.5 gallons an hour)
    and $5 and hour for the engine for a total of $36.50 per hour.

    Not to mention of course you spent $15,00 less right off the bat.

    I know you are aware of all this being on here for awhile but
    we always have new people that may not of heard it yet.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------
    Hi Matt,

    Here is a BSFC curve for the Lemans engine.

    The one labeled economy is probably stoichiometric (14.7:1)
    and the one labeled power is probably 12:1 best power.
    Unfortunately Mazda did not plot BSFC at best power.

    My point here is you don't give up much power by going to
    stoichiometric.

    It is very rare now a days for an engine manufacturer
    to publish a complete BSFC map. The only one I have on
    the rotary is 60 years old. Considerable advances have
    been made in the rotary since then. Come to think
    of it I might be able to measure the full power BSFC
    using the OBD II in my RX8 at a full throttle acceleration
    run when the RPM hits the HP peak of 8500.
    No problem if I could find a flat place in the desert
    where I could run flat out at 140 MPH at 8500 RPM
    for a few minutes :)

    I have seen the P-port engine run on the dyno at 18:1.
    Unfortunately we did not have the wide band O2 sensor
    interfaced with the dyno computer program so we could
    not get a simultaneous plot of BSFC verses mixture
    ratio and HP. We by no means ever got the engine dialed
    in (as far as mixture was concerned) on the dyno to my
    satisfaction.

    Also I know for a fact the MT CS (primarily wood) props on
    the Power Sport airplanes are noticeably less efficient than
    a metal CS prop used on some of the competing RV airplanes.
    Tracy Saylor (Fastest RV6 in the world. 238 MPH in the Sun 100)
    tested an MT CS prop back to back with a metal CS prop and
    was 15 to 20 MPH slower. Prop tip thickness and blade untwisting
    was the speculation for this fact. One can easily untwist a MT
    CS prop blade with one's fingers alone.

    Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

$25,000 for a Lycoming! I've got that in my RV-4 so far with a 13Brew,
and have only to purchase a prop, transponder, and EFIS and I am DONE!
No way a Lycoming can even come close to that.

Brian Trubee


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.