Subject: YELLOW JOURNALISM ! !!! Sport Aviation Magazine May 2006
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/14/2006, 6:17 PM
To: AAme


    >> I have been a member for many years and enjoy reading Sport
   Aviation.
    >> This month was an exception. Ken Scott wrote an article comparing
    >> PowerSport Rotary engines in VAN's RV aircraft with factory
   recommended
    >> Lycoming. Last time I heard Van himself speak about putting
   anything BUT
    >> Lycoming in his babies, he was very much against it.... today
   his web
    >> site is chilly at best on the idea. Now here is where the editors of
    >> Sport Aviation crossed the line. It seems that Ken Scott has
   financial
    >> gain from Van's Aircraft.
   http://www.vansaircraft.com/public/eaa-ye.htm
    >> This certainly would taint his story to the corporate tune Van would
    >> like to hear. especially since Van's Aircraft is a dealer for
   Lycoming
    >> and not for PowerSport. This would explain the extraordinary
   fuel burn
    >> the Rotary engines reported displayed and such descriptives as
   "outraged
    >> vacuum cleaner".
    >>
    >> This story should have been marked at "SPECIAL ADVERTISING" or
   at the
    >> very least the editors should have explained at the top of the story
    >> Ken's relationship to Van's Aircraft. Without this commonly accepted
    >> professional journalistic practice, your magazine becomes like
   so many
    >> other trade journals we get for free every day.
    >> -David Arbogast
    >>
    >> PS - Small world it seems that Ken and Van are both members of
   EAA 105
    >> among many other connections:
    >> http://www.eaa105.org/History/history.htm
    >> In December is was the spokesman for Van's Aircraft
    >>
   http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=15831491&BRD=2318&PAG=461&dept_id=4
    >> 84045&rfi=6
    >> And at one time was "a company pilot" for Van's Aircraft.
    >> http://dev.pilotweb.co.uk/content/articles/view_article.aspx?id=780
    >
    >
    >
    > Aloha Paul
    > What about if you guys make a test comparing Lycoming and Rotarys
   in an
    > equal airplane and publish this article on the Internet or in other
    > magazine?
    > I am suspicious to speak about Lycoming and besides being an
   amateur low
    > time pilot, I already have scaring bad experiences with them,and
   I can say,
    > lucky of being here to tell this because I used to fly a Twin Engine
    > Aircraft.
    > I neither have experiences about flying Rotary Engines nor piston
    > automobile engines adapted to airplanes yet.
    > My decision for changing for those engines (besides my terrible
   experiences
    > with Lycoming and Continentals)was when I made myself the following
    > question:
    > What should happen if Hertz, Avis or other Rental companies,
   start using
    > Lycoming on their cars?
    > How long will last those engines? And the companys?
    > JC Castro in Brasil
    >


   JC,

   That is a great idea. Lets approach this positively. I volunteer Tracy
   Crook. Find another pilot with an RV and of similar HP and prop and load
   them to the same weight and go flying.. Do some sound dB tests. The
   rotary
   airplane engine is still young. Every year the advantages become
   clearer.


   Doug in Japan



Doug and JC,

This is an excellent idea. I think it would be useful to send Sport
Aviation editors a letter proposing a story written by Tracy Crook as a
fair rebuttal to the story written by the Van's employee.

I think it would be appropriate to stress that in the interest of
fairness a more rigorous test should be done, which would be the focus
of the article. Also it is worth stressing that the figure of 30 percent
fuel flow disadvantage to the rotary is not credible, and does not jibe
with known empirical fact.

I think EAA members deserve to hear the other side of the story. The
Sport Aviation editors might reply that having just covered this issue,
it might not warrant another article, but considering the perceived bias
of the author and the dubious factual conclusions, they just might be
persuaded.

Regards,

Gordon.



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.