Subject: YELLOW JOURNALISM ! !!! Sport Aviation Magazine May 2006
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/14/2006, 7:26 AM
To: AAme


       ... snip ...

 Within "real" journalism circles, the enthusiast magazine
       sector is
 considered a joke. Few of the writers or editors are true
       professionals,
 or have even been near a journalism school. It is unrealistic
       to expect
 any kind of quality, or even fairness in their content.
       Really, the only
 aviation magazine that can be said to be a real magazine is
       Smithsonian
 Air & Space. But it doesn't really even fall within the
       enthusiast
 sector, strictly speaking.

 Still, Sport Aviation being a member-supported magazine should
       aim for
 better. Unfortunately they are getting worse and worse and
       will soon be
 as bad as the rest. There are still some informative articles
       here and
 there, but a lot of it is advertising-driven fluff.

 Regards,

 Gordon.

       :-)) Thanks Gordon - I'd forgotten about the Cirrus train at
       Flying. But I
       have seen Mac and most of the other author's quality go south as
       you
       say... Peter and Lane are about the only 2 I can read without
       putting my
       skeptical glasses on for protection. I like the couple times
       Peter wrote
       about rotaries. And Lane - well she simply touches my heart and
       soul :-)

       -dave

         --
       Best Regards /Mit freundlichen Gruessen,
           dave ( at ) arb.net <http://arb.net> http://arb.net


   Feeling argumentative..  :)

   Pater Garrison wrote a good description of the function and
   application of vortex generators in the June 2006 Flying issue.
   Interesting description of flow seperation, and wing stall.

   Paul pointed out a while back how critical Richard Collins was of
   the latest/greatest offering from Columbia, and how rough running
   the TCM engine on it is.

   Collins has also been pretty critical of the latest glass cockpit
   offerings from Garmin and Avidyne - legitimate gripes, though he
   didn't slam the products, per-say.

   Collins also rips on the known-ice systems applied to non-turbine
   light airplanes.

   I can't find the issue at the moment, but one of the writers
   recently reviewed the queen air, metro series of airplanes, and
   commented on how funky-handling that airplane is on the ground.
   Seemed honest enough to me.

   Flying is the only non-experimental general aviation mag that I
   think is worth a darn, however.  And many of the writeups are
   fluff.  But at least the authors are fairly knowledgeable, and
   generally literate.  That's something I can't say for the other rags..


   Regards,

   Matt-


One more comment which I forgot to make...

For the writers to be totatlly honest, they'd have to be able to fly
these machines without any sponsorship by the manufacturers/dealers.
New airplanes are way too expensive for the average journalism outfit to
rent one out for an afternoon of thrashing.  The reality is that if the
writers were to brutally, unpolitely editorialize about the equipment
they were exposed to, the manufacturers/dealers would stop the
sponsorship.  I have found that the decent aviation writers can clearly
describe something and make me aware of it's shortcomings without
directly calling it a POS.  I think that's fine.  I can evaluate for
myself the implications of a particular operating detail.  When the
writers leave the critical details out, that _is_ bad.

For polite but brutal honesty, I like Ed Kolano (Sport Aviation tester).


Regards,

Matt-



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.