... snip ...
> Within "real" journalism circles, the enthusiast magazine
sector is
> considered a joke. Few of the writers or editors are true
professionals,
> or have even been near a journalism school. It is unrealistic
to expect
> any kind of quality, or even fairness in their content.
Really, the only
> aviation magazine that can be said to be a real magazine is
Smithsonian
> Air & Space. But it doesn't really even fall within the
enthusiast
> sector, strictly speaking.
>
> Still, Sport Aviation being a member-supported magazine should
aim for
> better. Unfortunately they are getting worse and worse and
will soon be
> as bad as the rest. There are still some informative articles
here and
> there, but a lot of it is advertising-driven fluff.
>
> Regards,
>
> Gordon.
:-)) Thanks Gordon - I'd forgotten about the Cirrus train at
Flying. But I
have seen Mac and most of the other author's quality go south as
you
say... Peter and Lane are about the only 2 I can read without
putting my
skeptical glasses on for protection. I like the couple times
Peter wrote
about rotaries. And Lane - well she simply touches my heart and
soul :-)
-dave
--
Best Regards /Mit freundlichen Gruessen,
dave ( at ) arb.net
http://arb.net
Feeling argumentative.. :)
Pater Garrison wrote a good description of the function and
application of vortex generators in the June 2006 Flying issue.
Interesting description of flow seperation, and wing stall.
Paul pointed out a while back how critical Richard Collins was of
the latest/greatest offering from Columbia, and how rough running
the TCM engine on it is.
Collins has also been pretty critical of the latest glass cockpit
offerings from Garmin and Avidyne - legitimate gripes, though he
didn't slam the products, per-say.
Collins also rips on the known-ice systems applied to non-turbine
light airplanes.
I can't find the issue at the moment, but one of the writers
recently reviewed the queen air, metro series of airplanes, and
commented on how funky-handling that airplane is on the ground.
Seemed honest enough to me.
Flying is the only non-experimental general aviation mag that I
think is worth a darn, however. And many of the writeups are
fluff. But at least the authors are fairly knowledgeable, and
generally literate. That's something I can't say for the other rags..
Regards,
Matt-
One more comment which I forgot to make...
For the writers to be totatlly honest, they'd have to be able to fly
these machines without any sponsorship by the manufacturers/dealers.
New airplanes are way too expensive for the average journalism outfit to
rent one out for an afternoon of thrashing. The reality is that if the
writers were to brutally, unpolitely editorialize about the equipment
they were exposed to, the manufacturers/dealers would stop the
sponsorship. I have found that the decent aviation writers can clearly
describe something and make me aware of it's shortcomings without
directly calling it a POS. I think that's fine. I can evaluate for
myself the implications of a particular operating detail. When the
writers leave the critical details out, that
_is_ bad.
For polite but brutal honesty, I like Ed Kolano (Sport Aviation tester).
Regards,
Matt-
Matt,
I agree with you about Garrison and Collins. I enjoy reading both, but
the rest is pure crap, in my opinion.
Remember that series of articles where they paired an aircraft with a
car for a kind of road/fly test? There was one with a Pilatus paired
with a Ford Excursion, another with a Robinsoon heli and a Porsche SUV,
another with a Beech jet and a Mercedes, and so on. This was pure
advertising glossy territory and it made me gag. At least if there was
something informative or insightful in the articles it could have gone a
long way to redeeming this kind of stunt, but the writeups were bland
pabulum that offered no substance whatsoever.
Hats off to Collins for those instances you mentioned. Unfortunately he
is the only one there who has any integrity (Garrison's rubric is not in
the vein of commenting on products, so this doesn't apply to him,
although he comes across as a gentleman of integrity in every way).
And even Collins is walking on eggshells most of the time, one gets the
impression. I was especially dismayed to see him backtrack on the Cirrus
spin-testing issue. I really appluaded his integrity for calling that
spade, but was quite surprised to see him in hand-wringing mode later.
What really gets me about Flying is that they are promoting themselves
as "the Voice" of general aviation, which, if that were true -- and
thank God it is far from being so -- it would be a truly sad reflection
on the many interesting and dynamic people who make up general aviation.
Flying is owned by Hachette Fillipachi, a big-time publisher of
enthusiast magazines, including Road & Track and many others. If at one
time Flying was not in the "enthusiast magazine" mold, it surely is now,
and that is a sad fact.
The reaon Hachette picked up Flying is so they could offer another venue
to their big advertisers like the automakers. It's called group
advertising and its the business model of the popular magazine sector.
By having a number of magazines in your stable you can offer big
advertisers a group rate for placing ads in all of them. That is why
Flying suddenly started running car stories -- and that is why you
suddenly saw advertising from the automakers in the magazine.
Now none of this is especially bad in and of itself, as long as the
content of the magazine is not affected. Unfortunately, the enthusiast
format calls for "dumbing down" of content to the lowest common
denominator (Joe Average is not big on reading). Ironicqally, some of
the best articles I've seen in the magazine are in those special
advertising sections, where they often write about interesting people
and how they use their aircraft for business or pleasure. They could do
articles like this in the magazine proper, but they won't because it
doesn't fit with the "enthusiast" template, which is to keep it short,
fluffy, and substance-free.
And of course we can forget about any honest "review" of products,
because the makers of those products are advertisers or potential
advertisers. And the issue is not just about how straight they are when
they are writing about a new airplane, radio, or whatever. It's as much
about what they choose to write about to begin with.
Take the Eclipse jet, for instance. Have you ever seen an article in
Flying about this groundbreaking airplane, the interesting guy behind
it, or the many intersting facets of the project? No. There has not been
one feature article, except for some short blurbs in the "news" section.
This is really a disgrace. The reason? See if you can guess. Have you
ever seen an Eclipse ad in Flying? No. Hats off to Eclipse founder Vern
Rayburn for shunning this ridiculous rag with its laughable pretensions
of being "the pilot's bible."
The reason Maclellan has chosen to ignore one of the biggest stories in
GA of the last decade is because the company decided not to advertise
with them. Is this fair to the subscribers and readers? Are they getting
their money's worth? I think not.
Compare this to Adam Aircraft which has been given all kinds of feature
stories. Lucky for Flying readers that Adam decided to advertise, or
else we would have missed that story too.
The fact of the matter is that Flying is actually not a natural fit in
the "enthusiast magazine" mold. The car magazines have much broader
reader appeal and far greater subscription numbers. Their advertisers
are huge corporations that own the single biggest market in the world,
the car industry. The magazines can afford to lease these cars for all
of their testing needs, but why should they when they get them for free,
sometimes for a year or more? How much does it cost to lease a high-end
German sedan for a year or two? Yet each of these magainzes, at any
given tme will have the use of half a dozen of these cars for such
long-term "tests."
Then there are the lavish junkets to exciting locales for new product
introductions, which are inevitably followed by the glowing cover
stories and fawning writeups. It is a huge pork trough of goodies and
the result is a glossy piece of advertising that you can pay several
dollars to read and then throw away in disgust when you realize it is
completely devoid of any interesting or insightful content.
The world of aviation does not fit this mold. If you don't include the
bizjet makers, the entire GA manufacturing industry is denominated in
the millions, not billions. It is really a cottage industry. Even the
biggest company in this sector, Cirrus, is only considered a medium-size
concern with maybe a couple of hundred employees.
These companies sure can't dish out the lavish goodies that GM or
Daimler-Chrysler can. In fact I would bet that the big automakers spend
many times more on PR alone than the entire single-engine aircraft
industry is worth.
So how does an aviation magazine fit into this "enthusiast" mold. It
doesn't really. It is considered a throwaway by Hachette. It's just
another title to have in its stable so it can give one more outlet to
its big industry advertisers.
That's also why you see a lot of coverage of bizjets in Flying.
Companies like Raytheon, Bombardier, Honeywell, etc. may not be quite
the size of the automakers, but they have big bucks and Hachette wants
to get as much of those bucks as they can.
What point are these "reviews" other than good PR for these big
companies? Do you really think that the decision-makers in corporate
flight departments are saying, "Hmm, well Mac thinks the new Honeywell
Primus Epic avionics suite is the way to go, so I guess we'd better buy
the new Learjet?" Yeah, right...
It all adds up to a really pathetic picture, which is why I no longer
buy this rag, but go to my local library to read Garrison and Collins'
columns.
Regards,
Gordon.
PS: One magazine that I should mention positively is Flight Journal.
This warbird rag is excellent in all respects. It's edited by Bud
Davisson and he has a roster of excellent writers, many of them
bona-fide historians, test pilots and such. I especially like Corky
Meyer, the WWII-era Grumman test pilot who spins some terrific flying tales.
This magazine is head and shoulders above the enthusiast rag bilgewater
that you get in Flying. It is worth every cent and I would gladly buy
products from their advertisers, none of which are "aviation-industry"
related.
It proves that it is possible to produce a fine magazine with excellent
content, without having to sell your ass to advertisers.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.