I have been a member for many years and enjoy reading Sport Aviation.
This month was an exception. Ken Scott wrote an article comparing
PowerSport Rotary engines in VAN's RV aircraft with factory recommended
Lycoming. Last time I heard Van himself speak about putting anything BUT
Lycoming in his babies, he was very much against it.... today his web
site is chilly at best on the idea. Now here is where the editors of
Sport Aviation crossed the line. It seems that Ken Scott has financial
gain from Van's Aircraft.
http://www.vansaircraft.com/public/eaa-ye.htm
This certainly would taint his story to the corporate tune Van would
like to hear. especially since Van's Aircraft is a dealer for Lycoming
and not for PowerSport. This would explain the extraordinary fuel burn
the Rotary engines reported displayed and such descriptives as "outraged
vacuum cleaner".
This story should have been marked at "SPECIAL ADVERTISING" or at the
very least the editors should have explained at the top of the story
Ken's relationship to Van's Aircraft. Without this commonly accepted
professional journalistic practice, your magazine becomes like so many
other trade journals we get for free every day.
-David Arbogast
PS - Small world it seems that Ken and Van are both members of EAA 105
among many other connections:
http://www.eaa105.org/History/history.htm
In December is was the spokesman for Van's Aircraft
http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=15831491&BRD=2318&PAG=461&dept_id=484045&rfi=6
And at one time was "a company pilot" for Van's Aircraft.
http://dev.pilotweb.co.uk/content/articles/view_article.aspx?id=780
Dear Dave,
Thanks for your comments on the story that compared the performance
of RV-8s with rotary and piston
engines. Van's Aircraft's contribution to the story was allowing us
to use the company facilities
and aircraft to perform the comparison. As detailed in the story the
performance tests were conduced
in a scientific manner and the application was consistent among all
aircraft. At the conclusion of
the tests all participants got the data and was able to comment on
it, and everyone agreed it was
accurate.
You're correct that Van would rather not have builders installing
engines other than the ones
specified for the design, and that includes higher horsepower
Lycomings such as the builders who've
installed IO-540s in the RV-8, which was designed for the 200 hp
O-360 series engine.
Ultimately, no one received any financial gain for the story, and
the article didn't recommend one
engine over the other. It did however, provide some objective data
that readers can add to the
installation challenges of the rotary builders to make their own
decisions on whether to install a
different engine on their airplane.
As for the higher fuel burn revealed by the tests, if the owners
were flying the planes by the test
parameters, and they agreed with the results, as someone who didn't
participate in or witness the
tests, I'm not going to question them. When it comes to describing
the sound an engine makes, the
challenge is to convey in words something that sounds different to
all of us. What maybe an enraged
vacuum cleaner to one person may be a soothing hum to another, and
perhaps the only way to get
around that is to put a sound file on the website and let readers
decide for themselves.
Thanks for taking the time to write.
Scott.
Scott M. Spangler
Editor in Chief
EAA Publications
How would the owners know they were not operating the engines
too rich? Neither one of them has been on any of the list
that discuss the installation of rotary engines in aircraft.
Further more you ignore the fact that Van sells Lycoming engines
and therefore stands to gain financially from the sale of same.
The author is an employee of Van's and consequently his motives are
highly suspect.
You need to corroborate your information before you make
such outrages claims of excessive rotary engine fuel consumption.
In normal circumstances, with large corporation involved,
you would be sued for slander.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
I have to respond to this letter by the EAA editor.
First the issue of the author, who appears to be a Van's employee -- and
Van's being an advertiser in EAA.
There is huge conflict of interest here. Journalistic ethics do not not
condone an advertiser authoring editorial content. This just isn't done
in any serious publication that pretends to adhere to journalistic values.
Spangler's explanation that no one gained financially from the story is
a moot point and a pretty low standard -- are we now playing by rules
that say the only thing that is forbidden is for someone to get a direct
financial payoff from a story? Everything short of that is okay?
Let me be perfectly clear. Having an employee of an advertiser author a
story is a violation of core journalistic ethics. At the very least, the
author's link to the advertiser should have been disclosed in the article.
The practice of having advertisers author editorial content and not
reveal that link is absolutely a violoation of the trust between the
magazine and its readers. It is quite shameful.
As a former journalist for The New York Times and a graduate of NYU's
school of journalism, I believe I am qualified to comment on journalism
ethics. I can honestly say that I can't decide what is more distateful:
that the magazine ran a story authored by an employee of the advertiser
without disclosing that link, or that the editor is now trying to defend
that by saying no one gained financially.
This is pure bush league and an insult to the people on this forum who
made sincere inquiries to the EAA concerning this matter.
I urge everyone here to make their feelings known that they expect a
decent level of journalism ethics from the EAA, which publishes
magazines as a member benefit, not as a commercial venture.
Regards,
Gordon Arnaut
Oro-Medonte, Ontario
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.