Subject: Cooling a Glass Goose
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/17/2006, 7:03 PM
To: AAme



>> Paul and group,
>>
>> I finally have my Renesis mounted, and now I need to pursue the
>> cooling.  I've studied Paul's articles and all the cooling threads
>> here, but it looks like I may have several options.  I would
>> appreciatesome help so I might have a chance of getting it as close to
>> right as
>> possible!
>>
>> As per the attached pix, it is obvious  that the standard cowling is
>> far too wide (about 30", and just a little short) for this engine.  I
>> can narrow the two bottom cowling halves without any problem, but the
>> fit around the prop. is still too big.
>>
>> Perhaps I should just  implement the best possible cooling scheme and
>> build a new cowling to fit.  Other than overall drag, there are very
>> few real constraints on the  size and shape of a custom cowling for
>> this plane.  Cooling is obviously more important.
>>
>> For the radiators, it looks like there are at least 2 reasonable
>> options.  The first is to put two radiators sitting at about a 45
>> degree angle back, and tilted back from the top, in front of the
>> engine(see pic).  This can support two radiators about 17x12", but does
>> not
>> account for the oil cooler. I can make appropriate ducting to both of
>> these without too much trouble.  This has been done by other Goose
>> builders, but with small radiators and no ducting.  It seems like this
>> option needs quite a bit of width to work.
>>
>> Another option might  be to put a slightly larger, single radiator in
>> the front, and another radiator (or two) on the cool side of the
>> engine.  The side looks like it could easily handle a radiator about
>> 14x22"  Notice the RX-7 oil cooler in this location on one pic.  This
>> would  have to use a 90-degree-entry style duct that fed from the
frontof
>> the cowling, beside the front radiator.  The hot air could exiteither
out
>> the side of the cowling, or toward the engine.  This wouldgive a much
>> narrower cowling than with 2 radiators up front.
>>
>> The side version could handle the stock oil cooler (5"x22") as well as
>> a 9x22" water radiator.  However, there is another possibility for an
>> oil radiator if I still need more volume.  Down under the  rear
>> supportbridge (see pic), there is a space that would handle about
>> 10x14"radiator.  Air would have to be ducted down to this area, but I
>> could
>> probably get a 4" diameter tube to it.    It might  also need a fan,
>> because it would get no airflow unless the plane was moving.  Perhaps
>> an automotive-style fan and fan shroud might  work?  Some builders
>> haveplaced the 0-320 cooler in this location, with mixed results.  No
one
>> has used a fan.
>>
>> The Goose normally ingests a lot of air through its appx. 9"x15"
>> intake, and sends most of it  into the pylon after cooling the engine.
>> It exits at the rear of the pylon through 'augmentation slots'
>> supposedly to help deliver air to the prop.  This is obviously more
>> intake area than is necessary just to cool the engine.
>>
>> Is there a better solution than any of these ideas?  I suppose the
>> questions boil down to:  what is the smallest, most efficient way to
>> group water and oil radiators of certain sizes around the engine in
>> order to achieve the necessary cooling (240hp) with the least drag?
>> Your ideas and suggestions are greatly appreciated!
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Scott Gettings
>>
>> Real nice work on the motor mount Scott.
>>
>> I think you are being a bit optimistic on the HP.
>> With only four ports and a 2.85:1 PSRU you will
>> be limited to about 7000 to 7500 and about 190 HP
>> +/- 10 HP depending on the muffler and prop. Given that, one
>> 17" x 12" x 2" rad should work fine with a K&W truncated
>> well sealed diffuser vertically mounted in front of the engine.
>> The oil cooler can go on the plug side in a simple
>> K&L wedge diffuser. A Paul Lipps prop mounted close
>> to the rear cowl opening will enhance the air flow
>> through the engine compartment and the heat exchangers.
>>
>> More pictures next meassge.
>>
>> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>>
>> Opss I counted wrong. That should be six ports and
>> 215 HP +/- 10 HP.
>>
>> --
>> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>>
>
>
> Thanks for your help, Paul.  I couldn't have done the engine mounts
> without your and the group's help.
> Although I didn't end up using the oil pain-mount combination you
> suggested (couldn't find anyone to build it),
> using two, 1x2", 4130 horizontal beams ended up being very light, simple
> and inexpensive.  Ed will be building
> my custom oil pan that fits between the beams, starting with the flat
> flange you see on the engine.
>
> Regarding the radiators, I'm assuming I should allocate intake areas
> according to the 20% rule?
> - 20% of 17x12", or 41 sq. inches for the front radiator
> - 20% of 5x19" for the oil cooler, or about 20 sq. inches
>
> I'll need another 7-10 sq. inches for the intake, but have plenty to
play
> with due to the larger intake area
> (normally about 140 sq inches).  Should I allocate larger intake areas
to
> the coolers?  All this air will end up
> going out the rear of the pylon.
>
> thanks again,
>
> Scott Gettings
>
> Yes I think 20% is about right for the speed range
> of your airplane. Yes a large air out let in front of the
> prop won't hurt the drag that much. My guess is about
> 14 or 16 inches in diameter with a 12 inch pressure recovery
> spinner around one of Paul Lipps pusher props.
>
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



Paul and Scott,
I attended a seminar at Copperstate a few years back that Contact Mag. and
Paul Lipps hosted. Paul discussed his prop design and the benefits and
some
drawbacks.
There is no doubt that his design is fantastic for all out high speed, but
tests showed that takeoff distance actually increased 10 to 15% due to the
small tip area.
Somewhat like the ultimate cruise prop verses a climb prop.
This could be a real problem for high altitude based aircraft or even
seaplanes which might take longer to get up on the step.
A C/S version could possibly overcome these drawbacks.

Ron F.

Ron,
Very interesting, I wonder If Paul L. might elaborate on this.

This reminds me of a show I saw last night on 'Beyond Tomorrow' -
an Aussie invention show.
This young University Engineer (distinctly middle eastern name) has
developed a 'Wing Warping'  (I know the Wright Brothers did it first, but
he calls it Morphing), model aeroplane with a roll rate of approx 1,000
degrees a second. It seems the US Air Force is interested in it for
surveillance purposes. Apparently he got the idea from watching seagulls. He
has another wing design in a distinct M design i.e. large inner dihedral,
with pronounced outer wing droop.

Perhaps we should be looking at a Morphing propeller.
George ( down under)



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.