Subject: YELLOW JOURNALISM ! !!! Sport Aviation Magazine May 2006 (fwd)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/17/2006, 11:29 AM
To: AAme




> I finally got my copy.
> As far as I can tell the main fault lies with
> the Power Sport FADEC, As Tracy Crook has pointed out
> many times it is near impossible to program
> a FADEC that will optimize the rotary engine air fuel
> mixture under all possible conditions. The pilot must intervene
> and optimize the rotary engine mixture control for
> cruise. Unless you lean the mixture properly
> (up to 200 F lean of peak) you will not
> achieve .47 BSFC. The people involved with
> the test probably had no way of knowing that.
> > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Hi Paul,

The guys over at the "E-SubieForum" at Yahoo groups are sure "yucking it up"
about the fuel burn Rotary vs. Lycoming, in Sport Aviation.

One guy wrote; "Did anyone else note the amount of fuel those rotaries in
Sport Aviation
went through? That kinda leaves them out of the conversion race I would
think..."

Too bad Subies can't produce the HP as advertised, heavy pigs. Funny I think
that would kinda really leave them out.

Regards to All,
Rick in Alaska


I just got off the phone with Ray Richardson owner
of Power Sport. He said the software in the Power Sport
FADEC was far from optimized when they tested those airplanes.
That implies the engines were running too rich.

He also pointed out the test was run at a fixed prop RPM rather
than a fixed air speed. This gave a decided advantage
to the metal CS props used on the Lycoming over the primarily
wood CS MT props.  The muffler system used was also not finalized.
These are some pictures of the mufflers I took at OSH which
were added after the test was done well over a year ago. Ray
also said they notified Vans of the changes and nothing was done
to correct the results. EAA did not contact Power Sport prior
to publishing the article so corrections could be made.

I also called Jim Clark owner of one of the PS powered RV8
to get his take on the test. He told me he and the other planes
were required to fly formation on the lead Lycoming powered airplane.
Consequently he felt his FADEC was going in and out of auto rich.
After thinking things over for awhile he felt a lot of the ways
the test was set up were accurate or fair.

Ray also said they are not out of business and they are still
shipping engines and gear boxes. We have not heard from,
or about any of these customers so far.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


What were you thinking Scott ?? All things being equal = "Apples to
Apples" I think you said, how can ANY engine comparison be done where one
was a fixed pitch wood prop VS a CS metal prop ? That is A&P school 101 !!

-dave


-- 
Best Regards /Mit freundlichen Gruessen,
  dave ( at ) arb.net http://arb.net

The MT is a primarily wood blade electric constant speed
prop. It is known to be significantly less efficient
than a metal constant speed prop.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.