Subject: Cooling a Glass Goose
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/18/2006, 8:25 AM
To: AAme



    > >> Paul and group,
    > >>
    > >> I finally have my Renesis mounted, and now I need to pursue the
    > >> cooling.  I've studied Paul's articles and all the cooling threads
    > >> here, but it looks like I may have several options.  I would
    > >> appreciate some help so I might have a chance of getting it as
   close to
    > >> right as
    > >> possible!
    > >>
    > >> As per the attached pix, it is obvious  that the standard
   cowling is
    > >> far too wide (about 30", and just a little short) for this
   engine.  I
    > >> can narrow the two bottom cowling halves without any problem,
   but the
    > >> fit around the prop. is still too big.
    > >>
    > >> Perhaps I should just  implement the best possible cooling
   scheme and
    > >> build a new cowling to fit.  Other than overall drag, there
   are very
    > >> few real constraints on the  size and shape of a custom
   cowling for
    > >> this plane.  Cooling is obviously more important.
    > >>
    > >> For the radiators, it looks like there are at least 2 reasonable
    > >> options.  The first is to put two radiators sitting at about a 45
    > >> degree angle back, and tilted back from the top, in front of the
    > >> engine(see pic).  This can support two radiators about 17x12",
   but does
    > >> not
    > >> account for the oil cooler. I can make appropriate ducting to
   both of
    > >> these without too much trouble.  This has been done by other Goose
    > >> builders, but with small radiators and no ducting.  It seems
   like this
    > >> option needs quite a bit of width to work.
    > >>
    > >> Another option might  be to put a slightly larger, single
   radiator in
    > >> the front, and another radiator (or two) on the cool side of the
    > >> engine.  The side looks like it could easily handle a radiator
   about
    > >> 14x22"  Notice the RX-7 oil cooler in this location on one
   pic.  This
    > >> would  have to use a 90-degree-entry style duct that fed from the
   front of
    > >> the cowling, beside the front radiator.  The hot air could
   exit either
   out
    > >> the side of the cowling, or toward the engine.  This would give
   a much
    > >> narrower cowling than with 2 radiators up front.
    > >>
    > >> The side version could handle the stock oil cooler (5"x22") as
   well as
    > >> a 9x22" water radiator.  However, there is another possibility
   for an
    > >> oil radiator if I still need more volume.  Down under the  rear
    > >> support bridge (see pic), there is a space that would handle about
    > >> 10x14"radiator.  Air would have to be ducted down to this
   area, but I
    > >> could
    > >> probably get a 4" diameter tube to it.    It might  also need
   a fan,
    > >> because it would get no airflow unless the plane was
   moving.  Perhaps
    > >> an automotive-style fan and fan shroud might  work?  Some builders
    > >> have placed the 0-320 cooler in this location, with mixed
   results.  No
   one
    > >> has used a fan.
    > >>
    > >> The Goose normally ingests a lot of air through its appx. 9"x15"
    > >> intake, and sends most of it  into the pylon after cooling the
   engine.
    > >> It exits at the rear of the pylon through 'augmentation slots'
    > >> supposedly to help deliver air to the prop.  This is obviously
   more
    > >> intake area than is necessary just to cool the engine.
    > >>
    > >> Is there a better solution than any of these ideas?  I suppose the
    > >> questions boil down to:  what is the smallest, most efficient
   way to
    > >> group water and oil radiators of certain sizes around the
   engine in
    > >> order to achieve the necessary cooling (240hp) with the least
   drag?
    > >> Your ideas and suggestions are greatly appreciated!
    > >>
    > >> Thanks,
    > >>
    > >> Scott Gettings
    > >>
    > >> Real nice work on the motor mount Scott.
    > >>
    > >> I think you are being a bit optimistic on the HP.
    > >> With only four ports and a 2.85:1 PSRU you will
    > >> be limited to about 7000 to 7500 and about 190 HP
    > >> +/- 10 HP depending on the muffler and prop. Given that, one
    > >> 17" x 12" x 2" rad should work fine with a K&W truncated
    > >> well sealed diffuser vertically mounted in front of the engine.
    > >> The oil cooler can go on the plug side in a simple
    > >> K&L wedge diffuser. A Paul Lipps prop mounted close
    > >> to the rear cowl opening will enhance the air flow
    > >> through the engine compartment and the heat exchangers.
    > >>
    > >> More pictures next meassge.
    > >>
    > >> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    > >>
    > >> Opss I counted wrong. That should be six ports and
    > >> 215 HP +/- 10 HP.
    > >>
    > >> --
    > >> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    > >>
    > >
    > >
    > > Thanks for your help, Paul.  I couldn't have done the engine mounts
    > > without your and the group's help.
    > > Although I didn't end up using the oil pain-mount combination you
    > > suggested (couldn't find anyone to build it),
    > > using two, 1x2", 4130 horizontal beams ended up being very
   light, simple
    > > and inexpensive.  Ed will be building
    > > my custom oil pan that fits between the beams, starting with
   the flat
    > > flange you see on the engine.
    > >
    > > Regarding the radiators, I'm assuming I should allocate intake
   areas
    > > according to the 20% rule?
    > > - 20% of 17x12", or 41 sq. inches for the front radiator
    > > - 20% of 5x19" for the oil cooler, or about 20 sq. inches
    > >
    > > I'll need another 7-10 sq. inches for the intake, but have
   plenty to
   play
    > > with due to the larger intake area
    > > (normally about 140 sq inches).  Should I allocate larger
   intake areas
   to
    > > the coolers?  All this air will end up
    > > going out the rear of the pylon.
    > >
    > > thanks again,
    > >
    > > Scott Gettings
    > >
    > > Yes I think 20% is about right for the speed range
    > > of your airplane. Yes a large air out let in front of the
    > > prop won't hurt the drag that much. My guess is about
    > > 14 or 16 inches in diameter with a 12 inch pressure recovery
    > > spinner around one of Paul Lipps pusher props.
    > >
    > > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    >
    >
    > Paul and Scott,
    > I attended a seminar at Copperstate a few years back that Contact
   Mag. and
    > Paul Lipps hosted. Paul discussed his prop design and the
   benefits and
   some
    > drawbacks.
    > There is no doubt that his design is fantastic for all out high
   speed, but
    > tests showed that takeoff distance actually increased 10 to 15%
   due to the
    > small tip area.
    > Somewhat like the ultimate cruise prop verses a climb prop.
    > This could be a real problem for high altitude based aircraft or
   even
    > seaplanes which might take longer to get up on the step.
    > A C/S version could possibly overcome these drawbacks.
    >
    > Ron F.

   Ron,
   Very interesting, I wonder If Paul L. might elaborate on this.

   This reminds me of a show I saw last night on 'Beyond Tomorrow' -
   an Aussie invention show.
   This young University Engineer (distinctly middle eastern name) has
   developed a 'Wing Warping'  (I know the Wright Brothers did it
   first, but
   he calls it Morphing), model aeroplane with a roll rate of approx 1,000
   degrees a second. It seems the US Air Force is interested in it for
   surveillance purposes. Apparently he got the idea from watching
   seagulls. He
   has another wing design in a distinct M design i.e. large inner
   dihedral,
   with pronounced outer wing droop.

   Perhaps we should be looking at a Morphing propeller.
   George ( down under)



>From Wikipedia: "Wing morphing is a modern extension of wing warping
in which the aerodynamic shape of the wing is modified under computer
control."

http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/Science-Fiction-News.asp?NewsNum=442
<http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/Science-Fiction-News.asp?NewsNum=442>

http://www.popsci.com/popsci/aviationspace/87dd5b4a1db84010vgnvcm1000004eecbccdrcrd.html



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.