Subject: Powersport performance and fuel burn
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/18/2006, 8:55 PM
To: AAme
CC: editorial@eaa.org

    > You reported we had a phone call, but apparently
    > Did not print the points of what I said.
    > So here it is again in better detail:
    >
    > Vans chose the speed at 150 kts,
    > Vans decided the planes should fly at 2500 prop speed.
    > The Lycoming need the 2500 prop speed to reach 150 kts.
    >
    > The Powersport [p-port] engine RV's will fly their 150 kts at
   2100 prop
   speed.
    > Because the Powersport engine makes 450 lbs/ft of torque at the prop
    > at 2400 prop with the engine turning 5490 rpm, We CAN reduce the
    > prop speed to 2100 RPM And still out power the Lycom. Engines.
    >
    > I don't believe that Vans was slighting the fuel burn test. It
   just did
   not
    > occur to them that the Powersport engine could match their speed
   with the
    > prop turning so slow.
    >
    > The main point of the Vans test to us was to prove Powersport engines
   really
    > do make more power. Van's interest was performance in all areas.
    >
    > Vans reported the Powersport engines out climbed and out ran the
   IO-360
    > listed at 200 hp. and the Vans Special Built Fanuc 0-360.
    >
    > Before the tests I asked what mods that special built engine had.
    > Vans offered no details other than a $8,000.00 fadec system and
    > other things. So I asked how many of your customers have a similar
    > equipped engine. Vans said their might be only 1 other.
    >
    > The questions Vans have repeatly asked the Subaru's are:
    >
    > 1) Why no Subaru or any other engine other than Powersport has
    > ever flown to Vans and flew tests against them.
    >
    > 2) Why no builder with a Subaru engine has even answered
    > Vans question as to their flight performance.
    >
    > 3) Van's have asked many times Please come and show us what is the
    > performance of your engine. Vans said NO one except Powersport
    > has ever showed up!!
    >
    > It's really easy to burn less fuel. Make less power, don't climb
    > or fly fast. Then you don't need to have a large 3 blade prop.
    > Don't need large air inlet or outlets for cooling. You don't
    > need to worry about the exhaust temp. or flow rates.
    >
    > Exhaust:
    > The exhaust system at the Vans fly-off did not have the completed
    > upgrade tips. Their for the sound was 91 DB. Recorded at take-off
    > 50 ft under. Current Powersport exhaust now is 81 DB, full power
    > take-off 50 ft under. Those of you at Oshkosh, (who were close
    > enough) to hear the 2 Powersport RV-8 will attest to the great
    > sound. I received ALL positive comments. Most said they sound
    > like a Quiet Turbine engine. Even some Lycoming guys asked
    > if we could make their engines sound like that.
    >
    > The pilot fuel trim feature was added for exhaust and other
    > development. It allows a 5% trim. The ECU's hold lamdia .94 at
    > full power takeoff to lamdia 1.00 through 20,000 ft. with no
    > pilot trim used.
    >
    > [Lambda 1.00 is 14.7:1 air fuel ratio) Lambda .94 is therefore
    > 13.8:1 which is not quite best power. Best power happens
    > at 12.5:1. The rotary will continue to run up to at least
    > 18:1 observed on the Mazdatrix dyno and 200 degrees F lean
    > of peak. Best BSFC is around 16.6:1. (1.13 Lambda) This is
    > exactly what I thought was wrong with the Power Sport FADEC.
    > Tracy Crook cruises at altitude at up to 200 degrees F lean
    > of peak and with more spark advance and burns about the same
    > fuel as a leaned Lycoming. It is thought that the reason
    > this is possible is because the rotary is a rotating combustion
    > chamber engine and the rich fraction of the mixture is thrown
    > outboard toward the spark plugs due to centrifugal force.
    > This makes the rotary naturally stratified charge.
    >
    > BTW Klaus Savier LSE also uses the same techniques but is
    > unable to lean the Cont. O-200 to 200 F lean of peak.
    > See the attached mixture chart from The Sky Ranch Engineering
    > manual for more info. PL]
    >
    > Pilot trim was requested and granted for the following reasons.
    > At ALT 75% power could still be WOT. If you come to a mountain
    > and want best power it occurs at 10% rich = .9 lamdia. But best
    > fuel burn is 10% lean This was a way for the pilot to tell the
    > system what he wanted. This also allows the customers who do not
    > purchase our tuned exhaust system to fine tune to the exhaust
    > system what he actually built. He can record the deviations he
    > had. We can then make the changes he wanted to his mapping.
    > Our customers do not fly and need to trim our engines!!
    >
    > [Can you clarify this Ray? Is the trim 5% or +/- 10%? PL]
    >
    > Vans has had many years to perfect their best cruise and cooling
    > Powersport has not. Powersport's 1st cowling had lots of problems.
    > The worst one is the outlet and exchange width was the same as Vans.
    > Our mistake, because it needs to be the same width as the working
    > width of the coolers.
    >
    > Now we have enlarged and reshaped the cooling duct of our cowling
    > to cool our 215 horsepower for ground and VX climbs. Next refinement
    > is our new cowling now permits the oil cooler to be under the engine
    > and allowing the water rad. to be moved to a more optimum low angled
    > location. A point that Paul has correctly pointed out for years! Our
    > earlier cooling duct cowling was not built wide enough. We will add
    > a flap can be opened during taxi and VX climb. Then after a VX climb
    > the trailing flap (Not built yet) can be reflected inward to reduce
    > the height of our opening. This increasing the exit airspeed and
    > reduce the cooling drag. Presently The RV-8's have no flap
    > and are over cooling at cruse and thus a drag penalty toward
    > fuel burn and speed.
    >
    > The 2 RV-8 tested have not moved their coolers to those locations
    > yet. When they do they will fly faster and burn less fuel.
    >
    > Here is the performance as recorded by our 2 California customers
    > RV-8 builders 1 year ago. They were not trying to improve the fuel
    > burn or embellish it. They did not list the lower cruse RPM burn
    > performance.
    >
    > These do not have the coolers moved, they do not have any cowl
    > flap or the mods I have explained above.
    >
    > Aircraft Kit...............................Vans RV-8 (2004)
    > Engine Cowl Designer.......................Chris Armstrong
    > Engine Cowl Builder........................James Aviation
    > Engine.....................................Powersport Rotary
    > Propeller.................MT Model# 18B Electric Constant Speed
    > Hp.................................215 @ 6000 ERPM/2620 PRPM
    > FADEC System...............................Powersport
    > EFIS System................................Dynon Model D10
    > Nav & Eng Display..........................Powersport
    > 2:29:/ Reduction Gear Drive................Powersport
    > Interior Upholstery........................Classic Aero
    >
    > VNE 222 EW 1080
    > VSFR 57 MGW 1800
    > VSFE 53 Est. Time TBO 3000 HRS
    > Wt 1480# T/O Dist 191' @ SL (70degrees)
    > Acceleration Time.....1.8 sec. 2000 ERPM to 6000 ERPM
    > Initial Roc 90K 2750 FPM
    > Normal Climb 115K 1850 FPM
    > Time to Climb to 8,000'@1:15Kias.5 Min 7 Sec @ 1515lbs
    > Time to Climb to 10,000'@1:15Kias.6Min 47Sec @ 1515lbs
    >
    > Cruise @-------temp 68 degree F
    > @ 8000--65% 5100/2300rpm 150K 200Tas 10.4gph 19.23mpg
    > @12000--65% 5100/2300rpm 140K 200Tas 9.6gph 20.83mpg
    > @8000--75% 5400/2400rpm 156K 208Tas 11.2gph 18.58mpg
    > @12000--75% 5400/2400rpm 147K 210Tas 10.5gph 19.96mpg
    > @8000--85% 5700/2500rpm 159K 212Tas 11.9gph 19.82mpg
    > @12000--85% 5700/2500rpm 151K 215Tas 11.2gph 19.22mpg
    >
    >
    > N559 JC Jim Clark Owner/Builder
    > N838 SJ Jerry Gustafson Owner/Builder
    >
    >
    > Ray Richardson Owner Power Sport
    >
    > -------------------------------------------------
    >
    > Heck I would have needed to tape record the conversation :)
    >
    > Paul Lamar

   Ray,
   Thanks for that report, very complete and informative.
   I think Paul ( and others) were right to criticize the magazine
   article, but your report is much more informative. I feel the
   Rotary people are quite sensitive (and rightly so) to information
   being distributed, which puts a good product in a bad light.
   I am also pleased that Power Sport has re-evaluated their cooling
   system lay-out and is prepared to acknowledge improvements.
   Keep up the good work!
   George (down under)



I'm not sure I understand the conditions of the test.

Were both planes (the Lyc and rotary) supposed to hold the same speed
AND the same prop rpm?

If so then this is not a scientific test, nor comparing apples to
apples, because the plane with more powerful engine will have to
flatten its prop and waste a lot of gas to fly at the same speed.

If this is the way the test was run, it is ridiculous. Why would the
plane owner agree to this?

Regards,

Gordon.



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.