Subject: YELLOW JOURNALISM ! !!! Sport Aviation Magazine May 2006 (fwd)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/19/2006, 5:37 AM
To: AAme <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>, editorial@eaa.org

From "Powersport performance and fuel burn"

     > Vans chose the speed at 150 kts,
     > Vans decided the planes should fly at 2500 prop speed.
     > The Lycoming need the 2500 prop speed to reach 150 kts.
     >
     > The Powersport [p-port] engine RV's will fly their 150 kts at
     >  2100 prop speed.
     > Because the Powersport engine makes 450 lbs/ft of torque at the prop
     > at 2400 prop with the engine turning 5490 rpm, We CAN reduce the
     > prop speed to 2100 RPM And still out power the Lycom. Engines.
      snips.............
     > Ray  Richardson

Now that we know something about torque and HP we can make
a few calculations on what is going one here.

First the Power Sport PSRU gear ratio is 5490/2400 = 2.2875

HP = Torque X RPM /5250  =   450 ft# X 2400 RPM / 5250 = 206 HP

Assuming for the moment it is a completely flat torque curve
the Power Sport p-port engine is developing 180 HP at 4804 RPM.

450 ft# X 2100 RPM / 5250 = 180 HP. About right for 150 Kts or
172 MPH.

Sport Aviation article first paragraph page 36. Quote:
"All four airplanes took off and climbed at 130 Kts to
8500 feet  as a group. Once level the pilots switched tanks
and flew to Eugene, about 80 miles away and back. Over Aurora
everyone switched tanks and descended to land." Assume for
the moment Eugene was 80 nautical miles away and not statue
miles  that is 160 nautical miles distance or  1.06 hours
at 150 Kts.

At a BSFC of .47 and 180 HP that would be 84.6 pounds per hour or
14.1 gallons per hour. 1.06 hours at 14.1 gallons per hour is
15 gallons and not 7.8 gallons or 7.1 gallons as stated
in the article for the rotaries. Not possible.

For the Lycoming to do it while burning 5 gallons
an hour they would have to do it at 30 pounds of fuel per hour.
At 180 HP The BSFC would have to be 30/180 or .16 BSFC.
Totally and completely not possible. No way!

If you give them the benefit of the doubt and the assume
the Lycoming BSFC is an extraordinary .40 then the HP the
Lycoming powered airplanes generated flying to Eugene and back
was 30#/.4 or 75 HP. Equally not possible.

OK assume for the moment they made a typo error in
the chart and the rotaries burned 14 gallons an hour
which is about right for 180 HP and 150 kts. The Lycomings
burned 10 gallons an hour. The BSFC of the rotaries is .47 so
the BSFC of the Lycomings is then 10/14 X .47 or
.33!!! Totally and completely not possible as that is well
below the BSFC range of a diesel engine.

Check my arithmetic. Please!

Something is seriously SERIOUSLY wrong with this article.
It appears to me the numbers have been merely fabricated.
Shame on you Vans and shame on you EAA for not checking
the info.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.