Subject: YELLOW JOURNALISM ! !!! Sport Aviation Magazine May 2006 (fwd)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/20/2006, 9:07 AM
To: AAme


Paul, here is a note from a Subaru list that describes another
test that appears to have been handled differently.
Peter

Subject: Lyc comparison to Subaru

After reading about the Lyc to rotary comparison test in latest
Sport
Aviation, local Subaru enthusiast took his RV to Vans Aircraft
for same
tests. This is his report below. Couple comments: This Subaru is
same
engine I've been flying all these years, except he has added
supercharger. Supercharger is used to normalize pressure only, so
it's a
performance negative at sea level, an asset as you go higher. Too
bad
they didn't compare results at 12k ft. However, at 8k ft cruise,
the
Subaru used 2% less fuel....a wash in my opinion. Subaru has 1$
per
gallon economy advantage of burning auto gas.

-al

His report:

I took my plane to Van's last week for a head-to-head comparison
with their RV-9a.  Dick Reeves joined me for moral support.
Van's
plane, N129RV,  sports a Lycoming O-320-D1A and a 2-blade
Hartzell
CS prop.  Mine, N29GJ, an Eggenfellner Subaru 4-cylinder with
supercharger and 3-blade MT CS prop.  I weighed in at a
calculated
empty weight of 1183 lbs, which is 105 lbs heavier than Van's.
Two AP servos, 9 lbs ballast, a little extra paint and maybe 5 lbs in
the panel would account for about 1/3 of that.  I think the rest
is engine related  2nd battery, supercharger,  muffler.

It was a beautiful blue day.  In the 70's on the ground and 51 F
at 8000 feet by afternoon.  Ken Krueger was very thorough.  Both he
and Ken Scott were happy to have an Eggenfellner visit Van's in fact
several on the staff came out to welcome me.  Both Ken Scott and
Ken Krueger took short flights in the right seat and I think were
favorably impressed.

The purpose of the first flight was to make some qualitative
observations about 29GJ.  The plane was then fueled and weighed,
as was Van's plane.  Pilots were also weighed and Ken took on 35 lbs
of ballast to make up for his light lunches and bicycling habit.

The 2nd flight was a full-throttle maximum climb to 8000 feet AGL
pressure altitude (we set ground elevation of 200 ft to zero on
the
altimeter).  Timed from roll to 8000 ft was 6 min 9 sec for Ken,
and 6 min 40 sec for George.  A 2nd climb test later took 6:10 and
6:54.  So climb advantage went to Van's and the 105 lb difference
would, I think, accounts for much of the difference.  My IAS
isn't calibrated well and Ken tried to match my ground speed to yield a
fair comparison.  These climbs at 2700 rpm resulted in
temperatures as high as 236 F.  I always take off at 2500 rpm and
usually reduce to 2300 after 1000 feet, so don't usually see temps
above 200 F. Cruise temps are often right at 188 F, both oil
and coolant.

The next part of this flight was a 5 minute speed test full bore
at 8000 density altitude.  Ken gained about ½ mile on me and
registered 6 mph faster on the GPS (a one-time look).  The Subaru
consumed about 6% less fuel for this flight.

After returning for refueling and something to eat, we were back
in the air for the 3rd and last flight.  We did a  2nd climb test
and then a cruise to Eugene and back a side-by-side flight of about
170 miles round trip at 8000 density altitude.  I chose the speed
and went with 2300 rpm WOT on the outbound and 2000 rpm WOT for
the return.  We switched tanks to separate cruise efficiency from the
climb and descent.  The Subie used 2.5 % less fuel for this
flight. Interestingly,  the Subie used 8%  less fuel than the Lyc for the
climb & descent portion, but about 2% more for the cruise
portion.

Conclusions?  To me, the planes seemed remarkably well matched in
performance.  Horsepower from the 2.5 L engine/supercharger combo
pretty much matches the Lyc O-320 under 8000 feet and would yield
some advantage over a normally aspirated 160 hp Lyc above that
altitude.  I'm happy with the results and proud of my airplane.
Van's 9-a is a light little hot rod that took me (if only
slightly) in both climb tests and full-out speed.  If only I had
removed those tie-down rings..   And having to refill with 100 LL
at $4.00/gal reminded me of another reason I like my Eggaru.
It was a good day!

----------------------------------

Rather remarkable for a 152 cubic inch piston engine.
I don't understand why we don't see more of them at the air shows.
Perhaps they don't run them this hard and they are not good
cross country engines. I also wonder how many hours
they get before TBO.

Most auto piston engines are good for
about 300 hours in an airplane then they have a
catastrophic structural failure with out warning.
Usually a rod or crankshaft fails. A failed valve
will probably get you down safely.

You can't expect a
piston engine designed for 50 HP continuously to hold
up for 2000 hours at two to three times as much
HP under continuous use. You might get 600 hours if
aircraft quality materials were substituted for the major moving
parts. The aircraft piston engine is designed from
the get go to last 2000 hours at 75% max power.
The certified Thielert diesel is a good example of an auto engine
converted to AC use. 1200 hours and you are required to
throw it away. No over haul allowed. Also the Chevy big
block based Orenda V8, after about 30 years of  detailed
development, was granted  a TBO 1200 hours. Nobody wanted
a 1000 pound FWF $100,000 piston AC engine with a 1200 hour TBO.


The Mazda rotary is an exception as the type of reversing
stresses that cause metal fatigue are absent in the Wankel
design.

The test above is missing crucial speed numbers.
Prop RPM does not mean much as prop eff. varies widely.
3 blade props are usually better in climb.

Not bad performance. The engine temp difference is indicative
the pilot was pushing the airplane harder than he normally does.

"Supercharger is used to normalize pressure only, so
it's a performance negative at sea level, an asset as
you go higher." This statement does not make sense.
Normalizing means the power is the same at all altitudes.

Is he using a pressure relief valve? How would one
go about normalizing a supercharger with out a variable
speed gear drive or pressure relief valve?
How much boost was he using?

Are we going to see another article written by a Vans
employee in Sport Aviation?

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.