Subject: YELLOW JOURNALISM ! !!! Sport Aviation Magazine May 2006 (fwd)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/23/2006, 4:48 PM
To: AAme
CC: editorial@eaa.org



        Paul,

        I agree with you that the numbers given in the article are
   ridiculous. I
        also agree with your approach to solving for the fuel flow.

        However, to be completely precise one piece of information is
   missing:
        the exact amount of power required to push the RV8 through the
   air at
        the speed in question. You assumed in your example that it is
   180hp, but
        I suspect this amy be a little high.

        We know that in level flight thrust equals drag, so we can
   solve for the
        amount of power required if we know the amount of drag at the
   speed we
        are talking about.

        However, I wasn't able to find a drag curve of the RV8 (Drag
   Polar). I
        did find one for the RV6, but don't know how reliable it is.

        We can use these numbers from the graph for the RV6 and see
   what we come
        up with. We will use the formula for thrust horsepower:

        THP = Drag x Velocity,

        where Drag is in pounds and Velocity is in feet per second.
   Therefore:

        THP = D x (KTAS x6080/60) / 550

        Since horsepower is defined as 33,000 lb.ft./min, this equals 550
        lb.ft/second or 325.7 lb. x kt.

        This simplifies to THP = D x V / 325.7

         From the graph for the RV6 we see that a speed of 180 kt.
   gives a drag
        of about 200 pounds. So the power required is: 200 x 180 / 325.7 =
        110 hp.

        At a SFC of .47 that would give a fuel burn in pounds per hour
   of 51.9,
        or 8.65 gallons per hour. (I have to comment here that this
   seems like
        a very low fuel burn for 180 knots. I found this graph on a
   webpage that
        attributed it to a CAFE report in a 1993 issue of Sport Aviation).
        http://www.eaa1000.av.org/technicl/perfspds/perfspds.htm

        In any case, even if the chart is correct and an RV6 makes only
   200 lb.
        of drag at 180 kt., the above thrust horsepower calculation
   does not
        take into effect propeller efficiency. This is where I believe
   the big
        discrepancy is and how the test was tilted to favor the Lycoming.

        Like any wing, the propeller will have a certain angle of attack at
        which it is most efficient. Since the angle of attack of a prop
   depends
        on prop rpm, TAS, and diameter, prop efficiency will vary
   according to
        the ratio of these factors.

        The ratio: Velocity / rpm x diameter is the Advance Ratio:

        J = V/nD

        where J is the advance ratio, V is velocity in KTAS and D is prop
        diameter. The most efficient J depends on the prop blade angle.
   Course
        props (large blade angles) will be more efficient at larger advance
        ratios. Fine pitch props will be more efficient at small
   advance ratios.

        That is why the rotary was at a disadvantage in the test, which
   required
        the same cruise speed AND the same prop rpm. With its greater
   power the
        rotary was most efficient with its prop working at a course
   angle and
        lower rpm. But because the test stipulated that the plane had
   to be
        flown in the way that was most advantageous to the Lycoming, it
   skews
        the results.

        Another thing is the greater pumping losses from the engine at the
        higher rpm. Even at the same MAP setting, running the engine at
   higher
        rpm will use more fuel.

        The end result is that this "scientific test" is complete
   horseshit that
        was obviously planned carefully in advance to give a tilted
   outcome.
        This is just cheating, nothing else.

        Regards,

        Gordon.

        Power required = Drag x True Airspeed / 325.7

        Power required is also known as Thrust Horsepower

        -----------------------------------------------------


        Paul,

        In my previous message I forgot one crucial step, to convert
   from thrust
        horsepower to brake horsepower before solving for fuel flow.

        In the example using the drag number of 200 lb. at 180 kt. for
   the RV6
        we found that it takes 110 THP to move it through the air in level,
        steady flight.

        To find BHP we need to correct for prop efficiency, Neta, which is
        THP / BHP.

        If we assume a typical prop efficiency of 85 percent, we get
   129 BHP
        from the 110 THP we started with.

        At an SFC of .47, this works out to a fuel flow of 60.6 pounds or
        10.1gph, still very impressive for 180 knots true airspeed. I
   think that
        drag chart for the RV6 is a little optimistic (published in Sport
        Aviation, so take obligatory grain of salt).

        Just to further check this, I found a CAFE report on the RV8,
   which gave
        a fuel flow of 13.9 gph at 191 KTAS.

        Assuming an SFC of .47, we can calculate the thrust horsepower:

        SFC = FF / THP

        Therefore,

        THP = SFC / FF = .47 / (13.9 x 6) = 177.4

        Now we can figure out how high the prop efficiency is since we
   know the
        engine is 200 BHP.

        Since Neta = THP / BHP, we get:

        177.4 / 200 = .88

        This is pretty good prop efficiency, or maybe the Lycoming IO-200
        angle-valve in the VAN's prototype RV8 that was the subject of
   the CAFE
        test was hopped up a little and putting out more than 200 hp.

        We can also solve for drag, since:

        FF = SFC x THP = SFC x D x V / 325.7

        We can restate that equation to solve for drag:

        D = (FF / SFC) x 325.7 / V, which is the same as:

        D = THP x 325.7 / V

        So we get:

        D = 177.4 x 325.7 / 191 = 302.5

        That's the drag of the RV8 at 191 KTAS, 302.5 pounds.

        This is 100 pounds more than the graph I found for the RV6 at
   180 KTAS,
        which was also a CAFE report published in Sport Aviation. It
   seems to me
        that this confirms that the RV6 graph is a little optimistic.

        In any case, the thing to remember is the prop efficiency,
   which has a
        huge effect on fuel consumption. The attached graph for a
   McCauley 7557
        prop as used on some C-172s shows the correlation between prop
        efficiency and advance ratio.

        Notice that the prop reaches a peak efficiency of just over 80
   percent
        at an advance ratio of .7. And notice how the efficiency
   plummets as
        advance ratio decreases -- at an advance ratio of .2 the prop
   efficiency
        is below 40 percent.

        Remember that advance ratio, J, is Velocity divided by rpm times
        diameter, J = V / nD

        As n (rpm) increases, the ratio decreases. As the ratio
   decreases, prop
        efficiency nosedives.

        Van knew exactly what he was doing when he set up this test. By
   forcing
        the rotary to fly at the same speed AND rpm as the Lycoming
   ship, he
        knew the rotary would be running at a lower prop advance ratio
   and lower
        prop efficiency.

        This test was conceived very cleverly so the bigger engine and
   prop on
        the rotary would be giving up a lot of prop efficiency.

        This is simply a dirty trick and lousy cheating, nothing more.
   Of course
        this is what you get when you have a magazine that let's its
   advertisers
        write stories. Shame all around.


        Regards,

        Gordon.

        --------------------------------------------------

        Hi Gordon,

        The Vans article and chart says fuel burned for 160 N miles!
        It did not say fuel burned per hour. It did not specifically
        say at what speed HP or RPM the test was run at. It did say
        8500 feet. Ray Richardson gave us the other numbers from
        info he had.

        According to google it is 87 miles to Eugene from Aurora.
        Round trip would then be 174 miles.
        On 7 gallons that would be 25 MPG for the rotary.
        On 5 gallons that would be 35 MPG for the Lycoming
        I doubt seriously you could fly an RV8 at any speed
        HP or altitude with any prop that would yield 35 MPG.
        If that were the case max range for an RV8 with 42 gallons
        would then be 1470 Miles!!!!!! That is 50% greater
        than any GA airplane I can think of or find.

        BTW I would love to have any rotary powered airplane
        that got 25 MPG or a max range of 1050 miles.

        That is much much better than my C182 that gets
        13 MPG with twice the tankage (84 gallons) and about
        the same max range.

        Here is an RV8 performance chart from:

        http://www.pilotfriend.com/experimental/acft7/37.htm


        Paul Lamar

   I was going by the info that Ray gave: 150 kts and 2500 rpm.

   I assumed the 150 knots was indicated airspeed, which at 8500 feet on a
   standard day would give TAS of about 178 kt. I assumed this because it
   does not make sense that a 200 hp RV8 would need 2500 rpm to reach 150
   KTAS at 8500 MSL. This would be only 128 knots indicated at 8500 feet,
   which the RV8 could probably do at 2000 rpm.

   That's why I was using 180 knots true airspeed in the calculations. The
   point was to show what fuel burn we could expect from an RV8 using a Lyc
   IO-360 200hp, using known values for drag of an RV8. Obviously the fuel
   burn I showed in the calculations is far greater than that shown in the
   chart.

   Quite obviously the chart in the article is, at the very least, very
   confusing, or an outright mistake.

   But if the test was run at 150 knots true, let's see where that leaves
   us. Using the RV6 drag curve would give us a drag of 170 pounds at that
   speed. That means power required would be: 170 x 150 / 325.7 = 78 thrust
   horsepower.

   At a prop efficiency of 85 percent that would give us BHP of 92. At a
   SFC of .47 that gives fuel flow of 43 pph, or 7.2 gph. This is the fuel
   flow an RV6 with a Lyc would do at 150 kt. true at 8500 feet, so the RV8
   is probably not that far from that. (Assuming again the CAFE graph for
   the RV6 is correct.)

   So for the 160 nm trip in the article, it would surely take more than an
   hour's worth of fuel, depending on wind conditions. So that chart still
   doesn't make sense.

   It's obvious that EAA needs to print a clarification and correction
   that
   will explain all this. They should also print a full disclosure about
   the author being an employee of an advertiser and how that advertiser
   was given the prerogative to arrange the conditions for the "test."
   This
   is a journalism ethics issue.

   The clarification should also explain that the conditions chosen by the
   EAA advertiser (Van's) produced a tilted playing field against the
   rotary, in terms of fuel consumption, due to prop inefficiency at a
   higher than optimal cruise rpm. In order for the test to be fair, the
   planes should have flown at the same speed and distance, but allowed to
   adjust rpm to provide optimum efficiency for each respective ship. Only
   then could the test be said to be fair.

   If we take an auto analogy where we want to compare fuel mileage between
   two cars, do we insist that one of them cruises down the highway in 3'rd
   gear, while the other one is in overdrive? This is exactly the case
   with
   the rotary ship that had to flatten its prop to bring cruise rpm up to
   2500 -- it's like cruising in a lower gear.

   To be really fair, the magazine should revisit this issue in a future
   article, with a test set up completely fairly and which will let each
   plane perform to its maximum capability in all measured criteria.


   Regards,

   Gordon.

   -------------------------------------------------
   Lets simplify things. 180 SM at 180 MPH or
   or 1 hours. So the fuel burn is roughly 1 times the
   numbers in the chart? Let's say 7 gallons an hour for the
   rotary and 5 gallons and hour for the Lycoming. I don't think
   so at 180 MPH.

   Lets say they did it at 120 MPH or 1.5 hours.
   So the chart is not total fuel burned as stated in
   the chart  but the fuel burned per hour. So the rotary
   burned 10.5 gallons total and the Lyc burned 7.5 gallons
   total at 120 MPH?  Perhaps.

   Lets assume this was true and the chart was GPH.
   Lets say they both generated 100 HP doing it.
   BSFC for the rotary 42 pounds/divided by 100
   or a BSFC of .42. Wow! Nice but I don't think so.
   BSFC for the Lyc 30/100 = .3 double wow! No
   way in h***.

   No combination of speeds makes any sense what
   so ever out of what was actually stated in this article
   and in the chart.

   Taking the chart at face value the fact of the matter
   is no way is the Lyc going to get there at 38 MPG nor
   will the rotary get there at 27 MPG.


   Paul Lamar

--------------------------------------------------------

I didn't see that anyone here looked up how far it actually is between
EUG and UAO - it's 70nm each way, 140nm total (161sm).

The section of the chart relevant to this discussion says the Lyc's
burned an average of 5.25gal over the 140nm for 26.67nm/gal, or
30.67sm/gal.  The rotary powered airplanes burned an average of 7.475gal
for 18.73nm/gal or 21.53sm/gal.

I couldn't find any reference in the article to the speed flown for the
cruise portion of the test..

It's widely accepted that a 180hp Lyc O360 at 75% power will burn
10-10.5gal/hr.  75% of 180hp is 135hp.  If the BSFC is 0.47, that works
out pretty close..

From Van's website, the RV8 with 180hp, 75% cruise is 204mph (or 177KTAS).

Doing the math here says the fuel economy at 75% is 19.9sm/gal
(17.3nm/gal).  So clearly they weren't running 75% cruise settings.

The Van's site also lists 55% power cruise speed as 182mph (158KTAS).

Fuel flow at 55% should be around 7.75gal/hr (assuming the same
BSFC=.47).  That would give 55% fuel economy = 23.5sm/gal
(20.42nm/gal).  Hmm.  So they must have been really loafing.

Digging around, I found the previously mentioned mentioned CAFE report
for the RV8A - essentially the same airplane as "Tweety" from the SA
article:

http://cafefoundation.org/v1/aprs/RV-8A%20APR.pdf

Their chart (page 8/12) bottoms out at 182mph (the 55% power speed) and
25sm/gal, 7.2gal/hr.  Hmm.  Looks like the Van's published numbers are a
bit conservative.

One thing that's interesting about the CAFE scorecard is that on the
12000' DA test chart, the fuel economy actually starts to get worse when
slowed from a fuel flow of 6.7gph to 6.0gph.  Probably two factors here
- worse efficiency due to pumping losses from lowered manifold pressure,
and possibly higher induced drag from flying so slowly at altitude
(though TAS=180, IAS=145, which is hardly slow).

Going back to the 8000' DA chart, if we assume that we can extrapolate
out to slower airspeeds (ignoring the above paragraph), and we wanted
31sm/gal, we'd have to go down to a fuel flow of about 5.7gal/hr, and
TAS=172mph (IAS~=148mph).  Not totally unreasonable when eyeballing the
chart.  Would have to set a very low cruise RPM to not suffer pumping
losses.

Flying so slowly definitely favors these Lycomings against those
Powersports - one of the Lyc's has manual mixture control, which should
allow it to run quite a bit better fuel flow.

It would be interesting to know what power setting everybody typically
uses on RV8s.  I know that I usually run much less than 75% in my 182 -
WOT above 6000 MSL, 2300RPM (cause it's quieter, and cheaper).


Regards,

Matt-

----------------------------------------------
I had a telacom with Tracy this morning on the subject.
In all the years he has been going to OSH from Bell Florida
starting in 1995 he typically stops for fuel in Indiana
or Illinois. He has stopped in Evansville Ind several times.

Bell Fl. to Evansville Ind. according to google is 700 SM.
The RV4 tank holds 32 gallons. Tracy trys to stop for auto
fuel when he is down to 28 gallons or so. He knows how much
is left by how much he has to put in. 700/28 is
25 MPG. He trys to cruise at 12,500 to 14,500 feet
at 175 MPH TAS.

Time in flight is therefore about 4 hours or 7 gallons an hour.
Taxi, climb and descend perhaps several times to clear clouds
would add to the flight time.

If the flight time is 4.5 hours the fuel burn is 6.2 gallons
per hour. I forgot to ask him the exact flight time.

He figures his engine HP is right around 77  HP at
175 MPH. Sounds low to me but I have no experience
flying RV4's

Quote:
"My EM2 reads out directly in MPG so its easy to see
under all conditions.  Best case is ~30 MPG at 6 GPH
at 12,500 - 14,500, TAS 175 mph." That would be a BSFC
of about .47.

7 gallons an hour is 42 pounds of fuel an hour average
so BSFC is 42/77 or .54 for the whole trip given 4 hours.

6.2 gallons an hour is 37.5/77 or .48 BSFC given 4.5 hours.

The RX8 engine is leaned to about 150 degrees lean of
peak but it will run to 200 degrees lean of peak.
EGT's for the RX8 engine run 1250 to 1450 F and 1450
to 1500  F for the old engine.

Tracy's computer can be manually leaned to 33% lower than
stoichiometric and 50% higher than stoichiometric mixture.
He says he needs that much mixture range particularly on
the lean side.

This is year in year out experience for eight or nine
years running.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.