Subject: Why the stock TC turbines won't fail.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/25/2006, 6:46 AM
To: AAme


Hi Paul,

Read your paper about your turbo compound project - very impressive.
Clearly a lot of thought (and work)  has gone into the project.  It
would certainly be a boon to the airborne rotary to see such a project
reach commercial viability.

About the only thing that caught my attention as a potential downside is
the use of the stock Mazda Turbo.  I am personally aware of at least 5
cases where the turbine wheel section has malfunction in aircraft
usage.  I suspect that the turbo was simply not designed to handle boost
for considerable periods as might be used in aircraft and may have also
encounter "over speed" conditions at altitude.  You are probably aware of
these failures, but thought I would mention it.

I would think the mechanical coupling from the turbocharger shaft to the
output gear box assembly might pose a few challenges, but, of course,
that is what a project uncovers.  Nice CAD drawings and impressive
machine work in the photos.

Only other thing I could  think of is that it might be useful to provide
a couple of examples of the calculations you made to arrive at the % of
efficiency increase - that is one thing any critic is going to
potentially challenge.

Good luck in your efforts, Paul.  Certainly a significant undertaking
with obvious benefits, I would like to hear how things work out when you
get your prototype together and running.

Best Regards

Anonymous



Not the full paper. Just the abstract.

Yes we know about that. I figured out what the problem
is. I got a clue by calculating the centrifugal loads
on the blades as a function of TC RPM. The loads become
enormous at 80,000 RPM and above. The Wankel exhaust
heat is only a part of the problem. The turbocharger
turbines are indeed coming apart due to over speed. The
compressors are not coming part because they do not also
have to deal with the Wankel exhaust heat as well.

The automotive turbo charger turbine is over designed,
HP wise, for one simple reasons. It needs to accelerate
itself rapidly due to the acceleration demands of the car.
Cars engines never sustain max power for very long.
Basically the turbine over drives the compressor.
Consequently the turbocharger turbine never runs for long at
over speed RPM. Here is chart of the situation.

Turbines have max torque at zero RPM. The torque
falls off in a straight line  as the turbine blades
approach the Wankel exhaust gas velocity.
This causes the HP to increase to a point and then fall
off. In an automotive turbo charger the compressor size
relative to the turbine size is chosen to be such
that the turbine HP is always way more than enough
to provide the boost required at steady speed.
You can see this relationship in the second chart.
The waste gate and back pressure of the muffler system
serves to limit the boost for the brief period of
time the automotive engine is generating max HP.

The bottom line is if you want the stock TC turbine to
live in aircraft service you merely load it down with a
larger compressor. Exactly what Dave Leonard did. Now what
loads it down even more is connect it to the eccentric
shaft through a gear box and drive belt to take advantage
of all that excess turbocharger turbine HP. The turbo
compound configuration.

---------------------------------------------------------

I plotted another larger compressor load curve dropping the
max RPM from about 95,000 RPM curve A to 85,000 RPM curve B.
Since centrifugal loads are proportional
to the RPM squared the loads on the blades are reduced
by 20%. This is handy to know if you are building a  turbo
charged aircraft engine. The ideal would be a further
increase in the size and load of the compressor section
so the curve intersected the HP curve at it's peak
reducing the RPM to half and the turbine blade loads to
about 25% of what they are in a the automotive turbo charger.

Now all we need do is get some data on compressor loads
verses RPM's from the turbo charger manufacturer. That may
not be easy to do.

This is an easy and cheap way to turbo charge
your 13B. In the model years 1989 to 1991 the turbocharger
on the RX7 Turbo II model is near ideal except for the
compressor section. It is fairly easy to change out the
compressor with no other mods made. Also trimming the turbine
will work reducing its ability to generate HP if you wish
to do that. That is probably the cheapest way to go.

However if you want to eventually apply the turbo compound
principle keep the turbine the same and change out just the
compressor section. Keep the old compressor section as it
is ideal for the turbo compound configuration if and when
that becomes available.


Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.