Hi Paul,
I called Sven Nielsen up a few hours ago and spoke with him for 45mins.
He is no slouch and is quite knowledgeable about seals and coatings. This
of
course is the opinion of someone who isn't:) But I know human nature and
when he realized you weren't going to bite him he opened up and shared a
lot
of information.
Yes he does have the seal edges radiused and no he doesn't have glass
fiber
in the ceramics. He did say that there are many many types of Silicon
Nitride out there and the maker he has located has provide a product he
feels is superior to Iannetti. Sven mentioned on his two piece design he
copied Mazda older seals used on the rotary trucks because it was more
appropriate for use with ceramics. Basically that design as you know has
the long piece stretching all of the way across the rotor housing and the
tip is ground flat. The wedge part rides underneath. He explained in
detail
to long to write about why this method is superior to Iannetti's seals.
Basically ceramics don't like sharp points.
Ceramics are lighter than iron so spring pressure had to be increased and
his spring surfaces have been ceramic coated to make the wear
characteristics closer to the seals
He has developed several other proprietary chrome as well as ceramic
coating techniques as well.
On the RX-7 discussion groups he is know as GlassMan.
He invented the Cermet process and is aquainted with Ron at Pineapple
Racing. Supposedly Ron coated the housing too thick once and instead of
bringing the housings back to him to redo, the owner went somewhere else
and
ground the coating down to paper thickness. This resulted in flaking.
Another point is that Sven applies the coatings using a compression
technique while Ron was using a technique putting the coating in
tension.??????
No details on this topic except a coating under tension tends to widen any
developing cracks.
Puerto Ricans are running 40psi boost with his seals and they are holding
up
under detonation events. Side housing seal clearances are set according
to
amount of boost.
One interesting piece of info. In Aussieland an one (1) rotor engine was
putting out 300hp on tremendous boost and detonating constantly. One
seal
did crack in the middle but the engine continued to be used. In his
opinion side wall clearance is very important and the lack of clearance is
usually what causes seals to disintegrate.
He said at a group buy we could purchase a set of his Grey seals for
around
$955.
He has heard of different techniques for installing P-ports like screwing
them in, pressing them in, gluing them in and even TIG welding them in.
He said and Mazdatrix confirmed that the Renesis rotors installed in a 13B
would be fine except for the side seals. They are too sloppy in
clearance.
As much as 0.002" We discussed the possibility of ceramic coating them
to
build them up a little and this was my suggestion and reflects zero
knowledge on if that is even a good idea. To his credit he did say "I
don't
know" to several of my questions, or "You will have to test it"
He thinks the one or two piece 3mm seal would be fine for the Renesis
rotors.
He has been in business 7 years and all sales have been by word of mouth.
Recently a production bottleneck of radiusing the seals sharp edges by
hand
has been overcome by a local company being able to do the job with a new
machine allowing 150 seals to be radiused in one night.
He has no sales into Japan that he knows about as yet although Aussies are
a
big market. About aftermarket seals he agrees with you. There is a lot of
crap out there. Some seals from Aussie turn into bananas quickly. He
wasn't
surprised when I mentioned about the chatter marks on Dave Leonard's
engine.
I told him that because of your experience with so many people buying
inferior 2nd party seals you were quite leery about people claiming that
had
a good product. I said that basically you were a nice guy who gets
grumpy
sometimes when he doesn't have enough bran in his diet. HA HA! Just
kidding .... about the bran:)
What else is new????? Like you I am working to finish the front bathing
room. Endless....... Jeez the common trap of husbands huh? Our thought
processes go something this this. "No problem honey, contractors are so
expensive and you have to watch them like a hawk" and "Compared to an
airplane building the house is a cinch." And the famous last words "I can
do this"
Have a great escape to OSH.
Doug
Doug,
One way around the side seal clearances is to put in bigger corner seals.
George ( down under)
"side wall clearance is very important and the lack of clearance is
usually what causes seals to disintegrate."
"bigger"? Longer or larger in diameter?
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.