Subject: More sad news
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/22/2006, 1:04 PM
To: AA-me


> Hi Russell;
> > Sorry about the late response.
> Initially, information was scant..., the family wanted their privacy
> and the our chapter exec was busy contacting friends.
> > The preliminary NTSB report is available at:
>    http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?ev_id=20060804X01093&key=2
> It tells most of the tale.  The picture posted the other day as well.
> > An early account, with pictures of the accident now removed:
> http://www.vansairforce.com/community/showthread.php?t=9638
> > Gary was a friend and I was with him most of Osh week - I still get
> mad
> when I think about
> the stupidity of the accident.  Particularly, with some of the early
> "witness" reports on Vans.
> > If there is anything else, I can be reached offline at:
> cbeazley@innovista.net
> > Cheers
> Cary

Cary,
Thanks for the links.  I had already read the NTSB report, but there are
two important points in it.

The first is that the EAA video team has the accident on tape.  This is
much better than eyewitness reports.

The second was this closing "gem":
> An EAA official reported that the aircraft taxiing on Papa taxiway
> between the P-1 taxiway and Tower Road taxiway are not controlled
> by ATC ground control or by EAA marshallers.

The following is MY OPINION and not necessarily that of the EAA's.
As reported in the NTSB report, I believe that statement is simply not
true.  The pilots have the ultimate responsibility for the safe
operation of their aircraft on the grounds. HOWEVER, the EAA has
delegated the safe movement control to us, the marshallers. This is
evidenced by the marshallers authority (as granted by the FAA & EAA): we
marshallers can shutdown any aircraft on the EAA grounds at anytime.

I work in the south half of the field (aka "Antique/Classic" or "Vintage
aircraft"). This accident occurred in the north half (aka "General
Aviation & Warbirds").  I take no consolation in that. The immediate,
and incorrect, reaction would be to proclaim that "it wouldn't happen in
*MY* area." (I'm sure there's some psychological reason for such
feelings.)

It should be obvious that everyone involved believed they were managing
the danger: the Avenger pilot believed that his limited forward
visibility and limited S-turns were enough, the RV pilot believed that
the aircraft behind him could see him, the marshallers believed that the
Avenger pilot could see where he was going, the EAA believed the
marshallers could prevent ground accidents, the FAA believed the EAA
possessed ground control operations capable of maintaining safety. This
accident clearly demonstrates that all of those parties were mistaken.

It will be interesting to see what action, if any, the EAA or FAA takes
in response to this accident. I know *I* am taking action, by asking my
fellow instructors these questions:
- What can we do to prevent this from re-occurring?
- Where else might we have false beliefs?
- What should we do about them (if anything)?

Russell Kent

War Birds are not homebuilt or experimental aircraft.
Lets keep them out of the EAA.

Paul Lamar



As we've seen on the past decade or two, Mr. Poberezny and the brass have
created BIG Business out of EAA. This fact was driven home to me in 1995
when they celebrated the end of W.W.II and they also blocked all sales of
Kodak film on the grounds with an exclusive contact with Fuji of Japan due
to the slightly higher sales margins offered if they did this. I spoke
with Paul Poberezny face to face at the show because I was amazed with the
irony of this while the celebrations of defeating Japan 50 years before...
As I spoke to him, Yellow and white Kodak film golf cart went by with the
green Fuji logo taped half over the Kodak....  Paul was sympathetic, but
said Tom was in charge and I should write him a letter. I did and never
got a response.

War birds are a big money draw for this cash cow. I would venture to say
Tom & company are making a simple risk (as in legal cost) / benefit (as in
increased show revenue) of keep the mix the same... For this reason, I
also think they pay their fuel bills at the show.

-dave


-- 
Best Regards /Mit freundlichen Gruessen,
  dave ( at ) arb.net http://arb.net


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.