Subject: Tension bolt break and after market apex seals.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/23/2006, 8:39 PM
To: AA-me



Here is a picture of Perry's rotor housing we took out of
the above junk yard engine with 165 hours in the air. Obviously
it had stock Mazda apex seals. I would not hesitate to put
this rotor housing back in a rebuilt engine. First picture.

Second picture is a rotor housing that
had only three hours on it with after market apex seals.


BTW The black carbon deposits are normal when running ordinary engine
oil to lube the seals. When 2 cycle oil or synthetic oil is mixed
with the fuel you don't get these deposits. They can be removed
with Scotch Bright and MEK solvent. Perry's rotor houseings had
very little carbon but I removed it with Scotch Bright anyway.



Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
H

Hi Paul,
I have often thought about that LeMans engine going round and round at
full bore for 24 hours and after tear down, finding negligible wear. how
can we improve on that?
So set me straight, (again). After all the discussion these past few
years on seals;   ceramic, Hurleys, lanettis(?) RWS, and lord knows who
else, are you back to recommending stock Mazda factory apex seals for
airplane engines?

BR, Dave McC (still collecting the gospel)

Absolutely. Mazda knows what they are doing and they know far
far more about it than anyone else will know in the foreseeable
future. Laser heating and liquid nitrogen chilling of special
alloy cast iron for %^$^& sakes.

I was just thinking about this and wondered why the rotor
housing chrome plating could sustain a groove, caused by a junk
after market tool steel crude apex seal with a horrible surface
finish, without the chrome flaking off. IMHO the secret is the chrome
is porous on a microscopic level to hold oil and the tiny chrome
particles are sticking to the mild soft steel liner despite the
severe deformation.

The modulus of elasticity of cast iron is half that of tool
steel and the damping is much higher. It is widely known that
cast iron piston rings work well in steel bores. Apparently
the cast iron is porous enough to retain lubricant. I am certain
this is a factor in chatter marks. Think of a cast iron bell and
a hard steel bell. Which will have a higher pitch and ring
longer when struck? Jeff Spitzer who converted a OMC
single rotor air cooled rotary to a water cooled 2 rotor rotary
told us six years ago tool steel will not work. Too harsh
on the rotor housing. Jeff is now chief engineer on the
Predator UAV.

Obviously the people selling these apex seals failed
to educate themselves on exactly what Mazda went through
over the past 40 years and they were arrogant enough to think
they could do it better. They failed miserably.

I added a section to the web site on this subject.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/seals.html

What is really pissing me off is there are a bunch of engines
out there with these crude apex seals that are going to give the
rotary engine a bad name.


Proved ceramic apex seals excepted.
Here is a scan from the Mazda Lemans tech paper on that subject.


Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.