Subject: Rotary Power to Weight Max HP
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/1/2006, 10:33 AM
To: AA-me


    Hi Gordon,

    Firstly, Paul is absolutely correct that you cannot extrapolate RX-8 or
    other normally aspirated engine data to high-boost because of the
    change in
    compression ratios.  Also don't forget to increase boost to
    compensate for
    high intake air temperature, later than optimal ignition timing and
    richer
    than optimal mixture (both for detonation protection), etc

    Secondly, my boost-level guesstimate was based on 13B geometry and
    6500RPM.
    I have no personal experience with P-ported engines so will not take
    make
    any estimate or comment on these engines.  But I agree, I may have been
    pessimistic...

    Turbochargers won't take the punishment of unlimited aerobatics,
neither
    will (probably) high-spinning centrifugal superchargers. I do not
    know about
    twin-screw chargers...

    Finally, an unlimited aerobatic airplane needs full power for very
    limited
    periods and only makes short flights (except for ferrying).  Various
    solutions that Mistral doesn't even consider for its applications may
    therefore be open.  I shall not comment on things I only know
    second-hand.

    Francois


    Thanks, Francois.

    That's a good point about the g-loads on the supercharger. The Russian
    radials use gear-driven centrifugal blowers and they seem to be pretty
    robust.

    http://www.russianaeros.com/Future%20for%20M14P%20engines.htm

    I don't know how the screw compressors will stand up, but they spin
much
    slower, so centrifugal force is much smaller to begin with. The Lysholm
    blower sized for this engine output would spin at about 8000 rpm. Drive
    ratio from the engine would only be about 1.2 to 1. Hopefully it
    should not
    be a problem as these units are pretty robust, with large bearings,
    etc.

    I agree the challenge will be juggling compression ratio, boost, intake
    temperature, fuel octane, etc.

    Ideal fuel would be ethanol, which has almost three times higher
    latent heat
    so evaporative cooling would be much better. It also burns cooler,
    so total
    heat produced would be less. Not to mention much higher octane, so
    higher
    compression and better power. Hmm, I think I've convinced myself ...
    I grow
    a bit of corn on the farm anyway...

    But the thing is where do you get ethanol at an airport?

    There is an interesting option, using ethanol injection for knock
    suppression. I've attached a paper that gives great info on this. Their
    objective was from an automobile fuel-efficiency standpoint using
    smaller,
    highly boosted engines. It requires only a small tank for ethanol. I
    don't
    think I would try to scratch-build such a system myself, but if someone
    where to come up with a bolt-on product, it would sure make things
    interesting.

    My approach with a draw-through, carbureted engine will still give good
    results, I believe. This is the approach used on the Russian radials --
    although some of the high-power versions now have EFI.

    At stoichiometric ratio, the evaporative cooling at the carb is a
    temperature drop of about 40 F. That means that on a 72 F day the
intake
    charge coming into the compressor will be 32 F. At a pressure ratio
    of 1.7,
    the charge temperature coming out of the blower would be 160 F (71 C.)

    I think that's doable on 100 LL and reasonable ignition timing. I
    think this
    boost ratio (1.7, or 10 psi) is probably the maximum. That would be a
    manifold pressure of about 51 inches.

    The question is will that give 300 hp net? Maybe not, as you
    mentioned, for
    reasons of higher intake air temp, less ignition advance, etc. The
    Lysholm
    blower will draw about 33 hp to make that boost.

    Btw, I am not thinking P-port because what's the point when you have
    boost?
    Plus it looks to interfere with coolant passages.

    Also I would prefer the RX8 engine because I think the side exhaust is
    better for cooling too. I could be wrong on these points, as I am just
    guessing.


    Regards,

    Gordon.




Just want to back up on this discussion for one point..

Why would side exhaust be better for cooling?  Seems like it would
increase the cooling load - more heat transfered to the housings.
Wouldn't the extra heat have to be removed by the coolant/oil?


Regards,

Matt-


True Matt. What I think he meant was better for exhaust pipe
cooling. The EGT on the RX8 engine runs a couple of hundred
degrees F cooler than the RX7 engines. That lost heat goes into
the liquid cooling system of course.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Matt,

I assumed -- correctly it turns out -- that the exhaust would be cooler on
the RX8, therefore the exhaust manifold would not need to be as heavy.

I also assumed that with the exhaust going out the cast iron side housings,
there would be less heat transferred to the aluminum rotor housings. My fear
is that the aluminum rotor housings are the bottleneck, in terms of
conducting heat, and could see localized hot spots at high power levels
because there is not enough metal to conduct away the heat to the coolant
quickly enough. That may or may not be true at the power level I am talking
about, but I'm sure it's true at some power level.

I actually didn't think of your point that the extra heat absorbed by the
cast iron housings would add to the cooling load. This is true of course,
but I am not worried about hot spots in the cast iron. Its greater molecular
mass will conduct more heat than aluminum, given the same cross section.

Regards,

Gordon.

No I don't think so Gordon. The term "conduct" is the problem.
There is no doubt aluminum conducts heat better than cast iron.
I am no thermo guy so I am not sure about its ability to "store"
heat however.

BTW there is an Inconel liner in the p- exhaust port that
effectively insulates the aluminum rotor housing from  most
of the exhaust heat.

The same liners are found in the RX8 side exhaust ports but there
is no doubt about the fact the RX8 EGTs are lower.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.